You forgot about the Nordic countries.
>It was not rude but a reasonable assumption. Let's revisit what we discussed: Yeah, variations of "did you even read the link" are rude. Yours was perhaps particularly aggressive. >But in the link you could clearly see…
What you're missing is the erosion of the ability of the executing states to say things like "hey this is sketchy, we think this crime might not have happened", "hey the police department in this particular city is…
[flagged]
Oh great, I might have to click "New Identity" in Tor Browser.
ECHR decisions are (supposed to be) legally binding. If they're not obeyed, that's not a good look for rule of law in Europe. ECHR decisions are certainly not mere recommendations. >It can recommend changes to the…
>Sorry, but you should really read the links: That's rather rude of you, I did in fact read the entire text of the link. I hate citing wikipedia, but if you'll skip forward a few lines, you'll find this nugget: "On 12…
Are you sure "the press" doesn't just refer to physical printing presses there?
>Generally speaking, I trust EU countries criminal systems more then USA one. USA one is too procedure oriented - like for example with this rule. Those procedures are written in blood
EU is not a single uniform blob. There are neighbourhoods where you have to worry about being shot, and there are neighbourhoods where people leave their keys inside their cars. So, with the police? YMMV.
"Subject to review" means little more than "is the form filled correctly?", it certainly does not mean second-guessing by the courts in the executing state. Like, yeah, your EIO will be rejected if you don't tick any of…
>EIOs are subject to a dual criminality requirement Dual criminality requirement only applies to non-Annex D crimes. Which is... not many crimes. You seem awfully confident for someone so ill-informed. >And of course,…
Depends on how you interpret the ECHR. Does it allow blocking half the internet during football games? It almost certainly does not: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-115705%... AFAIU this is common…
>The wiki article you've linked ("List of killings by law enforcement officers in Germany") sums to 552 people over the last 100 years I think we can probably agree that this number is not very accurate.
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELE...
Germany agreed to extradite Puigdemont, Spain did not want him. Perhaps because they wouldn't have been able to prosecute him for rebellion? Rebellion is not one of the EAW listed offenses, so it would require German…
Which would be perfectly fine if your local jurisdiction could still properly review those foreign requests.
[dead]
Oh no, that's totally up to you. If you're happy with the courts in your country not being able to review the requests sent from Hungary, that's cool. Without transparent judicial review, how could we even know if the…
Having been personally touched by this, I see this as an entirely practical and not ideological issue. It's harder for me to worry about the NSA than people who have already negatively impacted me in the past.
>What you are claiming about European cops is also not uniformly true. A German police officer cannot "just" self-issue a search warrant. Yes. The more worrying situation is that Hungary can just decide that their…
This is the best I can give you off the top of my head, but look at which countries are the most active in eurojust :) https://www.eurojust.europa.eu/ar2020/data-annex An LLM can probably find some better links though.
You forgot about the Nordic countries.
>It was not rude but a reasonable assumption. Let's revisit what we discussed: Yeah, variations of "did you even read the link" are rude. Yours was perhaps particularly aggressive. >But in the link you could clearly see…
What you're missing is the erosion of the ability of the executing states to say things like "hey this is sketchy, we think this crime might not have happened", "hey the police department in this particular city is…
[flagged]
Oh great, I might have to click "New Identity" in Tor Browser.
ECHR decisions are (supposed to be) legally binding. If they're not obeyed, that's not a good look for rule of law in Europe. ECHR decisions are certainly not mere recommendations. >It can recommend changes to the…
>Sorry, but you should really read the links: That's rather rude of you, I did in fact read the entire text of the link. I hate citing wikipedia, but if you'll skip forward a few lines, you'll find this nugget: "On 12…
Are you sure "the press" doesn't just refer to physical printing presses there?
>Generally speaking, I trust EU countries criminal systems more then USA one. USA one is too procedure oriented - like for example with this rule. Those procedures are written in blood
EU is not a single uniform blob. There are neighbourhoods where you have to worry about being shot, and there are neighbourhoods where people leave their keys inside their cars. So, with the police? YMMV.
"Subject to review" means little more than "is the form filled correctly?", it certainly does not mean second-guessing by the courts in the executing state. Like, yeah, your EIO will be rejected if you don't tick any of…
>EIOs are subject to a dual criminality requirement Dual criminality requirement only applies to non-Annex D crimes. Which is... not many crimes. You seem awfully confident for someone so ill-informed. >And of course,…
Depends on how you interpret the ECHR. Does it allow blocking half the internet during football games? It almost certainly does not: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-115705%... AFAIU this is common…
>The wiki article you've linked ("List of killings by law enforcement officers in Germany") sums to 552 people over the last 100 years I think we can probably agree that this number is not very accurate.
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELE...
[flagged]
Germany agreed to extradite Puigdemont, Spain did not want him. Perhaps because they wouldn't have been able to prosecute him for rebellion? Rebellion is not one of the EAW listed offenses, so it would require German…
Which would be perfectly fine if your local jurisdiction could still properly review those foreign requests.
[flagged]
[dead]
Oh no, that's totally up to you. If you're happy with the courts in your country not being able to review the requests sent from Hungary, that's cool. Without transparent judicial review, how could we even know if the…
Having been personally touched by this, I see this as an entirely practical and not ideological issue. It's harder for me to worry about the NSA than people who have already negatively impacted me in the past.
>What you are claiming about European cops is also not uniformly true. A German police officer cannot "just" self-issue a search warrant. Yes. The more worrying situation is that Hungary can just decide that their…
[dead]
This is the best I can give you off the top of my head, but look at which countries are the most active in eurojust :) https://www.eurojust.europa.eu/ar2020/data-annex An LLM can probably find some better links though.