Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?

386 points by unclebucknasty ↗ HN
I recently submitted an item:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8052399

It made it to and remained on the front page for a while. Then, after some hours, ~180 votes and many comments, a HN mod changed the title completely and also modified the URL to a completely different article on a different site.

I understand that the new article might have provided additional detail (which another user had also indicated on the comments thread), but why is HN completely changing what its users are posting, while still attributing it to those users? It's odd to have something attributed to me that I did not submit. And, if the answer is that "the topic was the same", "the first article referenced the second", or similar, then it seems that editorializing to this extent wholly changes what HN is about. That is, why not just have users submit proposed topics for discussion rather than URLs?

And, what of any quotes or references to the initially submitted URL in the comments section?

BTW, on the one hand, it seems fairer to allow the user to keep karma earned for the article (as HN did), but this begs the question that if so many people had already upvoted the article, then might it have already been "sufficient"?

169 comments

[ 3.3 ms ] story [ 194 ms ] thread
> then it seems that editorializing to this extent wholly changes what HN is about

This has been being since very many years, so it doesn't really change anything per se. It's that you're just realizing it, and lately primary sources are being preferred more.

No, the mods have definitely become heavier recently. I saw one the other day which was a letter from Richard Feynman to an ex-student, explaining to him, amongst other things, how to choose problems to work on. The original title mentioned that it was from Richard Feynman, the modded title was just something like "How to choose problems to work on", with no mention of Feynman, which is so generic and boring that I would never have clicked on the link.

Dear mods, modding is something to use when there is a clear threat to community values. The default position, if you are in doubt, should be to do nothing.

The rules around titles are to always use the title from the article. If people could make up their own titles we could end up with a tonne of click-bait. There are clearly situations like the one you mention where the title doesn't do the article justice but I'd rather miss the occasional article that see a tonne of click-bait and waste my time viewing dozens of shitty articles.
The rules around titles are to always use the title from the article.

In general, that is the rule.

The cynic in me couldn't help but notice that an article with the original title "One of a Kind: What do you do if your child has a condition that is new to science?" has been on HN's front page for a day now with an alternate title.

For some reason, the same mods who removed "Feynman" as "click-bait" that is "not the title from the article" don't seem to have a problem sticking with the alternate title "Thanks, HN: You helped discover a disease and save lives" [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8050106].

The submitter here is Matt Might, whose family was the subject of the article. His first comment in the thread makes it obvious why this is an exceptional case.
With all due respect, you've only been on HN for a couple of months.

Why would there be an "exception" to the policy of discouraging submitters from editorializing headlines? Even if the submitter had a personal connection to the material (which isn't unusual), the guidelines should be respected.

Because the purpose of the guidelines is to make the site better, and changing that headline would not make the site better.

Also, the headline modifications in that case were not made with the same intentions that other (harmful) headline modifications are made.

So the Feynman article's title did change! I thought my eyes were playing tricks.

Dear moderators: please don't do that. And when someone reposts the classic "You and Your Reseach" again, don't strip out Hamming's name from that title, either.

Especially after the discussion has referenced the original article, now the entire context is broken.

But in the end, they can have whatever rules they want and it would still be bad because of one problem that prevails all of mod activity: that there is just so infrequently any notification that anything happened. Don't enforce them in secret, leading us to wonder what, when, and why something happened.

The mods here are out of control to the point where I'm considering going back to Reddit completely. The fact the stories are being censored due to "topic association" despite having enough up-votes is ridiculous.
Which stories?
NSA for example. Any topic with "NSA" gets a very large hit.
I'm willing to bet that has way more to do with the substantial body of people flagging down all the NSA posts than some mod conspiracy
Where do you go to get this definitive data on HN activities?
From Daniel Gackle, who comments on the stories that get buried.
That's exactly the problem. You received that info directly from a third person. There is no transparency. Would you believe everything I say? I wouldn't. But if the facts where out there you wouldn't need to. On an issue such as this where people take such sustained and intense interest, your second hand account of someone giving you their word is not sufficient. Maybe it is for you, but please don't condescend by passing it along as though it must be for others.
The third person is the site moderator. And yes, I believe pretty much whatever Daniel tells me. He's that kind of guy.

