Ask HN: How to move beyond “freelancer”?
Last year, I had a client (who had their own client...which we'll call the "true client") for a big project. At the beginning of the project, upon receiving my quote, my client told me that it was "way above" what the true client was willing to pay. I asked for more clear budget numbers, and was told very clearly that it was 60% of my original quote. After days of negotiations, I ended up reducing my quote considerably. Keep in mind, this did NOT involve me reducing my rate; I know better.
Part-way through the project, I found out that not only was my original quote under the true client's budget, but my client had also quoted them a price which was 3 times my original quote amount. Not only that...but they had used my quote to create their own, and then proceeded to cut me down farther.
I felt undervalued and belittled by the news. I wasn't upset about another company profiting off of me (of course that's going to happen by default, if I'm working through an intermediary). Rather, I was really bothered by the nickel-and-diming and flat-out lies I was told about the project's constraints and budget.
Since that time, I've paid closer attention to the companies I work with. They're consistently profiting off of me at ridiculous rates; however, if I raise my rates to compensate, I don't get work. I've tried to form my own "digital agency" with another partner...but we had a harder time finding work as a new agency than as freelancers.
TL;DR: I'm tired of being nickel-and-dimed, and want to move beyond the "freelancer" title. How did you become the digital agency that you are today? How did you drop the "freelancer" title and make something more of your daily life?
124 comments
[ 3.2 ms ] story [ 168 ms ] threadAlas this also means that I often need to actually turn up to the clients office.
Working though an agency has similar issues, as you describe, but let's face it - no-one likes paying their bills or pay the full whack for stuff.
It's just the cost of doing business.
The only way (that I can see) to totally escape is to actually make something other people will want to buy and sell direct.
There are many consultants (myself included) who make a living consulting, have fantastic clients, work remotely, and are able to deliver massive value to those clients without having to work through middle-men.
However when you're having a bad period, or just get tired of it all, the temptation to pack up and do something else can be very tempting :)
tirrellp makes a good point, though. I guess that's how?
There is no secret trick to getting those first clients. It's a scary suck for most people who build successful consultancies. The "trick" is in carefully and aggressively exploiting those hard-to-get first clients in order to make subsequent clients easier and easier to get.
1. At university there was a billboard for people looking for developers.
2. Responded to everyone, with a ridiculously low price of $25.
3. Completed first job with flying colors. Collect glowing reference.
4. Stitch up reference on to personal website.
5. Hike price by 50%, find next client.
6. Rinse and repeat.
I got up to $100 per hour for some clients[1], or $450 per day for other clients, before I finally found a full time developer job.
I'm glad I did this freelancing thing because my company knows I can walk any time and make 6-figures on my own.
I still get pinged by my former clients about new projects and refer them to friends.
[1] (I was offered $115 one time but I felt that was too much of a raise - I priced myself at the highest possible rate where I am certain I will receive a glowing reference. And glowing references means raises.)
P.S. I read patio11 and tptacek's advice at the time it was very useful.
As a consultant it's rare I had engagements lasting more than a couple of months. At a company there's more of a "narrative". It's like reading short stories vs reading a novel, both are good at various times.
Some random things I learnt from the transition :
- The most interesting projects rarely (mostly never) relies on a one person "team". Big projects are important for the customer and they need to know they will have someone to contact even if it's holiday time. You want the true customer to buy from you interesting projects : don't be alone.
- Once you have a team, you will look for interesting projects. They are more complicated to get. They often come from medium / large organization. Those orgs. have important inertia. Projects can take weeks of month to start. Chase multiple projects at the same time.
- Once you have bigger project you must learn to make precise time evaluation. It is really complicated. It must be done before the project is sold but you must not spend too much time on it. It is key since you want to earn money (no brainer) but mostly to have a smooth production calendar.
In my case, we are just a team of two. I spend half time in sales activities and the other developing websites. My coworker is full time dev.
If you want to discuss in details, reply here or email me : paul@agence-donatello.fr
Good luck ! There are freakingly high mountains of demands and needs outside. You can take your piece.
A few of the most successful freelancers I know have formed 2-3 person partnerships. All of the partners were individual freelancers before, but teaming up allows them to tackle bigger projects, and reassure clients that a holiday or sick time won't stop their project.
