You have admitted you don't understand Szasz's position, presumably you should be interested in finding out more, see: http://fallibleliving.com/thinkers/szasz and the reading list at the bottom.
I have pointed out that there can be correlations between genes and behaviour that are not caused by genes but by culture. Your link is irrelevant.
Kendell point (1). Szasz's position is not that diseases must be diagnosed by looking for chemical or structural abnormalities. Rather, such abnormalities are a criterion for having the disease. It may not be possible…
How do twin studies rule out "environmental" that is, non-genetic, causes. Twins look alike, so if there are ideas about how people who look alike ought to act alike we would be expect a correlation between genes and…
It's more irrational for somebody who is consistently unhappy to commit suicide than for somebody who is consistently okay to commit suicide?
You have admitted you don't understand Szasz's position, presumably you should be interested in finding out more, see: http://fallibleliving.com/thinkers/szasz and the reading list at the bottom.
I have pointed out that there can be correlations between genes and behaviour that are not caused by genes but by culture. Your link is irrelevant.
Kendell point (1). Szasz's position is not that diseases must be diagnosed by looking for chemical or structural abnormalities. Rather, such abnormalities are a criterion for having the disease. It may not be possible…
How do twin studies rule out "environmental" that is, non-genetic, causes. Twins look alike, so if there are ideas about how people who look alike ought to act alike we would be expect a correlation between genes and…
It's more irrational for somebody who is consistently unhappy to commit suicide than for somebody who is consistently okay to commit suicide?