"That Daniel Gackle is the HN moderator" is the kind of factual detail you might want to know before developing very strong opinions about how the site is run.

Please see my other comment on this page where explicitly say I completely agree HN is in the right in running a site in this manner. I was just trying to point out that while you may know Daniel others might not. And, again, I believe that a moderator system is 100% fine. HN news has made it work and produces quality content. But, for someone to tell me that since they know someone I should keep my trap shut, it's a little presumptuous.
(comment deleted)
First, nobody told you to keep your trap shut.

Second, if you don't trust the site moderators, HN isn't going to be a pleasant place to spend time.

sheesh. your comment isn't a pleasant place to spent time. someone needs some internet kitten love.
It's probably people flagging it and not the mods, yes. But are the people flagging it actual users?

The story in question here had 200 upvotes when it was a link to an NSA story at Slate. The link was changed to the same, source NSA story at First Look and it was quickly flagged to oblivion. I think there're likely some monitoring scripts and flag alerts at play, not just NSA fatigue by actual users.

Although the issue with NSA is important, the problem with most of those threads is that they all the same. Same predictable arguments, or no arguments at all.
Why do they get upvoted then?
Stores with "NSA" get a large number of user flags. As recently as last week, they also got a small penalty --- the second smallest on the site --- to compensate for the very large number of NSA stories that are generated every day.

If you submitted an NSA story and it fell off the front page, it was user flags that did it, not the penalty.

An article on global warming by Michael Crichton was killed a few hours ago.
That was killed by user flags.
Why do you assume it were the mods and not just people flagging?
Many stories are flagged by users off the page.
I think the penalty levels for flagging seriously need to be looked at, and some measures to prevent flag rings and other malicious flagging should to be put into place.

The story this thread refers to is the perfect example: it was #1 with 200 upvotes after just a few hours. The link was then changed to a different domain that covered the topic in more depth, and the story was suddenly buried within a half hour--apparently by flagging. How was the first link so popular and the second link inappropriate for discussion when the topic was the same? Either some users are just very prejudiced against certain domains, or there are some users and/or organizations that have automated systems in place to detect certain domains or links and send alerts to bury them.

I think the problem extends beyond submission flagging.

There have been enough times where I've witnessed completely factual and legitimate comments here that happened to criticize or even just question Mozilla, Rust, Ruby on Rails, NoSQL, or some other "revered" organization or technology get heavily voted down without justification.

Some of this may just arise naturally. Certain submissions may draw the attention of people directly involved with the given organization or technology. They may take it personally when the discussion touches on perfectly valid, yet perhaps painful, topics. They respond by downvoting these comments that are totally valid and raise some good points. Even if these people are not intentionally acting maliciously, this misvoting can still be quite harmful.

I'm not certain that there's a good way of dealing with this, however.

The disconnect here is that downvotes are considered OK when you simply disagree with something. The problem arises in that people can be made "dead" when this happens, and that individual posts become virtually unreadable because a few people disagreed with them.
Almost always the "dead" posts are worthless, and the people who replied should have been downvoted for indulging the conversation.
I rarely ever see wrongly gray comments, certainly not in a systematic way. I do see many rightfully gray comments, though. A comment being wrongfully downvoted is not actually quite harmful. There isn't any harm that happens. Unless somebody can't stand the notion that people disagree with their opinion -- but that's helpful because it drives them off the site. Usually, though, gray comments are not those where it's a matter of opinion.
Here's one example of systematic downvoting that I can think of: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7836937

So sum it up, me and somebody named jsmthrowaway happened to point out some painful realities regarding the Rust programming language. The facts we brought up must have hurt the feelings of some within the Rust community (several prominent figures were involved with that discussion), and so numerous factual and perfectly legitimate comments of ours within that thread of discussion basically ended up censored.

Now, I personally don't care about karma, or whether people agree or disagree with opinions I express or facts that I may happen to point out. What I don't like, however, is seeing perfectly good content grayed out, regardless of who posted it. Censorship is always harmful.

