Ask HN: Got hired for a position that doesn't exist. How do I leave?
During my last semester we had a guest lecturer in my parallel programming class. He came from a local startup which supposedly created advanced systems to assist the work of other statups.
The engineer from the startup went on and on about how each day there is a challenge and you learn so much. I decided to apply and see what would come out of it.
I went through a very tough series a interviews complete with Python puzzles and whiteboard problems. During these interviews I was reassured the job there was challenging and rewarding. I got a (generous) offer and accepted.
Fast forward to my first day and I ask my team lead what's the project I'll work on and I quickly learn that the challenging work is done in a sister office. I get told that this location mostly does very simple client facing Java Swing applications. I was devastated and almost quit on the spot. I would have if not for the fact that I have very large student debts and can't afford to not work.
Now I've been working there for a month and I've tried everything to get assigned interesting work. It's pretty much impossible since no such work is even done at my location.
How do I get myself out of this? I'm looking for other jobs already. I could omit my current position from my resume but then I'll be forced to reveal it if I get an interviews during regular office hours.
I have a friend who wants to personally refer me to work on his team at Amazon but I don't want to blow the interview. I would practice but at the end of the day I'm so burnt out from boredom and repetitive work that I can barely stay awake.
I know there are no clear cut solutions but I'm interested in hearing from people who had similar experiences.
72 comments
[ 3.2 ms ] story [ 140 ms ] threadLearn everything you can about their company. People love to talk about themselves, and their companies. What they've built, what they're doing, how cool it is, and what challenges they've faced.
You can learn more in a 20 minute conservation then in 2 hours reading their website.
All I was told about is the work done at the other locations without being told that there was a difference of course.
I tried to get to the bottom of things but apparently not hard enough.
His only mistake was not drilling down to "who will I report to and what is that group doing now?" And given that this was a bait and switch, at best he would have not gotten the job, which is mostly bad if he had other possibilities.
As other have noted, he is indeed getting an education in all sorts of other things. If he could move past the lies---not saying he should either forgive or forget---and make the best out of the current mess while finding a better job quickly, months not years, he shouldn't be too bad off.
You are young, fresh out of college, and obviously very sharp. You'll be fine, you learned a lesson that's all.
If it doesn't work out I doubt that IT is a field in general where finding a job is that difficult.
At the end of the day you have money and time on your side, I was once in a similar position and I cut back on everything social to optimise my time away from work to find a job that I really enjoyed. Good luck but try not to moan too much, even 6 months there will help dividends with finding future work. (No one wants someone that is gonna quit immediately because they don't get what they want to do all the time).
The interesting work is done in an office on the opposite coast and I can't move for family reasons.
I understand I might sound difficult but what really got me down is that the interviewer pretty much flat out told me "You will not do CRUD. Brush up on your algorithms!".
Anyway thanks again for the comment it's nice to know people were in similar situations and got themselves out of it.
Yet. Remember - your skills are an unproven commodity; performance on an interview has nothing to do with your actual abilities on real code. You're being tested now.
Many companies will not allow transfers for up to a year (including places like Amazon). If you decide to stick it out, you might be surprised what hard work will do for you.
[EDIT] Noticed the family bit after posting; these kinds of issues will resolve themselves with time as well. Remote work is possible, and if this is a startup, they may be more willing to accommodate your living restrictions, letting you work with colleagues who aren't in your office.
Its also possible that they plan to expand their "difficult" work into the other office; I just watched a company in my town here completely take over the bulk of development work from the home office, solely on the backs of a few skilled and perseverant individuals.
Also, the hard truth is that most programming is not exciting and really is just what you described, building CRUD apps. Further, who knows what you would have been doing if you were at that other office. You're a junior developer and nobody is going to give you particularly exciting or sexy tasks on day one or day 365.
An extension of this is every developer regardless of level ends up getting the algorithms questions and mind games because it is the only way most engineers know how to interview.
