Reading this reminded me of an article I read a little while ago talking about the tradeoffs "biohackers" take on to try to get ahead on relatively untested techniques[0]. It seems a little silly to think that shocking your brain with electricity will give you an advantage without significant side-effects, but who knows... as for me, I'll wait until brain-shockers have demonstrably better mental health.
This comes up every now and then. If people want to randomly zap their brains that's their prerogative, but let's call a spade a spade. I sincerely doubt that anybody will ever improve their brain by shocking their scalp.
The underlying idea is sound; deep brain stimulation, which this is sort of analogous to, is a surprising if short-lived panacea to a wide range of conditions. Applied randomly it's as likely to exacerbate a negative effect as it is to treat one, but it is generally performed by a trained neural surgeon while the patient reports on how well it's working, and it doesn't last too long anyways.
TDCS is like deep brain stimulation in that it applies a current to your brain, but the effect borders on homeopathic. It's imprecise, the charge is (happily) too weak to bring about any real change in the brain from the scalp, and I doubt it's anything more than a placebo, best case.
"I trust a lot in my intuition,” he said. “When you start doing this kind of stuff, you start to develop intuition.” He has also experimented with biofeedback tones to achieve different brainwave states and sun gazing to stimulate and heal the mind and body."
It's like punching a tv when it stops working. It can sometimes help, but in general, the method is way too crude to fix a complicated machine and can easily cause more damage.
9 comments
[ 3.0 ms ] story [ 34.3 ms ] thread[0] http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/03/01/searching-for-one-sided...
The underlying idea is sound; deep brain stimulation, which this is sort of analogous to, is a surprising if short-lived panacea to a wide range of conditions. Applied randomly it's as likely to exacerbate a negative effect as it is to treat one, but it is generally performed by a trained neural surgeon while the patient reports on how well it's working, and it doesn't last too long anyways.
TDCS is like deep brain stimulation in that it applies a current to your brain, but the effect borders on homeopathic. It's imprecise, the charge is (happily) too weak to bring about any real change in the brain from the scalp, and I doubt it's anything more than a placebo, best case.
http://diyhpl.us/~bryan/papers2/neuro/ultrasound/Histologica...
http://www.radiolab.org/story/9-volt-nirvana/
"I trust a lot in my intuition,” he said. “When you start doing this kind of stuff, you start to develop intuition.” He has also experimented with biofeedback tones to achieve different brainwave states and sun gazing to stimulate and heal the mind and body."