Can you put up a page with examples of objects and how much it cost to produce them?
I think I'm like the vast majority of people you'll see -- vaguely aware of 3D printing, but with no sense of what it can produce or how much it costs. If I could look at a page and say "gee, I'd like to make something like that item there, and that price looks reasonable" then I'd be far more likely to use it.
Education is actually a huge part of all of this, as I was in the same boat as you a year ago.
Short answer: anywhere from a few dollars to a few hundred dollars. It depends on how fine of quality you want in the part (which is also related to the particular process). If you can deal with some rough edges, it's much cheaper.
Longer answer: We're actually in the middle of making our "How it works" section much more in-depth. Something like this should be on there, especially for purposes of comparison between processes.
Will there be much discrepancy between the manufactured parts if they actually get fabricated in two separate machine shops? How precise is the equipment used in most of your participating shops?
I see you're working on the "How it Works" section and I'd love it if you had some pointers to books or frequently used applications (hopefully low cost??) for this industry.
The premise seems solid and I'm looking forward to using CloudFab!
Currently, parts will only be manufactured in one shop. We're big proponents of the 'release early, release often' mentality. So we're starting small, getting feedback, and improving. Getting bigger jobs done across shops is one of those things that is on the to do list. For that to be efficient, we'd have to be producing a fairly large batch of parts, and so we'll tackle that problem once it happens.
Well, we're accepting sellers, as well, so we'll have a pretty wide range of equipment. As of right now, we have equipment of average precision. I'm not sure if that helps, so I just grabbed an average printer from Dimension to give you a ballpark figure, and it has a .010" layer thickness. We're trying to encourage those with MakerBots to sign up, and they have a .1mm resolution.
One of the greatest blessings of 3D printers is also the greatest weakness, right? You can basically make anything. So the problem with examples is that one can make total sense to someone, and be totally foreign to someone else. To give you some ideas, I'd say check out Thingaverse, or this interview with Bram Cohen, inventor of Bittorrent: http://www.shapeways.com/blog/archives/268-Shapeways-Member-...
Thanks for the questions. We have some bigger things in the works as well. More on those later.
I work as a design engineer and regularly have parts I'm designing RPed so this looks really exciting and I look forward to something like this being available in the UK.
One of the things that we would usually do is have the RP firm finish our parts for us, painting and polishing, perhaps applying an overlay for the graphics on a screen or even vac casting to make a small batch of parts. I think it would be really important for you to allow people to request these services through the site as well.
I notice that you mentioned on the site that you will eventually supply laser and water-jet cutting as well. I think it would be good to also source machined components though the site.
We are increasingly finding that having parts prototyped in china is about half the price of having them produced here in the UK. For example a few months back I was looking to have a 400-300-200mm part prototyped that had been designed for injection molded. I cant remember the exact figures but our Chinese suppler quoted half the price for machining the component out of a solid block of plastic using a 5-axis milling machine than the local RP firm was quoting for an SLS. I hope you will allow oversees suppler to bid though the site as they are very competitive and very responsive!
Hi Sam. There's actually no reason that you couldn't use this in the UK if you wanted to; shipping costs would just end up being a bit higher. Eventually, I'm sure we'll have some international sellers on our system to help out with that as well, but baby steps!
We've talked to a few industrial design firms, and they agree with you on the finishing aspect. The issue is that unlike uploading a file, there are a _lot_ of ways that those kinds of things can be done. Imagine filling out a form on how you'd like finishing to go! So we've sort of come to a middle option. After you're quoted, but before you've accepted, there's a commenting feature that allows you to have a dialogue with the seller, so that you could ask for these kinds of things, and they could adjust their quote. We'll be looking into how to make that process easier in the future, to be sure. As you've said, it's pretty important.
I'm assuming by 'machined' components you mean subtractive processes like CNC? That'll be even farther down the support list, but yes, we'll get there at some point. The relative number of types of machines that do 3D printing and laser cutting are tiny compared to the number of CNC machines, so we figured that it would be a good beachead to start with.
