Poll: do you live in the country you were born in?

70 points by jacquesm ↗ HN

131 comments

[ 6.9 ms ] story [ 429 ms ] thread
(comment deleted)
Building very inaccurate stats i guess.
Living in Berlin and really can't think of another european city i would want to live in. USA? Nope. China? Nope. Singapore? Maybe. Australia? Maybe.
Zurich?
Thing is: friends of mine recently returned from Zurich after over a year of working there and apparently they got much "hate" for being germans working in Zurich, for whatever reason. Not saying suisse people are racists, the ones i know are nice people! Also it's expensive. And i am not the mountain-vacation-type of guy. ;)

(the last point is probably more of a reason then the first)

Yes, but I moved from here when I was 2 and only moved back a few years ago
I left my native Canada when I was 19 to write code abroad. I've since had work in four different countries on three continents. I might not end up being wealthy but I've enjoyed myself and don't regret a thing.
Country? No. But I live in the same city I was born in.

(I live in Croatia that was part of ex Yugoslavia, which fell apart in the 90es)

Nice country, I did the whole coast a few years ago.
We do have beautiful coastline with a lot of islands. It's a good place to live in.
I was only once there, as a tourist, but was attacked physically just because my car had a registration from one of Croatian neighboring countries.
I'm sorry to hear that.

The people who attacked you are morons, and unfortunately we have a share of those too. :(

I think we both have a fair share of morons on both sides :( Sadly, this doesn't make me feel more safe to go there again. But the city of Dubrovnik was nice anyways :)
Yes, this is valid for other similar instances, like the former Soviet Union republics, Germany, Sudan, and a bunch of other places which if not changed their boundaries, at least changed their political regime calling themselves differently now. Taking this a little bit further, you may also reach the conclusion that all places are different now because they changed somehow along the way, even if are called the same.
I was thinking that my response below (same city) didn't cover such cases. It would have been quite possible for someone in the right region of Europe to have lived in four countries without moving, with a lifespan of about 80 years: Austro-Hungarian Empire; Rumania; USSR; Ukraine.
12:48 GMT. 43 yes, 24 no.

I have a feeling that the yes's will greatly outnumber the no's a little later when the U.S. logs in.

Maybe different US states should count as a No?

Depending on what the point of this exercise is.

Although experiences across different states can differ. The OP states having moved to a different country. This entails new culture, language and traditions for many countries.

Of course this is more likely to happen in Europe where countries are smaller and borders, well aren't borders anymore.

The United States is a huge country and the job opportunities and lifestyle in Mexico may not seem beneficial to most citizens.

There may be some bias. As an expat I have a strong urge to say I AM EXPAT when I see threads like these.
I'm a foreign local hire, not high enough level to have a full expat on a package...they call us halfpats.
US -> Australia here; left for personal reasons. I would probably still be in the US otherwise. I miss the memory of the US sometimes, and the people I left behind. Also New Haven pizza.
US -> Scotland here; will probably return to US for the pizza.
Do a pizza startup? :)
There's this place not too far from Scotland, easily reachable via a cheap flight with EasyJet. It's called Italy. They make amazing pizzas. And gelato. Mmmmm, gelato pizza...
studying in US currently, born and raised in Burma (Myanmar), don't think I will be back home anytime soon
Came to London from Slovenia about a year ago. Quite an exodus these days.
Note that a vote in a poll does not count as an upvote for the poll! (just in case that wasn't clear...).
I must say yes, unfortunately...

I really want to leave, but I cannot yet.

why?
Some countries have more opportunities.

Some countries have more freedoms.

Some countries have more resources and that translates into more money, more technology and a better quality of life.

.

Pick one, or all three.

The third sentence should be split to two items.
I figured, but three is a just such a nice number for lists :-) .
How?

p.s.: serious question, and it's a lot tougher when you are from a third world country.

The how! It is one of the reasons I did not left yet, I have no idea.

Most countries won't accept Brazillians wanting to go there legally permanently (probably because the havock that illegal brazillians spread around the world :/) with few exceptions (ie: have specific degrees in case of Canada, or be married to a local, that sort of stuff).

Also, although some of our cities (like Recife) kill people faster than some war zones (Recife body count for example rises faster than Iraq body count), noone will grant refugee status to a brazillian (specially, because it would cause a political fallout of some government admiting that Brazil has civil war, and the government here is trying hard to avoid that status, despite having the Army and Navy being in active duty in Rio de Janeiro and fighting people that are armed with military grade weapons, like bazookas and anti-air cannons)

And my assets are negative, this is a big no-no for many countries (like US, that don't allow entry of people with negative assets even as tourists, because negative assets means they having nothing to lose, and much to gain by overstaying their visas).

