81 comments

[ 8.5 ms ] story [ 115 ms ] thread
One of Australia's two major supermarkets, fyi. If customer data has leaked, it's likely a significant percentage of all Australians.

Of course at this point, what's left to leak? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

> Of course at this point, what's left to leak?

Your condiments and your condom size!

they must be after their fridges
♩♪♫♬ Down, Down, the p̶r̶i̶c̶e̶s̶ fridges are down ♬♫♪♩
...and sugar we're going down glued to our screens.
Ha, it was a reference to an annoying jingle from ad campaign Coles ran, based on the Status Quo song.
I took a calculated risk assuming there was a high chance I was wrong because I think it still works :D
Just to annoy the non-Australians - Status Quo filmed a studio recording version of Down Down (Prices Are Down), complete with guitars shaped like Coles Down Down signs, and the drummer trying to play while wearing Coles Big Red Hands. It's on the official Status Quo YouTube channel:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XB383WkXcqE

"And when you need a helping hand / Count on the savings of that Coles big red hand"

Another day, another breach.
Imagine the country Australia could have been if it wasn't continuously intentionally stunted by willfully ignorant "leaders"
That's by design. Australia was set up for wealth extraction (mostly resources) by financial interests overseas, mostly Anglo/American.
I wonder what made them involve ASCS. It looks like personal data was not accessed and there was no availability issue. They're not a part of Critical Infrastructure as far as I understand, so they'd only need to report to OAIC.

(Unless it's "just in case")

They are part of Critical Infrastructure, so I'd say it was under those requirements in addition to a just in case
ACSC has also become the Centrelink* of incident response.

Companies who should’ve had retainers with IR firms, and a proper plan to respond to a major incident go crying to the government for help when they get popped.

* For non-Australians, Centrelink is the agency that handles social security payments.

Anyone thinking this is a bit of a useless post? It offers absolutely no detail about about what has actually happened. I understand it is early days and they're no doubt performing an investigation, but this post may as well read, 'Somewhere, something happened. Maybe?'.

The FAQ is just variations of 'We dunno'.

To anyone in Australia - this is potentially massive, they're one half of a nationwide supermarket duopoly. We'd all have shopped at Coles at some point, probably in the last week, even the existence of a breach there is major news for us.

To anyone else - yeah, it's just another data breach.

I mean, I'm in Australia and shop at Coles on occasion. I understand Coles scale.

However, the post doesn't actually say what has happened other than that there has been 'a cyber security incident' and that they 'have not identified any evidence that customer, team or supplier data has been compromised or removed from Coles’ systems'. Given that, what has actually happened? The post has nothing to say about that.

Not in Australia, so it's been a decade since I shopped at Coles.

However, the situation is not better anywhere else. They all collect more data than I want and security is a joke in most businesses.

I have revived paying by cash. I avoid shopping online wherever I can. My card statements are really short thes days.

> I have revived paying by cash

Cash plus gift cards for me. Gift cards can be bought anonymously and stored on your phone under the very nice FOSS app Catima, so a little bit more convenient than cash in some ways.

I had a good chuckle at the gift card FAQ entry. It really shows what they think the communication priorities are even during an incident.
Gift cards are their golden goose so they don't want to undermine confidence in them. They deliver the most profitable use of floor space per square metre in a supermarket.
MSFT was in We dunno mode for couple days mate :)

so this post is good I'd say - to at least know about this ! I didn't, so now I'm keen to find out more

They say I have to change password. Do they store passwords in clear? What century is it?
If you've hashed a password, even with a high-cost algo.. eventually (with all the resources in the world) someone can determine what it was (or they might get lucky with password lists or rainbow tables). Especially if the salt was stored in the database too, or if the pepper (if you believe in it) could have been captured in the incident.

A password is a shared secret.. as soon as someone else might be able to repeat the secret - change it.

All breaches, whether or not data was affected, should recommend rolling secrets. It is the reasonable thing to do, "just in case".

So its pretty standard copytext.

What is the motivation for these companies to have better cybersecurity? It seems like they get away with basically doing bare minimum, and when an incident happens it doesn't affect them at all. It makes companies spending the money on security teams and the time/effort of having good processes look like just a waste.
This has really always been the case, but AI is supercharging this in the sense that if you get hacked now just shrug and say "Well, what are you gonna do against all this AI?" and you basically have a get out of jail free card on culpability.
Cybersecurity is a cost. If it works, the CEO never knows about it.

In August Coles fired 1000 local backoffice staff and offshored the jobs via Accenture to save costs.

The Accenture staff on this, ain't offshored.

We're in Melbourne and Ballarat.

Insurance requirements, and an arguable measure of due diligence to non-tech types in leadership and board.
Won't happen with the Australian supermarket duopoly, both Coles and Woolies are so large they self insure.
I've been through a fair bit of this with "due diligence for non tech types" in Australia and it consistently involves paperwork exercises that noone outside the board room and one report writer ever sees or does anything with.

Which lends to the point that it's not doing much to encourage security.

It’s cheaper to just rebuild the cottages after the hurricane. Except that’s becoming less true each year.

In this analogy the role of AI will be played by climate change.

When you're one of the two largest supermarkets in the country you'd need a fairly big cyber attack for it to actually hurt your bottom line and/or your customers.

If all of your fridges got taken offline pushing customers to Woolworths or other supermarkets you might be motivated to do something about it.

Outside of your customers walking away and potentially insurance, there really isn't any other incentive

A lot of stock and food went to waste recently in Europe when their fridges and freezers were hacked. Coles also has a lot of those.

I would say they have a pretty big incentive.

It does effect them.

Minister/CEO/General's grandma gets scammed, then suddenly there is an emergency meeting on Security. Tale as old as time.

