9 comments

[ 3.6 ms ] story [ 24.6 ms ] thread
I know it's not quite the same thing, but http://fivesecondtest.com is awesome for this kind of testing. Been around a while, has a very active community (so tests are done quickly).
The site looks very nice. One thing I would quickly update is your 2014 copyright date to 2015.
Yes, link it dynamically :)
My first instinct was "Not another critique site", but I took a look and the ability to get started right away reeled me in.

I have no interest in getting credits to have my own work critiqued, but the fact that it's so quick and easy to provide feedback is a smart move. Before I knew it, I'd critiqued three pages. Loading another immediately after your previous one means it's easy to get on a roll a bit like Hot or Not back in the day.

You'll either need to become a regular tool espoused by HN types, or expand to target general marketers redesigning their websites and looking for broad feedback first.

That's a fantastic tool. Getting a site critiqued by people who know what they're talking is always a wise move when you want to quickly optimize a site. But the proof of the pudding is in the eating so I'd still recommend split testing different variations. Sometimes the results will shock you.
Someone should do this for ideas. Just poorly written ideas.
Nobody wants their idea stolen, no matter how badly written it is.
Pretty neat.

I chucked mine up there and will be keen to see the feedback. Also thought the way it just keeps loading is fantastic. Easy to get on a roll as @prawn mentioned.

Just fyi, this is unusable on mobile (iPhone 6 plus).