Unless the company is still very small (3-5 people), most of the people you talk to in an interview won't have any control over what you are working on anyway. They will probably be your peers and tell you what they are working on, but don't take that as an indication of your role unless you hear it from the person you'll be reporting to.
Outside of work I code the stuff I don't get a chance to do at work, get a cool idea and work on it in github/bit bucket etc. Once you've had the 6months plus at the company combined with some project work on a passionate personal project you'll find the programming world will offer you more opportunities than you thought possible! Chin up! :)
It's a job, not a playground. Jobs can be cool, but you need to work on that.
> so burnt out from boredom and repetitive work that I can barely stay awake.
Boring work alone won't do that to you. There's something else here, are you working overtime?
Perhaps exercise a bit to get your energy levels up. Sensible dinner (no junk food) and maybe after that you have some energy to work on things that you care about.
Perhaps if you can breeze through your day and not let it bother you since you have student debt you could spend your evenings coding or a projects that truly interests you.
If you really want the challenging problems at work I'd say you do need to find a new job.
In the next interview, you can be honest and say that "I like to get more challenges, and I feel I can do more than what I have done". True and to the point.
One of my earlier jobs was such that I applied for an interesting job to work on SQL applications in Unix environment, at XYZ, the largest publishing house in the country; I did not get that job but they put me to a team that worked on a useless Christmas card address register using dBase IV on MS-DOS. Afterwards, what I could say was that "I worked on database solutions with XYZ company, and while I liked the working environment, I'm looking for some more challenging tasks". Got me into a job where I stayed for 20 years and 1 day.
The world of "startups" is filled to the brim with charlatans. "Everybody's killing it." Be skeptical; even the "good" companies aren't all they're made out to be.
That said, start lining something else up while you make a little money and learning what you can. No big deal. Here's some advice: people care way too much about their "career path". There are more important things in life. If you're smart and capable, jobs and money will always come easy. This will be a mere blip on your radar.
Sounds like you were sold a pup, but this is firmly in your hands. You're in a (relatively) fortunate position:
Your daily work is so easy it's actually boring, you say. Plenty of time, then, to try little POCs in other languages, to do some self study on the internet, or to perhaps involve yourself in client-facing meetings or other aspects of the company's work, if that sounds appealing. Use the slack to broaden your skills.
An easy job means you leave on time. Go home, do some exercise, eat a healthy meal, then spend a few hours each evening working on personal projects in a much more exciting stack. Instant energy.
You can spend part of your work day thinking about you side projects as well, maybe researching whatever technique or library you need next (but be careful not to do any actual work - your contract likely forbids this).
And spend some time looking for a new job too of course.
Basically, don't give this job your everything. Do the work that's required of you and like the parent thread says leave yourself a bunch of energy. A technique that's worked out well for myself and other friends in the past is taking the first couple hours of each day to do personal projects and then go into work.
Don't give them the best hours of your day.
I'm often the first to say "pay your dues" to complaining youngsters, but OP has done nothing wrong and instead seems to need some guidance on how to maximize the value of his/her days while working out of this unlucky decision.
All I would say is that it's important that OP does try to find another, more engaging job, either in that company or elsewhere. It would be a shame to develop a permanently half-assed work ethic at 21, especially when he/she seems to have the energy and moral fibre to work hard. Treat this as a short-term situation.
I would start interviewing as soon as possible. Don't worry about blowing the interview at Amazon, you can try again in 2 years. You'd do well to read the interview questions at glassdoor.com, they often ask the same questions (I interviewed there), but don't think that you should postpone it and spend the time learning. Just apply again in a year, it's not like you are a very capable learner when you're burned out.
You shouldn't be ashamed of your current job; it's well paid, it can be done well and professionally, and probably it can be more creative than you think.
My advice is just to float your resume out to recruiters and keep looking for other jobs, which you are already doing. If you can keep the job you have and still make it to interviews, don't quit.