Only detail seem to be

> We are aware of a small number of customers experiencing issues with Liquorland click-and-collect, and we are investigating.

Shit mate I didn’t realise it was that serious!
Ok, now I see why the government needed to be involved.
Is this because someone mistyped the prices of slabs of premixed drinks again?
I interviewed here a few years back. One of the interview questions was if a junior submitted a very bad PR what would you do? I told them we could review and leave comments on all the shortcomings or ask how we arrived here in the first place. Did we set the hiring bar too low, did we properly describe acceptance criteria for this ticket, do we have good onboarding and style guides, do we pair our juniors with more experienced teammates. Seemed like they didnt like that answer.
Coles is a supermarket in Australia, so it's not relevant to most people outside of Australia as most people will have never heard of it.

This post offers zero detail about what actually happened. Can the submission be replaced with another link explaining with what actually happened?

(comment deleted)
They got hacked, lawyers were called, they posted vague statements.

The equivalent of “smile and wave, smile and wave”.

My money is on the group that hacked them to publish more information.

Until this post I didn't know what Coles is. It was entertaining though, the whole way down to here.
why replace anything ? he posted, we can add stuff here, as we go
Piece of shit monopolist company that has been successfully fined by the regulator for price fixing and deceptive practices dozens of times over the past decade also has an incompetent tech security team.

More at 7.

Also, lol at these dipshits doing facial recognition at all Coles and Coles affiliates. Lmao even. This is why people lost their shit when that stuff was announced.

Cybersecurity is a bit of a joke in Australia. Australia's medicare system was "hacked" by agents (the medicare system had unauthenticated endpoints for over 10 years, but it suited authorities to blame "AI" as it deflected responsibility and demonised tech to garner support for regulation) [0], and a big company/govt org being breached every 6 months or so has become a regular occurrence [1] e.g. Optus, St Vincent’s, the Australian Federal Police (!), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Pizza Hut, the Royal Women’s Hospital, Latitude Financial etc.

[0] https://therecord.media/openai-australia-breach-cyber

[1] https://www.choice.com.au/data-protection-and-privacy/protec...

Cybersecurity seems to mean watching a silly childish Huntress training cartoon video each month to tick off the box for cyber insurance.

For a lot of places, security is a box ticking exercise playing lip service, not actually doing security in the spirit of good security

The Huntress can be bypassed thanks to the absurdity of the multiple-choice quiz questions (with infinite retries). E.g.

Bob receives an email marked 'URGENT' requesting he log in to an external site so he can be paid. Should he:

A) Visit the site and enter his email and password asap

B) Enter his credentials and follow up by sending his credit card details for good measure

C) Douse his computer in kerosine, set it alight and run out of the building screaming

D) Report the suspicious email to the security team

This is the same for the Mimecast cyber training.
Bob's Security (yes thats their name) forced you to click on 1 pixel wide lines to to show that you had actually read everything. There was like 6 of them you had to click to be allowed to go on.

These days i make it a competition with colleges of who can do all the trainings in one sitting the fastest.

The answer is clearly C, I don't know how anyone fails these.
I don't want to speak for nomilk, but for those not familiar with the Australian vernacular: the idiom "a bit of a joke," in this context, is a low-key understatement best translated as "a complete and utter shitshow of epic proportions."
The royal women's hospital IT is a joke, they rebranded a few years ago to Digital Innovation and their support staff to "Tech Innovators" or something equally idiotic.

They rolled out a new pay system in 2022 which is a big ugly Silverlight application that sneakily launches Edge in compatibility mode that mimics IE6.

Silverlight was discounted in 2021.

Edit: they were running exchange server 2013 up until 2023 I think.

Other dumb shit they've done: they run Cisco umbrella which resigns all certificates. Took me a month to workout why my tools complaining of SSL issues. Theyve changed twice without informing anyone.

They only just this year locked Ethernet ports, you could just plug any machine in to access this network and internet.

I would suggest government is a bit of a joke in Australia; we haven't really had one since the mid-90s.
Probably have the Libs to thank for that (the right-wing party in Australia for those that don't live here). Otherwise we have had NDIS and NBN since the 90s. Say what you will about the former, but the latter has ended up pretty decent.
"ended up pretty decent" is debatable. The process and politics around it was farcical, and the sell-off of Telstra was a debacle.
Unrelated, I love that Australia around 12pm AEST has enough readers of hacker news to upvote a useless post like this, that would normally be downvoted to oblivion. Yet here it is at #4.
Security is an illusion. This is not news. This is business as usual. This is expected. This is accepted. When are we all going to realize there is no such thing as security on the internet. If you are still shocked when you hear about yet another breach of 30 million accounts, I'd like to talk to you about this bridge I have for sale. Seriously, there is no such thing as a secure system. Information will flow, and it will not be constrained by your feeble attempts to guard it from others. Damn, I felt like I was channeling my inner Ian Malcolm there for a second.
>When are we all going to realize there is no such thing as security on the internet.

Nah good security is real, as is the choice by most people to not invest in it.

According to posts on reddit it seems that internal systems used by the staff to work have been affected. Including Simpler Tools and all inventory related processes. Unable to mark down prices on stock seems to be major issue.

https://github.com/abhnvshrma/coles-simpler-tools This is not a code repository but shows Simpler Tools running on a PDT

Unable to mark down prices on stock seems to be major issue....

Coles could call that a silver lining I'd say

>Unable to mark down prices

So this is an acknowledgement of a hack that took place 15 years ago?

wow wow - how did you even find out about this :)

keen to learn more now actually

Having heard things from a friend that worked there until recently their operating environment is as dreadful as their culture. I won't go into detail but I am not at all surprised.