Ask HN: How do you decide when to stick with a project

2 points by mjs06 ↗ HN
I always tend to pivot whenever I encounter a dead end or believe that the value I saw when starting the project is no longer there, and I shouldn't waste my time continuing with said project. I guess what Im trying to ask is, is cutting off my project early whenever I feel like it is the smart thing to do or should I continue until Im certain that whatever my project is the end goal is not feasible/realistic.

10 comments

[ 6.9 ms ] story [ 94.4 ms ] thread
When was the last time you started and finished a project?
Other than very simple projects, don't really remember.
I guess what Im trying to ask is, is cutting off my project early whenever I feel like it is the smart thing to do or should I continue until Im certain that whatever my project is the end goal is not feasible/realistic.

That depends on why you're doing the project.

If you're doing it to learn something, and you've learned it, then quitting early makes sense.

If you're doing it for fun, and it's not fun any more, then quitting early also makes sense.

If you're doing it because you want to make millions, but you haven't proven the idea yet, quitting doesn't make sense. Also, going to market is scary and expensive, so are you just avoiding that pain? It's very common to quit just as things get hard.

In retrospect, most of my projects start with learning as the goal, since I'm young and just trying things out.But whenever I feel that one of them may have value I get stuck (probably out of fear) when I need to go to market, which makes me believe the value I once saw is no longer there , so I pivot and start over again.
I am at this exact stage. It turned out that building was the easiest part. I tried to promote consistently for months and I am barely at 45 signed-up users. It feels super good to get every new user, believe me. What helps me decide is a clear deadline. Mine is the end of the year, so I gave myself almost half a year to try to get users. Until then I use every promotion channel I can. From brochures to Reddit.
(comment deleted)
I am sure if MVP + google ads have no ROI at least 30% then project will not be profitable. In the last 5 years i tried to polish and polish more than 10 projects which had no success in MVP and all polishing gave maybe +20-30% ROI in the best way. It was mobile games, apps, web services, utilities, there is no way to make successful project from useless MVP. Also i had 4 not so bad and 1 good result project, all of them had more than 60% ROI already in the simplest MVP with a few main features and many many bugs.