These days, I find the grayed out comments more disruptive than beneficial. Many of them are perfectly valid content. Some of them often are quite insightful, in a way that some people probably find painful.

So instead of being comments that I feel comfortable ignoring, I usually find myself trying to read the grayed out ones even though they've been obscured and are harder to read. They're often the most worthwhile comments within a submission's discussion.

You don't think maybe people just responded naturally to a comment that started "The similarity to Rust should scare the hell out of Rust's creators and proponents" and went downhill from there? You instead think your slightly downvoted comment is evidence of systemic bias?
I merely pointed out one recent example that I could demonstrate quickly, because it happened to involve some of my comments and those of somebody else who happened to express similar ideas.

It isn't the only instance, of course. Mis-moderation is quite frequent here. Some of the discussion under this submission is a good example of that. I see I have once again been targeted by people who find it easier to downvote than to bother discussing the matter at hand like adults.

I wish that people here were more willing to discuss stuff that they might happen to disagree with, rather than engaging in censorship.

I think people downvoted that comment because they thought it was wrong, was based on a completely hyperbolic worldview, and had a very high excitement:substance ratio.
Your (and others') comments about Rust/Mozilla normally get detailed replies indicating how they are either wrong, or misrepresentions (I would go so far as to label them as willful mispreresentations now, given the number of times the discussions have come up).

(I don't speak for the other topics, though.)

The guidance on this is pretty confusing, I agree. On one hand, we have this:

  If you want to add initial commentary on the link, write a blog post about it and submit that instead.
On the other, we get this:

  If a blog post reports on something they found on another site, submit the latter.
So, which is it? Report just the original source without the additional discussion, or the additional discussion if you feel it worth the talk?

It worries me how much power a few people hold over submissions. A few flags on a popular topic, and it's burned to the ground. A few people complaining in the comments about the "original source", and the entire post is changed. It just feels wrong.

Sounds pretty clear to me: If you write an opinionated blog post on an article you are free to submit it just as much as the person who submits the article itself. But if your blog post is just a summary of the article it's probably going to get removed.
I would agree, if reality had matched up with this theory. I've watched many insightful blog posts be replaced with the original article over the last year. Usually as a result of a few people just linking to the original article (despite some dozen plus other threads continuing the conversation started by the blog).

Sadly, no, I don't have links (and it's not something you can search for), so you'll have to take me at my word, and choose an appropriate amount of salt to go with it.

I'm perfectly fine with them changing to a better sourced URL and a more accurate title - however I never thought about your attribution point. If they change both of these things you now have something attributed to you that has absolutely nothing to do with you. That definitely seems like it could cause problem, especially for people who are not 'anonymous' and are using real names.
"I'm perfectly fine with them changing to a better sourced URL and a more accurate title"

I can see how this behavior can bring some benefits. However, what if the mods just change the urls in order to point to their own blogs? Or to blogs where the opinion expressed shares their view or supports the interests of whoever? That behavior can dangerously lead to manipulation.

I do not like the fact that I can see some news in the front page with 200 votes and the article that I read is not the one that received those 200 hundreds votes.

I also do not like at all the attribution issue that you mentioned.

It's publicly known who the HN mods are AFAIK so if they were personally benefitting from changing the links the community would know about it.

>> "Or to blogs where the opinion expressed shares their view or supports the interests of whoever?"

This is what got me thinking about the dangers of attribution, particularly when linking to a political article.

I think the reasons for changing titles and links (click-bait, blogspam instead of source) is sound but we as a community need to police it and generally that's done pretty well. When links or titles are changed there is usually a comment from someone who noticed and the comment usually lets people know of the original link/title.

I'm not a mod, but I can answer your three main questions.

1.) Why do titles get changed?

2.) Why do URLs get changed?

3.) Why do things drop off the front page?

The first two questions are answered in the HN guidelines:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

In short, is says to always avoid "linkbait" and misleading titles, and always submit the original source URL. If someone suggests a URL to the original source, then changing the URL helps everybody. The same is true for changing bad titles. Regurgitated blogspam with a linkbaiit title is always annoying, and most aggregators fight against it every single day.

