I'm curious what the original deal was, because Intuit doesn't even have the free system anymore. This year, they "elected not to renew its participation in the IRS Free File Program." [1] [1]…
It's not so much the "interesting-ness" aspect. It's about recognizing where the papers fit and if there is a novel contribution in the first place. Even though they emphasize technical correctness, it's very easy for a…
I mean, maybe there's an aspect of pointless mimicry (though I haven't seen evidence of it), but my comment represented my general experience as someone who works the dynamical systems area and has reviewed for that…
It's unfortunately an artifact of the peer review process. Many venues only accept 15-20% of submissions, and so otherwise good papers get rejected for not following the formulaic structure. The issue is really that…
I'm curious what the original deal was, because Intuit doesn't even have the free system anymore. This year, they "elected not to renew its participation in the IRS Free File Program." [1] [1]…
It's not so much the "interesting-ness" aspect. It's about recognizing where the papers fit and if there is a novel contribution in the first place. Even though they emphasize technical correctness, it's very easy for a…
I mean, maybe there's an aspect of pointless mimicry (though I haven't seen evidence of it), but my comment represented my general experience as someone who works the dynamical systems area and has reviewed for that…
It's unfortunately an artifact of the peer review process. Many venues only accept 15-20% of submissions, and so otherwise good papers get rejected for not following the formulaic structure. The issue is really that…