Every project still needs some project and client management, but overall it seems that the time each partner spends on "management" is actually reduced in this format.
The TLDR is: package a small part of your expertise as a product, and sell it as a SaaS. Having dependable recurring revenue is a game changer.
What are you doing to find work directly?
1. Go to technical meetup/groups relating to technology you're interested in. Get known in that community.
2. Go to technical meetup/groups relating to technology you're NOT interested in. Get known in the community. With PHP and Java skills, I go to the .NET group a few times a year. When some of those folks I network with need PHP, I'm the first (and sometimes only) person they think of.
3. Go to industry group meetings that relate to a particular industry you want to serve - education, govt, manufacturing, retail, etc. Learn who's doing what, what their terms are, etc. Start making connections there.
4. Go out of your way to connect people in your existing network who you think might be able to benefit each other. Invite them for a mutual coffee, make introductions. See what happens.
5. If there's not any sort of meetup in your area that doesn't cater to your interests, start one, and publicize it. If it's successful, you'll be one of the 'go to' folks for that topic in your area.
There are many other steps and paths to follow; this is just one I point out to people.
For me and most of the folks I know this isn't a fast process, but it does have payoffs over the long haul.
Happy to take this offline at mgkimsal@gmail.com if you or others want to dig a bit deeper.
Also, on point #2, make a concerted effort to find unrelated people that you can refer work to. When I get .net projects crossing my path, I have 3 people I immediately can hand off to (depending on their schedule). Make part of the networking purpose at those meetings to find people you can refer work to first.
Specialize and partner up. If we use a webdev for example, he might specialize in marketing. Shopping cart platforms, Survey/Forms software, SEO/PPC agencies, basically everything that tangentially touches web development in that particular field. Instead of marketing, you might try HR and go for Companies that resell Sharepoint, Alfresco, Opentext, recruiting agencies, etc. The possibilities are endless.
Carve out a niche that has well-paying clients. Do some cool stuff on your website to showcase your skills. Start outreaching for companies in that niche. Keep in touch with them and mention from time to time that you're looking to build a clientbase. Referrals and/or subcontracts will fly your way. You will also get visitors on your site from SEO/social. In the meantime, you can straight-out cold email target customers with sales literature. It might sound silly, but it works if you're smart about it.
You will build a large enough network to fill all your hours in no time.
But what you described is another part of networking - finding other people in the field who can get you work, and becoming a partner to them - either for direct referral or subcontract work, or just pre done services.
Niching is certainly my recommendation - one of my points was to find a particular industry you want to serve, then focus on that - f2f meetings in that industry is just one aspect of it (but can also open a lot of doors quickly - one mention from a f2f contact 2 weeks ago turned us on to a whole network of related professionals that need a service we're working on).
Excellent points :)
You need to hire a couple people to write code, and start selling full time. This is where things get hard. I haven't made it work correctly yet either. Good luck!
Edit: Wow. In the small sample on Audible this guy already mentions something I've seen over and over with the clients I work with.
When you start your company you go from employee to business owner. But your mind stays in employee mode. You keep doing your job just like an employee. You get over worked (those 80 hour weeks) and never thrive.
Everything you do needs to involve building a process to hand off to someone else. Otherwise you are simply substituting a 40 hour work week for an 80 hour work week.
Derek Sivers also discusses this issue in Anything You Want (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1936719118), which one of my favorite books, ever, and highly recommended.
One of the best books out there on how to build and grow a business.
Otherwise you will hire the cheapest labor -which is yourself...and you'll never break free of being a freelancer.
My personal advice...the reason raising your rates isn't working for you is because "you don't get the work." This is key...if you need the work, you will never successfully raise your rates.
I have fetched $350/hr for SEM consulting...when you can easily hire an experienced pro for $50 and someone more experienced than me for $175. How do I charge that much? It's simple. My opportunity cost let's me turn down lower paying gigs.
The secret to winning a negotiation is going in believeing you can walk away without feeling like you missed out. If you can walk away....you are in the driver's seat.
"The power to destroy a thing is the absolute control over it."
Well said and always works. In every business.
Car dealers would absolutely hate for people to know that.
A few years back, it took me half a day researching and half a day visiting two dealers to get the car I wanted, at a reasonable price: I think it was in the 90% percentile cheaper in true car's range, even though I bought my car in SF bay area, which is supposedly more expensive than the average price.