The third question is tougher to answer, since you'd need to do a whole lot of reading. The two most common things which will cause the rank of a submission to drop are users flagging the story, and setting off the voting ring detector (i.e. trying to fake up-votes).

Sam Altman (hn user: sama, YC S05, and a YC Partner) mentioned the ring voting detector issues here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7972941

And somewhere in the comments of our fearless public moderator Daniel Gackle (hn user: dang) was mentioned the issue about user flags affecting the rank of stories.

Your fourth question:

4.) Is it fair to attribute something to a user that they did not actually submit?

If you failed to follow the guidelines, then yes, it is fair because it helps everyone else on HN.

For notes, I've had titles of my submissions edited for clarity, and the only part that bothers me is that I made a moderator do unnecessary work that I should have done myself.

EDIT: Found the link where dang mentions user flags sinking a story:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8008472

I think we all understand these points, however people such as the OP seem to have their URL/title changed, even though it doesn't "violate" the guidelines, but just because some seem to think differently in the comments.

I can't really judge since I haven't noticed such changes, it's just what I take away from the discussions above.

> seem to have their URL/title changed, even though it doesn't "violate" the guidelines

Posting original sources is an HN guideline, and an important one.

Maybe it's as simple as having a changelog on titles. If a mod changes the link or title, you could show something to indicate that on the frontpage, and on the comments page show more details like what the original link/title was, and what it was changed to, and by whom.

IOW it seems like transparency in moderation is what you really need. This would also solve the problem of original discussion referencing the old article no longer making sense when the article changes.

Usually dang post a comment when he changes the title or url. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=author%3Adand+changed#!/comment/so... Most of the times the change is sensible.

It's still a problem because some of the comments refer to the old version.

"usually posts a comment" is not sufficient. Dang is human and humans make mistakes. If the system allows somebody to have that kind of power, it should also make it transparent so that we can call them out when it is being abused.

I agree with the parent, if we as a community are going to allow this type of stuff, there needs to be a changelog. We can't rely on good graces of the moderator. It will be abused.

HN has never, ever been more transparent than it is today. "The system" has always allowed people to have that kind of power; the difference today is that 'dang goes out of his way to point out when he's using it.

"We as a community" have "allowed this type of stuff" since its inception.

Just because a situation isn't as bad as it once was doesn't mean that it's somehow "good" now, though.
Perhaps we disagree, but I think the transparency has measurably improved HN over the course of more transparency.
What bad things happen if there isn't a changelog? Somebody changes the URLs on you without a log? So what? What's the harm here? As far as I can tell, the only people that have a reason to get angry are those that post suboptimal links. Usually it's a link to a rather crappy article.
Simple fix: a "moderator comment" which simply sits at the top of the thread and is required when changing the URL or title.
Dang is really transparent about his modifications. I always see him posting a comment on many threads about title changes, and voting ring detections etc. He's a great moderator who does a tremendous job.
Wholeheartedly agree. But it'd be good if the surfacing of title/url moderation were automatic rather than reliant upon the mod's (current) good behavior.
A comment at the bottom of a 180+ comment thread is not sufficient. I'm always annoyed when I get to a comment thread that is talking about a different article than the one I clicked on. There needs to at least be an indication in the UI that this happened.
> This would also solve the problem of original discussion referencing the old article no longer making sense when the article changes.

This isn't really a problem. It doesn't matter.

Solution: If (mod wants to change link AND link is front page) then mod leaves a comment with link to original.
That's what the moderator currently does.
(comment deleted)
I think this question would have been better via email to the mods. There's a good chance they would have reverted for you based on what you've mentioned in this particular instance. For what it's worth, while they are only human, I think the mods do a great job with both titles and (more rarely) changing URL.

When a URL is changed, it is a way of saying, 'Look, we think this other URL is better for the discussion', while keeping the discussion. Daniel does a great job of mentioning these changes in a comment - hardly ever to a complaint. https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=dang for some of Daniel's comments.

Title changes are also generally good ones. Often they happen in response to a complaint.

If you don't like it, email the mods with why!

They do a fantastic job. I approve of changing the titles (even silently) or URL's, especially with a comment. If you have a complaint do feel free to email the mods about it.