I guess the question was "why not yet"?
Why not yet?

I have some crazy student debts here, and moving money in or out of here is not much simple, also it has some other implications... I am basically forced to stay until I pay those debts, unless someone offer me some REALLY good job elsewhere (REALLY good in the sense, that wage - cost of living is significant... although I currently earn 15k usd, a 80k usd job in SV is not much profitable for example...)

I am from Brazil.

Extremely violence ridden, I had guns pointed at me in more than once instance, and I witnessed firefights from my bedroom more than once too, in different cities (one firefight was even in a expensive "safe" neighbourhood, what happened is that a dumb guy tried to steal the car of a celebrity private security)

Also, really bad environment to do business, we frequently get scored very low on "ease to do business" index, there is excessive bureaucracy, rules that change randomly (on average the country enacts 18 new laws per day, most of them related to taxes, subsidies, and so on...), excessive corruption...

Also the average brazillian is usually very, very treacherous, people are always warm up front, but quick to stab you in the back, this particular reason is one that I want to change my citizenship (I don't think the average brazillian deserves my life to defend them in case a war happen)

And there are also a mass of other problems summed (for example, trying to homeschool your children here is a felony, jail and all included, also the Gini coefficient is severely absurd, the top 0.1% get more money than their peers in many other developed countries, while the top 5% get less than US minimum wage, probably thanks to banks charging 70%/yr of interest, and credit card companies charging 250%/yr, making finance be wildly profitable, and anything else not so much)

Thank you. That's an uphill battle you're facing, I wish you the very best of luck in overcoming that challenge.
As a brazilian, I can confirm 100% what speeder said above.
Portugal -> Switzerland/France -> Germany

Who knows where to next.

No, Portugal -> UK and not planning to return anytime soon.
Left in 2003, and for the looks of it, I share your feelings.
My case is similar: Portugal -> Ireland -> UK. Not going back soon either.
I always have a hard time answering the question "Where are you from?"

I was born in a country that doesn't give out citizenship (A middle eastern nation). My father, too, was born there. In fact, I need a visa to go visit my own birth country (where my parents still live).

I inherited Indian citizenship through my father and his family (I've never lived there), and potentially British citizenship through my mother (she was born in England but British nationality laws are very complicated). I travel on an Indian passport although I can not vote in India as I am a Non-Resident Indian (That might change for the 2014 elections).

My permanent residency, interestingly, is in Canada; and I live and work in the US.

Edit: I just know there is a business in here somewhere.

What was the country you were born in?
One of the GCC [1] countries. I am sure none of them give citizenship or even permanent residency to non-citizens born in them.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperation_Council_for_the_Ara...

Generally only in the Americas is citizenship given to those who were born in a particular country. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli
It used to be the same in India. But it changed a few years ago. Now you can Indian citizenship if you are born in India and atleast one of your parents is an Indian citizen.
I think I know which country you're talking about. They do give citizenship only to non-citizens (as you've said), but there are other exceptions.
Yup, that's what people usually really mean when they ask "Where are you from?"

I went NZ -> New York, NY -> Scotland and if I'm say on holiday somewhere, doesn't really matter whether it's in the UK, Europe, US, and someone asks "Where are you from?" then I have to think.

Depending on my mood I might answer New Zealand because that's the accent they hear and they really mean "What country were you born in?". Or I might answer Edinburgh or Scotland because that's where I live and consider my home, in which case the response is often "... but you don't have a Scottish accent", and I then explain and they get the answer they were looking for or expecting. Or I might answer "Where does the wind come from?" and disappear down the rabbit hole.

My children have triple citizenship and will no doubt have their own difficulties with "Where are you from?" in later life.

Same here. I was born in Dubai. Dad was working there as an engineer during the building boom in the 70s. I inherited British citizenship through both parents, and US citizenship through Dad.

But, I've lived most of my life just outside Washington DC, USA.

(comment deleted)
Yes for the time being, but there’s probably a move in my future.
Ireland->UK->Australia->France. Plus probably 6 months in the USA spread across a number of visits.
No, but yes. I was born in USSR, but Lithuania gained independence since then.

Been living in different countries and even on another side of the globe, but keep coming back.

US -> LT here, loving living in Klaipeda.
Bitch please! I live in the same city I was born in :P
A different country of the UK from the one I was born in - does that count?
I live 15 miles from where I was born (Los Angeles, CA).
I live 15 meters off, literally.
India > USA > Back to India for me.