Recently I went through the car buying experience. Here's what have happened. I did some research online to see the models and the prices of the car. Then I started with Costco's car buying program, which referred me to a dealer. Went to the dealership to test drive, and negotiated to a price that they won't sell. I walked. Went online and emailed all the dealerships in the area for a quote on the car spec I gave. One of the dealers actually emailed back with a quote below the test-driven dealer's price. Went over to pick up the car.
You're being nickel-and-dimed because you don't value yourself enough. Stop charging hourly rates and stop working for middlemen.
[0] http://www.kalzumeus.com/2011/10/28/dont-call-yourself-a-pro...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4245960#up_4247615
The "true client" proves there's business for you to get which will pay you what you want to be paid. Go out and find the customers. That's really what it comes down to.
I found that the key was to find clients who value your work. Working with individuals or small businesses can be tough because they are usually highly constrained by budget and do not understand everything that goes in to what you do. They want freelancers because they can't afford full time people. They will compare you to the rates they can find on Craigslist or Elance and balk when you require market rates.
Instead, find startups with technical people doing the recruiting or large companies with established roles and processes for freelancers. They will at least understand market rates and what you actually do.
You also need to have the power to say no to clients. That usually means savings and the willingness to wait long periods between jobs in order to find the right one. For me, the hit rate of was 1 out of every 8-10 job opportunities.
Some days is 4 hours, some days its 8 hours, some days it's 10 hours. Do more 4 hour days. You're probably only productive for the time period, anyway.
Both are better than hourly billing!
For newer freelancers, it's important to be able to establish an hourly rate that meets your financial goals. For most, that would include a salary, expenses and then profit for your business. After you're receiving steady work at your base rate, you can start experimenting with daily billing, project based billing, increasing your hourly rate and so forth. But it takes time to get there.
For larger projects, there's inevitably scope creep and project based billing can be dangerous. I've been burned a number of times on large projects and now I put a "10% overage" clause in my estimates. If the time to completion is more than 10% over my estimate the project immediately jumps into hourly billing. It opens up a conversation very early on and sets an expectation that my work is not an open checkbook.
I've also found this to be very true.
When I'm evaluating clients I consider whether or not the person writing the check is using their own money. More mature clients often have a marketing director or employee that has a budget. With entrepreneurs and small businesses, you're often speaking to the owner and they tend to care more about how much something costs. It's just more difficult.
1. Jim Camp's negotiation book, "Start with No": http://www.amazon.com/Start-No-Negotiating-Tools-that-ebook/... One key takeaway: You can refuse to compromise on your rates, provided that you can afford to walk away if necessary.
2. Patrick McKenzie's (patio11's) advice for moving beyond the "freelancer" title, in particular http://www.kalzumeus.com/2011/10/28/dont-call-yourself-a-pro... and http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/09/17/ramit-sethi-and-patrick-...
I used these strategies to double my daily rate as an Ember.js consultant from $1k to $2k, and it was a fairly straightforward exercise in the end.
Edit: This appears to be a newer edition, and one that's available as an ebook: http://www.amazon.com/Start-No-Negotiating-Tools-that-ebook/...
This is very important advice, and I've applied it to car purchases, condo lease agreements, cable and phone contracts, you name it.
It's about leverage. If you have alternatives, and what the person on the other side of the table offers doesn't fit your needs, take your business elsewhere. You have to be prepared to leave or say no.
On the other hand, if you can't say no, then you don't have any leverage.
The key is the perception of the other party, not the actual reality of whether you can say no or not.
Robert Ringer's amazing (and must read) book, "Winning Through Intimidation." Talks about how he manufactured the perception of being able to walk away, and why image and perception are more important than actual circumstances.
It's of course much simpler to play the part of being able to say no, when you can actually walk away...but you can hack your own perception to believe you can walk away even if you can't, and pull it off... or you can be a good actor and take some risks...
Either way... The premise is true...but it's more about the story you are selling than anything else.
My favorite quote from the book is...
"I didn't mean to cut off your hands, but I had no choice when you reached for my chips." This is his argument for DEMANDING a contract for every business deal, especially with friends or people you trust. (I admit I am not great at this...)
