HN Explorer

Ask HN: Do you think iPhone 6 is a design copy of Samsung S5?

2 points by joaodmj ↗ HN
Today I was shocked when I hold for the first time the iPhone 6: it looked like a Samsung (!). Would Steve Jobs approve this design?

Three clear points that I just didn't like: 1. Rounded glass in the edges of the screen 2. Back camera comes out of the device... 3. Sleep/Wake button is on the side like most Samsung's (I know it's because it's taller, but the old place is iconic).

I'm exaggerating?

3 comments

[ 3.3 ms ] story [ 16.8 ms ] thread
jbrooksuk
1. Rounded glass is nice, although mine does seem to be lifting near the power button.

2. This was a silly decision IMHO. I'd have rather had a thicker device, however my leather Apple case makes this a non-problem.

3. If they'd left it at the top, people would complain that they can't naturally reach it. It's really easy to get used to and makes a lot of sense being on the side due to the size of the screen.

joaodmj
Thanks jbrooksuk. And do you think it's too big? Did you prefer the size of 5S?
jbrooksuk
Before the 6, I had a 5 and I must admit I wasn't fond of the size difference at first. However, after using it for a couple of hours it was brilliant. Just the right size for a "bigger screen" in my opinion.

A friend went for the 6+ and after using it for half an hour I hated it. But again, that's preference.