We don't have any bias against having international sellers. As far as your 5x difference goes, there aren't that many SLS machines in the UK, but lots of milling machines in China. Add in the whole £ vs 元 thing, and I can certainly see how China'd come out cheaper. However, you have a lot of turn around time, and I've heard of some people having intellectual property concerns, unfounded or not.
The best thing about the Internet is that it levels the playing field for everyone!
9 comments
[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 32.3 ms ] threadIf you guys want to get in on stuff, use "hackernews" as a code so I know to give you dibs over random people.
Anybody have any questions?
I think I'm like the vast majority of people you'll see -- vaguely aware of 3D printing, but with no sense of what it can produce or how much it costs. If I could look at a page and say "gee, I'd like to make something like that item there, and that price looks reasonable" then I'd be far more likely to use it.
Short answer: anywhere from a few dollars to a few hundred dollars. It depends on how fine of quality you want in the part (which is also related to the particular process). If you can deal with some rough edges, it's much cheaper.
Longer answer: We're actually in the middle of making our "How it works" section much more in-depth. Something like this should be on there, especially for purposes of comparison between processes.
Will there be much discrepancy between the manufactured parts if they actually get fabricated in two separate machine shops? How precise is the equipment used in most of your participating shops?
I see you're working on the "How it Works" section and I'd love it if you had some pointers to books or frequently used applications (hopefully low cost??) for this industry.
The premise seems solid and I'm looking forward to using CloudFab!
Well, we're accepting sellers, as well, so we'll have a pretty wide range of equipment. As of right now, we have equipment of average precision. I'm not sure if that helps, so I just grabbed an average printer from Dimension to give you a ballpark figure, and it has a .010" layer thickness. We're trying to encourage those with MakerBots to sign up, and they have a .1mm resolution.
One of the greatest blessings of 3D printers is also the greatest weakness, right? You can basically make anything. So the problem with examples is that one can make total sense to someone, and be totally foreign to someone else. To give you some ideas, I'd say check out Thingaverse, or this interview with Bram Cohen, inventor of Bittorrent: http://www.shapeways.com/blog/archives/268-Shapeways-Member-...
Thanks for the questions. We have some bigger things in the works as well. More on those later.
One of the things that we would usually do is have the RP firm finish our parts for us, painting and polishing, perhaps applying an overlay for the graphics on a screen or even vac casting to make a small batch of parts. I think it would be really important for you to allow people to request these services through the site as well.
I notice that you mentioned on the site that you will eventually supply laser and water-jet cutting as well. I think it would be good to also source machined components though the site.
We are increasingly finding that having parts prototyped in china is about half the price of having them produced here in the UK. For example a few months back I was looking to have a 400-300-200mm part prototyped that had been designed for injection molded. I cant remember the exact figures but our Chinese suppler quoted half the price for machining the component out of a solid block of plastic using a 5-axis milling machine than the local RP firm was quoting for an SLS. I hope you will allow oversees suppler to bid though the site as they are very competitive and very responsive!
We've talked to a few industrial design firms, and they agree with you on the finishing aspect. The issue is that unlike uploading a file, there are a _lot_ of ways that those kinds of things can be done. Imagine filling out a form on how you'd like finishing to go! So we've sort of come to a middle option. After you're quoted, but before you've accepted, there's a commenting feature that allows you to have a dialogue with the seller, so that you could ask for these kinds of things, and they could adjust their quote. We'll be looking into how to make that process easier in the future, to be sure. As you've said, it's pretty important.
I'm assuming by 'machined' components you mean subtractive processes like CNC? That'll be even farther down the support list, but yes, we'll get there at some point. The relative number of types of machines that do 3D printing and laser cutting are tiny compared to the number of CNC machines, so we figured that it would be a good beachead to start with.
We don't have any bias against having international sellers. As far as your 5x difference goes, there aren't that many SLS machines in the UK, but lots of milling machines in China. Add in the whole £ vs 元 thing, and I can certainly see how China'd come out cheaper. However, you have a lot of turn around time, and I've heard of some people having intellectual property concerns, unfounded or not.
The best thing about the Internet is that it levels the playing field for everyone!