And here's a thanks to the great work the mods do and to hoping they will keep it up.

You're only reading Hacker News thanks to their tireless work.

Nonesense.! I am sure there are lots of people who submit links for reasons other than karma and HN base discussions. Not everyone will appreciate the redirection of traffic from their researched and well written post. Not to mention the prestige of making it to the front page!
(comment deleted)
I knew I'd be downvoted but its the unpalatable truth
Public discussion doesn't hurt anybody.
No, but it clutters up the site, and having the discussion in public can make the actual discussion impossible as the thread gets swamped with people threatening to leave for Reddit or worried that 'dang is a secret Republican.

Which I assume are among the many reasons that the moderators have asked that these conversations go to hn@ycombinator.com instead of threads.

Considering that there is a lot of users using their own identity, changing the title - or worse - the actual source of a submission, could result in misunderstandings.
I asked a very similar question of dang [1] about two months ago when he decided to change an article's URL to one I added to the comments [2].

His response to me (w/ irrelevant stuff redacted):

    The short answer is that HN's goal is quality, so that's
    what we optimize for. Optimizing means trading other things
    away. One thing we're willing to trade away–if it's a clear
    win for quality–is fidelity to the original submission. HN's
    focus should always be on the content, and the details of the
    original submission are of little interest compared to the
    subject at hand.
    
    HN isn't a purist's kind of place. Our goal to make the
    front page and the threads as interesting and substantive
    as possible. We change a lot of things to serve that
    principle. If we knew how to serve it better, we'd happily
    break more crockery to do so.
    
    Someone (perhaps a purist!) will object that terms like
    "quality", "interesting", and "substantive" have no precise
    definitions and are in the eye of the beholder. True, but (a)
    they're not arbitrary either, (b) the alternatives suck, and
    (c) someone has to make the calls. We don't get them all right,
    but we do try hard to correct mistakes, and I'll defend the
    principle any day.
1: dang = Daniel Gackle, HN's moderator. http://blog.ycombinator.com/meet-the-people-taking-over-hack...

2: Original thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7747401

I simply don't like the fact that someone can change a link that I submitted to something else. Moderators have the right to kill a story or ban a user for valid reasons, but changing a link to point to another completely different article is just being pedantic and definitely crosses the line. We might as well then just post topics, and let the mods choose the best story for that topic.
I agree that mods changing submissions is a little like putting words in the original submitter's mouth, but if the practice is well known I don't think there's much harm in it.

Like I hinted at in the other thread, and as dang seems to confirm, it's an issue of purism vs pragmatism.

Then there should be a way to say:

    <a href={{new_link}}>new title</a> [changed from <a href={{old_link}}>old title</a>]
I don't think the practice is well known. I've been on HN for a year or something, and have seen reference to the practice in comments a maximum of 5 times. And I think I tend to read pretty deeply.
Since Dang has taken over as the main moderator and been more public about it, he's announced doing it more times than that.

    > I simply don't like the fact that someone can change a
    > link that I submitted to something else
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foot_voting
Nothing would ever be changed for the better if people simply walked away from problems, rather than discussing them in an attempt to find a solution.
Your perspective is wrong.

The important thing is not that HN gets "better" according to your preferences (which appear to differ from those of the moderators), but that you have a community that more suits your preferences.

In a similar vein, you can complain as much as you like that company x's smartphone doesn't have the features you think are important, or, better, you can buy company y's smartphone that does.

so, instead of trying to make hn better, you suggest that whoever does not agree with something here should just silently walk away? if everyone acted like that what a happy society we would have been living in.
Make our own HN! Quick someone register nothn.io!
Let's be honest, this website isn't a democracy or a republic or anything like that, even if there is "voting" on submissions and comments.

Average users really have no say while they're here. There's no real ability to control or even influence how this site is operated.

Leaving, or choosing not to actively participate any longer, probably does have the biggest impact of all of the options available to a user. Discussion forums need participants, and participants leaving over time can have a huge impact.

