> To publish your idea, you should craft the smallest possible publishable unit
This is good. It encourages publications that are more like the web, and less like Xanadu.
> Maybe your paper would get ranked into class A, B, C or D, maybe you’d get some score on a 5 or 10 point scale.
The constrained resource here is reviewers. A typical submission is read by what, three reviewers? In which case we really don't have the resolution to justify some more precise scale.
1 comment
[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 10.0 ms ] threadThis is good. It encourages publications that are more like the web, and less like Xanadu.
> Maybe your paper would get ranked into class A, B, C or D, maybe you’d get some score on a 5 or 10 point scale.
The constrained resource here is reviewers. A typical submission is read by what, three reviewers? In which case we really don't have the resolution to justify some more precise scale.