Staying busy writing Java Swing applications isn't a black mark by any means. I think it would be harder to explain a period of unemployment than a period of underemployment.
My first dev job out of college was at a startup (not in SV), and there was only dev work for the first 2 years. After that, all responsibilities were taken on by the lead dev, and we juniors were left with no work at all. Nada, zip. The salary was just enough to live on, and no one was allowed any raises. I took on a QA role and the other junior just bided his time taking MOOCs. QA wasn't for me, but I did it for almost a whole year until I couldn't stand it anymore and quit. I actually planned on becoming a truck driver, because the starting salary was about $5-10k more than what I was making as a dev. But I sent my resume out one more time and ended up getting a great Rails job in another city through a recruiter. So I didn't actually do trucking.
You've had a tough break but the only way you're going to get through it is with effort on your part.
Decide where you want to be in six months and come up with a plan to get there. Then just work it, work it, work it.
If you can't move directly into another position then start a project on the side that you find interesting and can be shown to prospective employers or may turn into something you can grow.
You need to avoid feeling sorry for yourself. It's not going to help. It's only going to weigh you down and make you a drag to be around. Prospective employers and partners will pick up on that and will be turned off by it.
Welcome to the workforce.
The fact that you nailed a well paying job out of college should be considered a blessing/miracle/massive gift...not a burden.
Work your ass off for several years and prove your worth. In reality, a degree means almost nothing in the workforce...it's just the price of admission.
Real world experience is worth more than gold.
Prove you have what it takes over the long term - and THEN start bitching about not being on cool projects :P
Now is the time to spend an hour a day developing your own skills on your own pet project.
You also have quite a few years before I would consider yourself a 'good' developer. Even 21 years later I'm still learning new stuff almost daily.
Challenge yourself. If work isn't challenging, then it's your responsibility.
1) Being in debt sucks. Become incredibly passionate about the idea of never being in debt again. If you don't have a giant student loan weighing around your neck, you are far more free to pursue work that interests you. So what to do? Come up with a plan in your favorite evolution of Visicalc, complete with how much debt you're going to pay off each month so that you can put a date on the calendar about when you're going to be debt free. Even if you're doing soul-draining work, knowing that that work is getting you one step closer to being free from debt should help.
2) Your current situation isn't as bad as it seems. I work with a ton of devs for whom working at a cool startup was their first real job. Awesome for them! Also totally not in line with most people's reality. Most people start in some version of "the bottom," whether that be in terms of low salary or poor culture, and then they maneuver their way through a couple of jobs until they find work they really enjoy. If you are smart and get things done, you'll do this too.
So your interviewer lied to you, exposing a toxic part of the company culture. They'll probably lose you over it and you'll eventually end up in a place you prefer to work.
Just come up with a plan to get out of debt. That can move your career a lot closer to freedom than you may think.
I'd just stick with it and keep looking. Be honest with the places you interview with when they ask why you are looking after so short of a time - the job is not what it was represented to me and despite my trying I can't fix it; and as a recent college grad with student loans I can't afford to leave while I'm searching. There's no need to try to hide this on your resume - it's better to be honest and explain it than try to hide something. Employers are people too and they will understand that.
My biggest piece of advice is don't give your notice at your current place until you have a written offer in hand for a new position.
Ay my first year review, my boss called me out on it, and I said, "am I getting my work done?" He couldn't deny it.
I continued this for another year. At my second year review, my boss did something I still think is brilliant. He'd been following what I'd been learning, and asked if I couldn't use my new knowledge of building web apps to solve an in-house problem.
I spent the third year working extra hours, building a web app but for the company. Everyone was happy.
I've never been a good employee, so YMMV, but CYA, and let it be their problem. If they fire you, there are always other jobs. You'll get out of debt eventually.
I'm not understanding this part. If you land an interview can't you take a day off for it?
- Take care of your immediate responsibilities first (rent, food, loan payments, etc)- this is non-negotiable unless you have a golden parachute (i.e. mom & dad). It's quite honorable to work for survival.