He opens with a theory that most successful people who claim "hard work and a positive attitude" drive success are lying. They are either too embarrassed to admit how easy it was for them...or they can't see the forest from the trees and really have no idea why they are successful.
He has a few key points that really stand out for me...
"The results you get from a negotiation are inversely proportionate to how intimidated you are."
"With every deal...The key is to hope for a good result, but expect a negative one. (otherwise you will get discouraged way too quickly and give up.)
Image is everything... "It’s Not What You Say Or Do That Counts, But What Your Posture Is When You Say Or Do it."
I wrote a few blog posts over the years about his book... http://www.davidmelamed.com/2012/11/19/robert-ringers-theory...
http://www.davidmelamed.com/2012/11/20/i-really-didnt-mean-t...
Edit: I have a few extra copies. Would be happy to mail one to the first two people who ask. Just find my email on my profile and email me.
Do you have a link to amazon? I'm willing to buy the book and give you a little profit while doing so.
http://www.amazon.com/Winning-Through-Intimidation-Robert-Ri... (Non affiliate link)
UPDATE:
I actually have a Prime account and Kindle so I was able to read the book for free using the Kindle Owners Lending Library.
http://www.amazon.com/Winning-Through-Intimidation-Robert-Ri... (kindle edition link affiliate free)
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KQZU7SY/ref=as_li_tl?ie=... (kindle edition link with affiliate id)
I highly recommend Winning Through Intimidation. It's not about what you think. I read it after someone else recommended it in another discussion on HN.
http://www.amazon.com/Winning-Through-Intimidation-Robert-Ri...
UPDATE: After posting this I read the sibling comments and see someone else also recommended the book. Seriously, read it!
Yes. You can try to bluff, but someone might call you.
People have suggested building our own product. That is all well and good, and honestly at some point you will want to stop selling your time because your time is finite and can't be scaled. That's when product development becomes more attractive. But if you are still having fun writing other peoples stuff and just want to get out of a rut and increase your rate then you can do that.
Pricing is a skill, we charge weekly rates (based on 32hrs) per person and honestly most clients equate that to an hourly rate in the end. We also set a minimum charge for all projects and bill based upon value delivered instead of hours when appropriate, for example, we just picked up a small project < 1 week in duration where we charged $7k. Every time a potential client starts trying to negotiate our rate down, I move the conversation to value and most of the time I can win solid deals and I don't negotiate my rate down. I have in the past, but once someone knows you will negotiate your rate, they will always go for more and you end up in a death spin to the bottom.
1. Word-of-mouth.
2. I do grant writing for nonprofit and public agencies, and we occasionally get pitches for the "true client," and we always tell the would-be middlemen to just send the true client to us. This almost never happens, and in reality there is rarely a true client, and even if there is the middleman won't pay our rate because we're already near the top of the market (see point 4).
3. You might not be able to move beyond "freelancer" without getting a conventional job or starting a startup.
4. If you can't find a way to charge more you may have found the market rate for what you're doing and who you're doing it for. In my consulting firm ~$200/hour is the top market rate. We can't functionally charge more.
5. I don't want to be a jerk, but I wonder how your sales and marketing skills rank. I wrote more about that issue here: http://jakeseliger.com/2014/04/07/how-i-learned-about-assert.... In many small consulting firms, sales and marketing are at least as important as product. Have you thought about hiring a business or voice coach? What's your sales funnel like?
I do know that we're in the process of hiring a firm to re-do our website, and we found a couple through http://wpengine.com/partners/ and one through our ISP. One guy we sent an email to, and he said he didn't talk on the phone. Not surprisingly he's off the list: If he's that uninterested or busy before we send him a lot of money, what's he going to be like after?. We found an outfit named Orange Blossom: http://orangeblossommedia.com/ that has an impressive portfolio, and they seemed to understand the non-standard stuff we needed. CohoWeb: http://cohoweb.com/ is another favorite, and they came through our ISP. In both cases their sales guys were efficient.
Clients often have a hard time evaluating consultants. That's one reason we've been writing a blog for the last seven years: We're professional writers, and the blog does at least show that we can write, and it also attracts a lot of potential clients via search traffic. How are your clients finding you?
