[dead]
« spontaneous » I'll add that the entire vocabulary used today is totally misleading. The standard term is "Überfall auf Polen". Well, that sounds like "surprise attack", which is impossible anyway. Poland had fully…
Thanks for a thoughtful reply. « Hitler's invasion into Poland … Humanitarian » There's no such thing as a "humanitarian military invasion". There were pogroms against Germans in Poland, and thousands of refugees…
« 99% 9/11 » Here's some of the glaring WTFs about 9/11: • no plane at the Shanksville site • no plane at the Pentagone • aluminium planes ("eggshells") shown on TV going cookie-cutter style through steel girders • WTC…
Concerning the JFK assassination, maybe in Germany there's a majority that is "okay" with the "LHO did it alone" claim. But only among people who are not interested in the case, of course. As for the USA, I'm sure (and…
« If a massive object came into the solar system and perturbed orbits, caused chaos and collisions, then any "planet" with debris within its neighborhood would cease to be a planet. » Major impacts on Earth on a regular…
[repost of 50464331 b/c comment was censored, probably b/o link] « lol, lmao at the idea Hitler was invading for any reason related to humanitarianism » You're laughing because you don't know about the August crisis…
« ideologically driven … quoting the cold war soviets … credible to me! » See? You put ideology first. "Soviets = bad", so quoting them is bad, too. Ideology first, hence facts don't matter any more. And this is not an…
« every fact which is part of the commonly narrative must ipso facto be false » Such an approach would of course be completely misguided. OTOH, the official narrative does contain lies and omits a lot of facts in many…
Okay, I wasn't thinking about the first Olympics before Berlin 1936 (where Jesse Owens won the 100 meters), and never studied historical statistics. I'd say that back then there were likely socio-environmental factors…
HN user rramadass in 50451133 this morning: « Most people just look at the surface level of what is presented to them and don't really think about anything (unless forced by circumstances). In spite of the fact that we…
« I don't see » Perhaps because you don't want to? Some people put ideology first. Many more use ideological vocabulary as the baseline of their reasoning, which is how people are educated in Western societies. So do…
« any science » — What? Is that supposed to be a joke? Ever heard of the olympics? Ever seen any world-class competition, in sprint or marathon? The former is dominated by West Africans (or the descendants of the negro…
« They did talk … » I haven't read the transcripts, but I remember reading about Weizsäcker stating that they went outside whenever they didn't want the British to listen in on their conversations, simply because they…
« rigging the numbers » Excellent point about how "a rigorous quantitative approach based on official documents" can lead to wrong results and flawed conclusions… :)
History is written by the victors, and Hitler is for our day's historiography as Hannibal for Roman history. It's a cover story to justify insatiable greed and lust for control. Hitler lacked prudence, and his rise was…
« the more you realize just how bad the Nazis were at the economy » Funny thing is that Germans back then didn't realize that at all. On the contrary, they were – by and large – really happy with Hitler, and that was…
Wonderful indeed (I didn't know him), a treasure-trove of (un)common sense and humanity, encouraging amid the AI extinction event.
