Agreed. One of the claimed selling points of capitalism is that it leads to the efficient allocation of resources; this demonstrates a failure of that.
You can't solve the problem of malicious actors by asking them not to act maliciously.
The student is the customer, not the employer, if you must phrase it in those terms. And I think education benefits when you define the student as a student, before anything else.
Yes, but they were lying.
You can offload the simpler things, but struggling with the simpler things is how you build the skills to handle the more complex ones that you can't hand off. If the simpler thing in question is a task you've already…
> a standard way of talking, not a claim about real agency. A standard way of talking used by people who do also frequently claim real agency.
Have you considered that the opposite explanation might be true instead? It could be that other developers are not benefitting from AI as much as you because they don't understand it. It could also be that you are…
The issue here is that you think the problem is > intellectual property rather than > used over and over again, primarily by the rich and powerful, to stifle original ideas and hold back cultural innovation You're using…
> a machine that can generate a poem or illustration depicting [CHARACTER_X] in [PLACE_Y] doing [ACTIVITY_Z] in [STYLE_S] without being creative Your example disproves itself; that's a madlib. It's not creative, it's…
I'm convinced that people who complain about this don't use recipe sites very often. There are loads without any preamble, and many of those with narrative provide a 'jump to recipe' button. Even if it is a long article…
> We’re told of the engineer who isn’t hired by Google because he can’t invert a binary tree. >Meanwhile in the real world, hordes of awful engineers deliver no story points These two seem linked; if hiring practices…
This is the beginning of the plot in [The Trench](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trench_(novel)). It's unlikely that the rest of the plot will play out, but always interesting when the real world starts connecting…
The video shows two people whose full-time job is watching an automated dashboard and who have failed to spot an issue for at least a month. Quite apart from anything else, this isn't a good argument that this type of…
> What's the name for the fallacy that “is” can be derived from “ought”? Any deliberate action makes clear that this is only sometimes a fallacy.
Some people want to do work they find meaningful.
Tech evangelists/EdTech salespeople saying that it was the future; there's been a big push in recent years.
I think you've just reinvented the notebook.
If the 80yo people are living in the house, then it isn't vacant.
> You could harness AI to give every child a superhuman intelligence as a tutor I don't disagree with the overall point you're making, but there is currently absolutely no reason to believe this is true.
> Many other news publishers, including the Financial Times, the Associated Press and Axel Springer, have instead opted to strike paid deals with AI companies for millions of dollars annually, undermining the Times'…
How are you defining 'ownership' in a tangible way?
No it wasn't; absolutely no one ever thought the issue with films with sound is that their creators fundamentally misunderstood Girl with a Pearl Earring. Some people thought that [new medium] wasn't art, they didn't…
"We made Girl with a Pearl Earring smile and wink" demonstrates the fundamental failure of this (and similar) technology: it's the promise of generating art, made by people who really don't understand what art is.
If a chocolate factory was making deceptive claims about curing cancer, then -- regardless of chocolate quality -- I think a lot of people would very reasonably 1. Stop eating that chocolate 2. Preface every…
Your experience of cognition isn't universal, and asserting a universal law based on your subjective experience is tenuous at best. There's a reason we've been discussing these exact ideas for millenia, rather than…
Agreed. One of the claimed selling points of capitalism is that it leads to the efficient allocation of resources; this demonstrates a failure of that.
You can't solve the problem of malicious actors by asking them not to act maliciously.
The student is the customer, not the employer, if you must phrase it in those terms. And I think education benefits when you define the student as a student, before anything else.
Yes, but they were lying.
You can offload the simpler things, but struggling with the simpler things is how you build the skills to handle the more complex ones that you can't hand off. If the simpler thing in question is a task you've already…
> a standard way of talking, not a claim about real agency. A standard way of talking used by people who do also frequently claim real agency.
Have you considered that the opposite explanation might be true instead? It could be that other developers are not benefitting from AI as much as you because they don't understand it. It could also be that you are…
The issue here is that you think the problem is > intellectual property rather than > used over and over again, primarily by the rich and powerful, to stifle original ideas and hold back cultural innovation You're using…
> a machine that can generate a poem or illustration depicting [CHARACTER_X] in [PLACE_Y] doing [ACTIVITY_Z] in [STYLE_S] without being creative Your example disproves itself; that's a madlib. It's not creative, it's…
I'm convinced that people who complain about this don't use recipe sites very often. There are loads without any preamble, and many of those with narrative provide a 'jump to recipe' button. Even if it is a long article…
> We’re told of the engineer who isn’t hired by Google because he can’t invert a binary tree. >Meanwhile in the real world, hordes of awful engineers deliver no story points These two seem linked; if hiring practices…
This is the beginning of the plot in [The Trench](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trench_(novel)). It's unlikely that the rest of the plot will play out, but always interesting when the real world starts connecting…
The video shows two people whose full-time job is watching an automated dashboard and who have failed to spot an issue for at least a month. Quite apart from anything else, this isn't a good argument that this type of…
> What's the name for the fallacy that “is” can be derived from “ought”? Any deliberate action makes clear that this is only sometimes a fallacy.
Some people want to do work they find meaningful.
Tech evangelists/EdTech salespeople saying that it was the future; there's been a big push in recent years.
I think you've just reinvented the notebook.
If the 80yo people are living in the house, then it isn't vacant.
> You could harness AI to give every child a superhuman intelligence as a tutor I don't disagree with the overall point you're making, but there is currently absolutely no reason to believe this is true.
> Many other news publishers, including the Financial Times, the Associated Press and Axel Springer, have instead opted to strike paid deals with AI companies for millions of dollars annually, undermining the Times'…
How are you defining 'ownership' in a tangible way?
No it wasn't; absolutely no one ever thought the issue with films with sound is that their creators fundamentally misunderstood Girl with a Pearl Earring. Some people thought that [new medium] wasn't art, they didn't…
"We made Girl with a Pearl Earring smile and wink" demonstrates the fundamental failure of this (and similar) technology: it's the promise of generating art, made by people who really don't understand what art is.
If a chocolate factory was making deceptive claims about curing cancer, then -- regardless of chocolate quality -- I think a lot of people would very reasonably 1. Stop eating that chocolate 2. Preface every…
Your experience of cognition isn't universal, and asserting a universal law based on your subjective experience is tenuous at best. There's a reason we've been discussing these exact ideas for millenia, rather than…