If your sales and marketing are not very hot—and I'm not saying that, but I am saying it's possible—you may want to consider trying to work for Orange Blossom or someone else on the WP-Engine list.
You simply build your brand, including a website, a blog and attract people to it. Get known widely (by having content that people share) and deeply (through good work and referrals). This takes time to build. But it's like any other brand.
Basically, you need a brand, and cultivate relationships. Probably the best two pieces of advice I can give you are:
1) Make it safe to fail, so you can iterate and try better things. For example, have 100 users and only try a particular pricing or offer with 5 of them. A/B test various website designs, email marketing strategies, etc. Partner with one or more business developers who are passionate about client relations, and give them % of PROJECTS, not the company. This way, if anything fails, it doesn't bring down the whole thing. And you can do this "all day" because your expected value is always nonzero, so the more you do it, the more you get. You can even hire others to do your job for you - again, on commission. Like 2 levels of MLM.
2) Establish relationships before you need them. Network, and let people know what you need without pushing them. Over time when you really need something, you do 90% of the work (set up the whole experience etc) and let them know how they can be of help by doing only 10% of the work. Something simple and well-defined that starts off your onboarding process. Inbound leads basically, and "warm introductions".
First of all, pick a niche industry and own it. Too many agencies I see are just out to make money by developing as many apps and sites as possible. This means a lot of cold calling into different industries and talking to a lot of different people with different needs. If you stick with one industry, pretty soon, you'll find areas where you can really start to focus. This in turn makes you valuable to not only business, but then your name starts to get passed around since you have specific ways you're helping other people in that industry. Less cold calling and more referrals is what follows then. I would also start locally, get as many customers in your local niche then broaden out, go regional, then national.
Secondly, the one thing that has made my agency successful is minimizing overhead. It's basically me and my partner. We work from our homes, but are in constant contact with each other (technology is great ain't it?). This means, no employees to pay, no office rent, no heating bills, no additional hardware or furniture. It allows us to keep our rates fairly low and still have a very nice profit margin since we have so little upfront costs. This also benefits our clients since it saves them money too.
Lastly, I use a progressive billing system. I start out working with my clients on an hourly rate - mainly doing consultation work. Then once we start having steady work, I go to them and say, "Hey, you're paying a lot for my hourly rate since and we're always doing work for you, why don't we just set up a monthly total (a 5-8% discount off my hourly rate) with a minimum of hours I need to work for your company each month and go from there?" 90% of our clients have switched over to a monthly or yearly billing subscription. This is a biggie since you don't have to worry so much about where your next project is coming from, you can really focus on your clients and know you have a steady stream of revenue coming in. This also allows you to continue to cold call and bring in new business - makes a huge difference compared to working project to project.
Hope this helps!
wrapping your head around this and going without a paycheck is tough. most people aren't tough enough to deal with it, including you, until now. this is why agencies can charge 200% markup on your estimate AND screw you for 40% on the backend.
i mean literally, so what? do you want to make the money, or not? nobody is going to hand it to you. you have to go out and find it. you're competing with people with no kids, no debt, no spouse, and plenty of savings. tough cookies.
if you don't want to risk it, then don't. going on your own is not for people who sit around all day and think of reasons why they can't do something.
Build and sell your own product or service. This also will carry way higher residual value than hit-and-run freelancing gigs.
I'm getting my cofounders to read it now, I first read it 12 years ago, and I still think it's the single best introduction to business and sales skills I've seen, despite having read a LOT of such books before, during and since my MBA. Good luck with the business!
How good are your communication skills? In consulting/freelance/contract this is huge. You will never be able to charge as much as someone who has great rapport with the customer, articulates points in a clear way, and shows understanding of the big picture goals.
How big are the companies you work with? As a rule of thumb small companies are not usually paying the highest rates. Small companies have more interesting work, but pick your poison.
What percentile are you capabilities in? This requires some brutal self honesty but usually it's harder to get top rates if you are not at the top of your field.
Do you try to work remote? Jobs usually pay more if you are willing to stay on site most of the time. Hate this but it's true.
Do you have an impressive portfolio of work to show? When people see it do they "ok, thanks", or do they say "wow that's really cool"?
The good news is you can change and improve everything on this list.
If you don't have a huge history as a 'company', that's not a weakness, because you can pay more attention to each new client you get.