- Always keep an eye out for a better job, the more interviews you go on the easier they will be. Never be satisfied where you are if personal growth is important to you.
- NEVER expect to just be given the most interesting work out of the gate at a new job. That's not the way it works. You generally have to prove yourself. If they are not delivering on a promise that may be a separate concern, but I'd be skeptical of a job that would give a rookie dev the "interesting" work (which is usually the architecture work).
- Identify problems at work and solve them in your free time, then present them to the appropriate people; that is the best way to fast track your own interesting work. Note the politics of your company and be sure to not step on any toes.
- Most importantly, do your own interesting work on the side. Start a company, create/contribute/maintain an open source project. I can't stress enough the incredible opportunities that exist for skilled developers that have some initiative.
- Get in a good routine that works to accomplish your short and long term goals, it's unusual for a job to satisfy that entirely.
What does that even mean? It's necessary sure, it can also be a smart strategy, but honorable? You don't owe them anything and staying for 'honor' is foolish imo.
If your parents are supportive and you are looking for a CS degree, only work at McDonalds if you feel like a life experience - probably not a bad idea.
If you have opportunity to get a zero interest loan from your parents or free bedroom with no external judgement (ie, supportive parents), that is a far better standpoint to spend your days working full-time at getting a job in your field.
I've been in your position before. Well, sort of. At the time, I hated seeking advice and getting responses along the lines of, "Well, that sucks. But just make the most of it." But there's really something to that advice. Make the most of it, and in the meantime, conduct a job search.
The good news is that you're an engineer! I cannot possibly overstate what an advantageous position that puts you in with respect to 99.99% of job seekers on the market. If you were anything else——a salesperson, a marketer, a corporate strategist, or what have you——your situation would be a lot thornier than it is. At least take some solace in that your line of work is in high demand.
I'm about to quit my job with the aim of starting up my own company. I don't have a lot of non-tech contacts - i.e. potential customers and angel investors. That is my biggest worry.
I can't really bootstrap while on the job since I am currently in a large corporate job where the company owns everything I dream up.
So .. while I agree with all the advice about not quitting a job until one has another one lined up (I've given the same advice to others) ... I am about to go against this advice myself.
Any words of advice on how to manage this? Am I bonkers? Some stats ... have 6 months of living costs in liquid savings. No kids. Going to be leaving a job that pays north of 120K (which is not much in elite companies it seems).
She bootstrapped while on the job. I am not 100% sure how she managed that vis-a-vis her employer, but I'm guessing that she had a conversation with them and put her cards on the table, and that they came to an agreement of some sort. Incidentally, IANAL, but my understanding of those workplace IP agreements is that they only cover inventions and ideas you come up with "in the course of performing your job," or something to that effect. They do not cover nights and weekends. Read your contract's fine print, though, because there have been horror stories here.
Hit me up over email (address in my profile) if you're interested in speaking to my friend about her experience. I'm also happy to help as best I can.
1. Make sure you've told your boss that you are not being challenged and that you really want to work on something that will challenge you. Perhaps you have already done this, but I still mention it because sometimes we can have a difficult time being direct and saying exactly what we mean. Make sure that they know you are grateful for the position but from what you were told during the hiring process, you were going to have more challenges. This may help you get the challenges you were looking for, but even if it doesn't it will help you when you need to explain why you have to leave. (If you have to leave, exit gracefully. I cannot emphasize this enough.)
2. Make sure you're open to challenges. Are there other challenges around you that you can work on? Sometimes the best challenges are not the ones you go looking for. Sometimes the best lessons come from unexpected challenges.
3. Keep open to new places and don't hide what you're doing. Explain clearly why you would be leaving - you were told that it would be challenging but once hired that changed. Honesty is your best policy here because hiding anything will be a red flag to anyone who scrutinizes your experience.
Not very original, but I hope it helps.