Slashdot is a good example of this. Various site owners/operators started changing things in ways that users did not like. Many users spoke out, but they were ignored. In many cases, they were subjected to downmodding, especially those who spoke out against bad UI changes or the recent beta site. Seeing that discussing the problems had no impact on the situation, they left. Now Slashdot is a wasteland compared to what it once was, a decade or so ago. The decline in participation may be gradual, but it's very real, and its impact is significant.

> Now Slashdot is a wasteland compared to what it once was, a decade or so ago.

So it seems as if leaving slashdot did not really make it better. I'm not aware of a reincarnation that kept the good bits, either. So, to put a sharp point on it: just because blowing a city up has a "bigger impact" than being in it and complaining, doesn't necessarily make it the better option, if you know what I mean?

I think the exodus from Slashdot has been beneficial. It has shown that the various problems there are in fact severe enough to drive a large number of users away.

It may not be an ideal situation, of course, but it's better than the problems continuing to build under the surface, and users remaining miserable.

Now that the discontent is much more visible, there's at least some hope that real improvement may just happen there. That would not have been the case if people had remained, even if they were merely just vocal about their discontent, without acting upon it in some measurable way.

> Average users really have no say while they're here. There's no real ability to control or even influence how this site is operated.

I have to take issue with this. We change decisions all the time because of what users think, and I've left many records of that in the threads. HN moderation is really a collaboration between us and the community.

What HN isn't, is purely driven by votes. If it were, the front page would consist of outrage, gossip, and fashion. Those are the things that reliably get upvotes regardless of how substantive they are.

Reversing a bad moderation or operational decision when it's widely pointed out as having been a bad decision isn't what I consider giving the community any control or influence. That's merely fixing mistakes that probably shouldn't have been made to begin with, had real community involvement been in place.

What I mean, for example, is that while submissions and comments may be critiqued, there's pretty much no formal way for users in general here to critique that critiquing. The best that can be done is a submission like this one, which for whatever reason ended up off of the front page rather quickly. That's what I'm talking about.

Slashdot has its meta-moderation system, for example, which is somewhat useful and somewhat accessible. There's nothing even approaching that here, as far as I know.

(comment deleted)
By "make hn better", you mean "make it different from how the originator and moderators want it to be".

Given that, yes, you should find a community whose leadership agree with your perspective.

Do people pay attention to who submits items? I never do. Maybe the display of the submitter could be removed without any loss.
Yes they do. Some people can get to front page at will. Now, whether that's good or not is a different discussion, but people trust their judgement so they get more weight.
> Do people pay attention to who submits items?

Would we be having this conversation if they didn't?

I think he primarily referred to other readers, this topic was posted by a submitter.
I don't usually pay any attention to who submitted something, and one of the biggest issues I see with HN is the imbalance in points between someone who submits an article and someone who has valuable input in the discussion.

Half of my karma is from 2 submissions but I think a good comment is much more valuable that being the first person to submit a link.

What you fail to articulate is how anybody benefits from seeing the old URL.
It's a problem when there is discussion about a submission, then the URL is changed to a somewhat different article, and the existing discussion no longer makes as much sense.

Ripping away the original context unexpectedly is the problem. So making the original context more accessible is one good solution to this problem.

I've seen that happen, and you'll never believe what happens next:

The people on the thread, being adults, write a couple sentences about how the story there were commenting on used to say something else.

For many of us, this infinitesimal inconvenience is more than offset by the improved experience of not clicking through blogspam to get to the right sources. Nine times out of ten, when this happens, the original submission is awful compared to the one we end up with.

Maybe there should be some indication on the post that the article/title was changed so the edits aren't attributed to the original submitter. This would at least resolve that confusion.

It seems like the current model tries to be like SlashDot (where everything curated) but retains the appearance of user-driven content by keeping it's curation hidden.

When an article and/or title is changed, I'd like to see a comment with the original title and a link to the original article. I should note that dang often adds a comment that a change occurred -- which I appreciate -- but I'd like to see a little more context.
The modified/edited/curated title and/or URL could always be shown underneath or beside the original title and URL, which remain unchanged.
Or, how about "forking" posts. If the content is truly of higher quality, then the fork will be up-voted more from that point on. If not, then the original post will be. And why must the article be attributed to only one person. Karma could be shared by some mechanism if a forked post gits [sic] more up-votes.

