Cool sites - I like this idea of sharing concepts and getting feedbacks. One other larger one is producthunt.co. I'd be curious to see a full list if you happen to do some more competitive research!
This is why I don't like posting my product ideas publicly for anyone who searches keywords. If I give away all the details of my implementation, I could be helping someone else who is doing "competitor research." If I don't give the details, then my idea sounds incomplete or just like everyone else's idea in that space. No matter how many articles I read on HN that ideas are worthless, I still feel reluctant posting my best ideas on a site like that.
But I have a solution. It's called Indie Developer Club (see my profile for link). All the meetings are small with less than 10 people. You can show off a pre-release demo or talk about the specifics of your project, but you aren't posting it for the world to see. So you get some feedback but you don't have to worry about a competitor Googling you.
I believe you. But I had the same reaction as mkaziz. And was about to comment on this.
So I think the takeaway is that people are turned off by this - and you can convince people on HN that you won't abuse it. But not everywhere.
And, with a million products attempting to take my time - anything that makes me hesitate (like that I have to allow you to "update my profile") is enough to turn me off.
Ok then why not just ask to post tweets on my behalf? why ask for Update your profile., Read my tweets, etc. Not letting any unknown app update my profile. Sorry.
I thought it might be something like that. Twitter needs to fix this or developers like you will be facing the consequences of their actions. Facebook's permissions are much more granular.
2. I found it strange that the landing page didn't have any pitched ideas. To see an idea, I had to read the bottom text, and click on one of the countries. I didn't know those were links at first either.
3. Can ppl only pitch the title of their idea? Is there a description or something.
I didn't realize that "France", "USA", and "anywhere else" were links until you mentioned so right here. You should make these links distinctive from the rest of the text without the need of having to hover over them so that they are more obvious.
One thing I've done on my site is abandon passwords. Authentication is by email (if you can receive a link you can "sign in" once with it - thereafter cookies).
This avoids the need to ask for permission (to tweet for me? really?) up front. Users can start reading and posting without giving up anything but their email.
This is not a new idea, but I think it works well to minimise barriers for potential contributors.
I have no idea why this is required. Why add friction to posting? Email + password + confirm password seems like the best idea, with Twitter as a separate option.
I didn't terribly mind having to use Twitter for signup.
As soon as you asked for my email AS WELL, I could no longer be bothered to click through - the only value of 3rd-party login is not having to give you my email address.
My 2 cents: I've thought about doing this exact thing before...then I realized it's like giving other people free ideas. Isn't this just the perfect place for others to steal your stuff? What're you gonna do if that happens? I would never post a good idea publicly, just asking for competition you probably can't afford to have.
This point has been discussed into the ground before, but in general, ideas mean nothing. I've had many million dollar ideas: I know because I've seen them in the marketplace. No execution, no value. Also, most people aren't the precious little butterfly they think they are: someone has had their idea before.
41 comments
[ 2.0 ms ] story [ 57.8 ms ] threadBut I have a solution. It's called Indie Developer Club (see my profile for link). All the meetings are small with less than 10 people. You can show off a pre-release demo or talk about the specifics of your project, but you aren't posting it for the world to see. So you get some feedback but you don't have to worry about a competitor Googling you.
So I think the takeaway is that people are turned off by this - and you can convince people on HN that you won't abuse it. But not everywhere.
And, with a million products attempting to take my time - anything that makes me hesitate (like that I have to allow you to "update my profile") is enough to turn me off.
That's right. I totally understand. The thing is... Twitter permissions aren't very precise.
I just wanted to ask for the permission to write tweets from my app, not to edit your profile. But they don't allow you to do that...
Anyway thanks for the feedback!
1. I don't have a twitter account.
2. I found it strange that the landing page didn't have any pitched ideas. To see an idea, I had to read the bottom text, and click on one of the countries. I didn't know those were links at first either.
3. Can ppl only pitch the title of their idea? Is there a description or something.
2. You can access the ideas list here: http://www.gopitch.me/ideas/all
3. You can see a pitch here: http://www.gopitch.me/idea/4769741570834432
Again, there are reasons for the things you are doing - I understand this. And there are ways to get around your block - but take the feedback.
If one person says it here, it means that dozens had the same reaction and just decided not to voice it.
One thing I've done on my site is abandon passwords. Authentication is by email (if you can receive a link you can "sign in" once with it - thereafter cookies).
This avoids the need to ask for permission (to tweet for me? really?) up front. Users can start reading and posting without giving up anything but their email.
This is not a new idea, but I think it works well to minimise barriers for potential contributors.
Your auth is pretty clever to minimize the barrier to entry.
Yet, I thought Twitter could be an interesting channel for my app and decided to build my website on top of it.
Recent ideas should be more prominent. Probably show the latest ten on the main page, then a link for more.
Plus a huge (red) button to pitch a new idea in the front page.
As soon as you asked for my email AS WELL, I could no longer be bothered to click through - the only value of 3rd-party login is not having to give you my email address.
I really want to host one but cannot find any cheap way