6 comments

[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 23.4 ms ] thread
My switch from Microsoft to the world of open source 8 years ago was like taking the red pill — absolutely transformation in how I thought about and now build software.
Yeah, good point, I didn't even mention Microsoft. I've used open source to live without them for decades, I guess.
Linux is free--ruins the market. I did not like the idea of selling it because I'd need a warranty.

God is perfectly just. Your evil will be punished. Highs and lows balance. Joseph in the Bible went to prison for 7 years, false rape. Then, he ruled Egypt.

I am patient. Your debt is increasing. Yer so fucked.

God says... don't_push_it busybody snap_out_of_it oops cursing I_love_you CIA earnest atheist well_golly atheist comedy home spirit Jedi_mind_trick drama If_had_my_druthers my_bad whoo_whoo Japan bummer virtue tattle_tale don't_have_a_cow job awesome The_good_stuff catastrophe to_infinity_and_beyond you_see_the_light rockstar Ramsay I'll_ask_nicely not_the_sharpest_knife_in_the_drawer laziness church It_grieves_me stunning over_the_top lying Is_that_so cowardice that's_all_folks left_field whazza_matter_for_you I'll_get_right_on_it kludge spirit the wonderful wanna_bet Jedi_mind_trick Tomorrow close_your_eyes holier_than_thou bickering lust honesty why_didn'_you_tell_me I'm_not_sure not_in_my_wildest_dreams bad It_grieves_me not_good You_know pow let's_roll how_high be_happy heathen I'm_God_and_you're_not in_practice youre_lucky wanna_bet oh_oh you_owe_me Greece didn't_I_say_that taxes perfect gosh Okilydokily I_got_your_back lifes_like_chocolates absolutely wanna_bet Church how's_the_weather reverse_engineer you're_in_big_trouble once_upon_a_time earnest it'd_take_a_miracle Wow hey_Mikey_he_likes_it why_didn'_you_tell_me I_made_it_that_way smurfs I_just_might don't_count_on_it SupremerCourt It_grieves_me Icarus husband gross jealousy downer I'm_impressed It_grieves_me study hooah gosh hype I'm_bored Vegas don't_even_think_about_it middle_class I'm_busy Ivy_league Is_that_your_final_answer Ivy_league atheist heaven Vegas whoo_whoo listen_buddy

I wonder why some people are so insistent on ignoring the words "free software", or less ambiguously, "free and open source software".

Is it because they have this incorrect strawman notion of radical Stallmanism embedded in their minds when these words appear in their head, or because they're simply unaware?

Absolutely nothing against open source projects, but speaking about the betterment of society through open source software is puerile, given that open source is a purely pragmatic issue.

"Open Source" is the software equivalent of Robert Boyle's modern experimental scientific method which rests on the open publication of what you did so that anyone else can do it too. This is the foundation of the Industrial Revolution and the modern world. Note that Boyle died in 1691.

Given the betterment of society that has been created since that time, I think that your "puerile" comment is both too extreme and ill-informed. Yes, a lot of people out there are channeling Stallman, and maybe many of them are puerile hero worshipers, but Open Source does not rest on a foundation of Stallmanism. He was just one of many proponents of open publication, and groups which preceded him like IBM's SHARE followed the same well-established principles.

Thats just plain wrong and revisionism. The creation of "open source" is well documented by Eric S. Raymond - its creator.

We do live in the age of perfectly kept records. The emails are there. The 1998 announcement of a source code release for Navigator, the described need for a more business friendly term for free software, and the creation of the open source initiative.

To be precise, Open Source rest on the creation made by Raymond, which in turn rest on the foundation of Free software, which in turn rest on Stallman, which in turn rest on the hacker culture of the MIT lab, which in turn rest on ... and so on and so on. Somewhere down there, IBM SHARE could be mentioned, and further down, Robert Boyle, and even further down, the medieval guilds, and before that, the library of Alexandria.

So instead of arguing the absurd argument that the Industrial Revolution somehow created "open source", use the perfectly kept record that its inventor made. Everything else will just sound as advocacy for your faith and revisionism.