I think "hellbanning" should also be a part of this conversation. The combination of mods non-transparent editing practices and hellbanning makes an extremely strong case for categorizing the mod system as a form of censorship.

HN is a private website. So, I fully believe that HN should be allowed to censor if it would like to. I certainly at times censor my friends when they post to my facebook wall. But my facebook wall isn't a community. And it doesn't purport to provide news. Thus, I believe HN should be held to a higher standard.

I wonder why the parent comment was voted down. I don't see anything wrong with it. In fact, it has some perfectly reasonable ideas and suggestions.

I find it odd that people within the discussion here can suggest that bad flagging or bad voting isn't an issue, when we have a perfect example of it involving what's currently the 7th comment from the top.

I'm just at a complete loss at to how I was down-voted so much without a single comment as to the reason why. I was trying to be constructive and on topic.
You were lawyering about whether or not something is censorship, but the question of what words to assign to what acts has nothing to do with the question at hand. You made a weak argument to declare X, then presumed X in a weak argument to declare Y, and you tried to amplify your argument simply by declaring that you're being convincing.

Also you took the opportunity to be clever with some weird pun about git(?) and readers probably inferred certain things about your motivations for making a post.

I see your 'straw man' and raise you an 'ad hominem'. I've just read through your HN comments. You're consistently extremely negative, to no purpose. "Your argument sucks because..." etc.
Yes, I am not that good at posting and I often get downvoted accordingly.
>One thing we're willing to trade away–if it's a clear win for quality–is fidelity to the original submission.

What worries me about this is how bias comes into play. For example, what if a mod thought a pro-Republican view on an issue had higher fidelity than a neutral view? Sure it might not always be that blatant or obvious, but this is an area I'd think twice about editing so the stories don't reflect what you think is ideal.

I would rather call it "censorship" and "impersonation" instead of "quality". Sorry, if you (dang or whoever) edit whatever I put there, just remove my name from there, so that people know who write the new content.
Agree. It wouldn't be hard for it have a little "originally" link/flag that pops up what was actually submitted prior to the mods fiddling with it. The attribution could also be changed from "username" to "modname via username", providing additional clarification about where it came from.
Every site has a duty to respect its users, especially when their content is the driving force of the site, this shouldn't be an optional thing at the whims of some "quality optimisation expert". Moderation should be about filtering the toxic users, not about getting in the way of the legitimate ones.
This might seem simplistic, but couldn't this problem be solved with a "related" list?

It's been many moons since I've been to Digg, but it had a notification if you're submitting a post with a similar title/URL. While we're discussing it, it may not hurt to have a "previous discussion" list either.

Opinions, information other relevant factors can change over time, so it may not be so bad to revisit a topic.

@unclebucknasty, could you show your original submission for comparison?

At https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8052399 it says right now: "Hacking Online Polls and Other Ways British Spies Seek to Control the Internet", which is linked to https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/07/14/manipulating-o...

What did you originally post?

Here's a comment of mine from that thread explaining what he posted, how it changed, and what happened [~]:

This story was in the first position on the front page less than an hour ago. It was there for hours. The link was then changed from [0] to [1], and within thirty minutes, it was on the second page at number 47. (It first took a drop to around 17, hovered there for a while, then hit 47.)

Could we have an explanation of what's going on here? How can penalties from flagging be this steep for a story with 200 upvotes and 90 comments? Why did the position suddenly change shortly after the link was changed, but not right away?

[0] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/07/15/documents...

[1] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/07/14/manipulating-o...

[~] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8054173

interestingly enough , I submitted [1] after it was initially published and no one cared

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8031791

No one cared because it was quickly buried, which could quite possibly be due to a flag ring or automated monitoring for flagging of the firstlook.org domain. Here's my other comment on the topic [~]:

It would be incredibly easy to use this sort of program to game visibility on HN.

This story itself serves as the perfect example. When it was submitted four days ago [0], it quickly took a huge ranking hit and dropped off the front page. When a story drops off the front page this quickly, it's nearly impossible for it to get the upvote momentum required to gain any additional visibility. And the same URL can't be submitted again, so the opportunity for discussion of the article has essentially been removed.