« more like gratitude that the Allies couldn't hang him for working on an atomic bomb » Why would they have done that? Hadn't they themselves been "working on an atomic bomb"? Wernher von Braun wasn't hanged either…
Funny though that at "Operation Crossroads" in July 1946, the US was still trying to convince the Soviet Union, which they had invited to send a delegation, that the atomic thing was real. They apparently still didn't…
And if "the Bomb" was so overpowering and decisive, as immediately claimed by US propaganda, then why did the US attack again on Aug 14/15, using pumpkin bombs¹, in a " Grand Finale" ? Here's Yozo Kudo, general…
[repost b/o deletion/suppression] « This is alternative history, not real history. » Okay, but "real history" is full of lies, so that per se cannot be an argument against "alternative history". Which is not to say that…
« Most of the main directions of advance by Germany and Japan were trying to get access to the 15% of the worlds oil they could get to (Romania, Baku and Indonesia). » This is the key to understand WW2. The oil, and the…
[dead]
« spontaneous » I'll add that the entire vocabulary used today is totally misleading. The standard term is "Überfall auf Polen". Well, that sounds like "surprise attack", which is impossible anyway. Poland had fully…
Thanks for a thoughtful reply. « Hitler's invasion into Poland … Humanitarian » There's no such thing as a "humanitarian military invasion". There were pogroms against Germans in Poland, and thousands of refugees…
« 99% 9/11 » Here's some of the glaring WTFs about 9/11: • no plane at the Shanksville site • no plane at the Pentagone • aluminium planes ("eggshells") shown on TV going cookie-cutter style through steel girders • WTC…
Concerning the JFK assassination, maybe in Germany there's a majority that is "okay" with the "LHO did it alone" claim. But only among people who are not interested in the case, of course. As for the USA, I'm sure (and…
« If a massive object came into the solar system and perturbed orbits, caused chaos and collisions, then any "planet" with debris within its neighborhood would cease to be a planet. » Major impacts on Earth on a regular…
[repost of 50464331 b/c comment was censored, probably b/o link] « lol, lmao at the idea Hitler was invading for any reason related to humanitarianism » You're laughing because you don't know about the August crisis…
[dead]
« ideologically driven … quoting the cold war soviets … credible to me! » See? You put ideology first. "Soviets = bad", so quoting them is bad, too. Ideology first, hence facts don't matter any more. And this is not an…
« every fact which is part of the commonly narrative must ipso facto be false » Such an approach would of course be completely misguided. OTOH, the official narrative does contain lies and omits a lot of facts in many…
Okay, I wasn't thinking about the first Olympics before Berlin 1936 (where Jesse Owens won the 100 meters), and never studied historical statistics. I'd say that back then there were likely socio-environmental factors…
HN user rramadass in 50451133 this morning: « Most people just look at the surface level of what is presented to them and don't really think about anything (unless forced by circumstances). In spite of the fact that we…
« I don't see » Perhaps because you don't want to? Some people put ideology first. Many more use ideological vocabulary as the baseline of their reasoning, which is how people are educated in Western societies. So do…
« any science » — What? Is that supposed to be a joke? Ever heard of the olympics? Ever seen any world-class competition, in sprint or marathon? The former is dominated by West Africans (or the descendants of the negro…
« They did talk … » I haven't read the transcripts, but I remember reading about Weizsäcker stating that they went outside whenever they didn't want the British to listen in on their conversations, simply because they…
« rigging the numbers » Excellent point about how "a rigorous quantitative approach based on official documents" can lead to wrong results and flawed conclusions… :)
History is written by the victors, and Hitler is for our day's historiography as Hannibal for Roman history. It's a cover story to justify insatiable greed and lust for control. Hitler lacked prudence, and his rise was…
« the more you realize just how bad the Nazis were at the economy » Funny thing is that Germans back then didn't realize that at all. On the contrary, they were – by and large – really happy with Hitler, and that was…
Wonderful indeed (I didn't know him), a treasure-trove of (un)common sense and humanity, encouraging amid the AI extinction event.
« more like gratitude that the Allies couldn't hang him for working on an atomic bomb » Why would they have done that? Hadn't they themselves been "working on an atomic bomb"? Wernher von Braun wasn't hanged either…
Funny though that at "Operation Crossroads" in July 1946, the US was still trying to convince the Soviet Union, which they had invited to send a delegation, that the atomic thing was real. They apparently still didn't…
And if "the Bomb" was so overpowering and decisive, as immediately claimed by US propaganda, then why did the US attack again on Aug 14/15, using pumpkin bombs¹, in a " Grand Finale" ? Here's Yozo Kudo, general…
[repost b/o deletion/suppression] « This is alternative history, not real history. » Okay, but "real history" is full of lies, so that per se cannot be an argument against "alternative history". Which is not to say that…
[dead]
« Most of the main directions of advance by Germany and Japan were trying to get access to the 15% of the worlds oil they could get to (Romania, Baku and Indonesia). » This is the key to understand WW2. The oil, and the…