Then, we're left discussing a breaking story as the top item four days later, when a summary report about the original story that contains no new information is published on Slate.

One might be quick to blame moderators, but in the discussion of another recent First Look story, dang said most of the penalty came from users flagging the story. [1] How many users flagging the story does it take to produce this outcome? Does GCHQ just need three accounts with a little karma to seriously diminish visibility here for days? Safeguards should be developed to prevent this sort of malicious activity. Maybe some sort of collusion penalty, where if the same users are flagging the same stories, the effect is diminished? Or a greater restriction on the maximum penalty?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8031791

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8008472

EDIT: And it's happened again! This story was #1 when the link was to [3]. About a half hour ago, the link was changed to firstlook.org, and within minutes, the story fell to the center of the main page. Now, thirty minutes later, it's at number 47 (with 200 points after six hours). It was at the top for hours, then dropped to 47 within thirty minutes of the link being changed. The fact that flagging happened right after the link was changed seriously suggests that some someone has automated monitoring for First Look links to flag.

[3] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/07/15/documents...

[~] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8053852

Thanks! How about the text? Would be good to know the text changes as well.
The title was "U.K. Intelligence Agency's Ability to Manipulate Online Polls, Etc.", which notably doesn't include words that would trigger automated alerts if someone with an agenda that involved flagging surveillance stories had set them up somehow.
Hacker News mods are just dicks! That's all.
HN is not as open as other group sites like, say, reddit where it's up to the users to decide what's important. It's run with a specific purpose of quality of stories within a specific set of topics and a vehicle for promotion of YC-related content. Voting exists to provide group input within those guidelines.

The bit about writing a blog post and submitting it is out-of-date based on current mod behavior. If you want to provide commentary, post the original source and add a comment. Links to blogs are nearly always pulled for the original source unless the blog is the original source on an overall trend, research, etc.

take a look at /r/undelete some day. Reddit is frighteningly unopen.
It varies quite a bit by subreddit, of course. Some mods like to rule their little fiefdoms.
This is very true.

Many of the subreddits that are very specific to a given technology or programming language or something like that are often the worst. The audience is comparatively small to begin with, and mostly made up of people who hold the technology in high esteem. Any user who submits comments that may be deemed as slightly negative or questioning of the technology are targeted and "eliminated", so to speak.

This leads to a very toxic environment where quality content and discussion become totally non-existent.

> a vehicle for promotion of YC-related content

That's not true. YC companies get to post job ads. They get no special promotion—that is, the only promotion they get comes from the fact that the YC startup community and the HN community happen to overlap. The site mechanisms don't favor YC cos and the moderators try hard not to.

Your point about original sources is exactly right, or at least I hope it is.

On this issue, Slashdot strikes a pretty good compromise, I think, by providing a link below their posted item to the original submission, i.e., in the "You may like to read:" section.
If the shared URL changes, the moderator that changed the post should also re-attribute the submission to the person that suggested the new link. When this happens, the system should auto-post 'the original submission: ShortURL by USER has been modified to ShortURL as suggested by NEW USER.'
Because they are nazis.
Flagged for meta noise.

I'm pretty sure one of the guidelines is to email in for these kind of questions rather than polluting the frontpage with these kind of posts.

There's something strange about adding meta noise to a post you believe is meta noise.
The entire thread is meta noise.
(comment deleted)
I think that at least the edited entries should be marked as such! (Maybe in the footer with a small link to reveal the original.)
I really don't want to hear another fucking word about "karma" on this site, ever again. "Karma" is what ruined reddit, with spam and reposting rampant only for the sake of stupid fucking Internet points. That is not what the system is meant for.
That's an argument I hear a lot, but karma was integral in building the community when reddit is young. It motivated people to contribute.
> It's odd to have something attributed to me that I did not submit.

They could just change the submitter and add something like "Originally submitted by xxx" below it to let people know it's been changed.

Why not have a public edit history? (Or why not show multiple versions, one grayer or smaller print?)
I was once the receiving end of such editing and I thought the mods did the right thing (Added a better link).

It's probably a good idea to give some visual indication to submissions that are tampered with though.