Exactly - a p-hack is a form of misreporting, so isn't easy to detect at the level of individual studies. However, p-hacking isn't the only threat to replicability: in this case the authors have reported a large set of…
I am not claiming that the possibility is excluded, just that it is not demonstrated here. > In mammals, this is what guides birds to migrate. It's far more than that and the earth undergoes these field changes every…
I'm not saying it isn't true, just that it's not statistically supported by the evidence presented in the paper. You can invent post hoc justifications for almost any positive conclusion (although this one is weak since…
Brief comments suggesting this result is p-hacking are being downvoted, but I highly doubt this result will replicate. There's just so many chances (men/women/everyone, light, hunger) to reject the null hypothesis, no…
For a more conservative FP-inspired R library there's `lenses` (disclaimer: I am a coauthor), which is available on CRAN, accessible to users familiar with R indexing syntax, tidyverse-compatible, and has gentle…
Exactly - a p-hack is a form of misreporting, so isn't easy to detect at the level of individual studies. However, p-hacking isn't the only threat to replicability: in this case the authors have reported a large set of…
I am not claiming that the possibility is excluded, just that it is not demonstrated here. > In mammals, this is what guides birds to migrate. It's far more than that and the earth undergoes these field changes every…
I'm not saying it isn't true, just that it's not statistically supported by the evidence presented in the paper. You can invent post hoc justifications for almost any positive conclusion (although this one is weak since…
Brief comments suggesting this result is p-hacking are being downvoted, but I highly doubt this result will replicate. There's just so many chances (men/women/everyone, light, hunger) to reject the null hypothesis, no…
For a more conservative FP-inspired R library there's `lenses` (disclaimer: I am a coauthor), which is available on CRAN, accessible to users familiar with R indexing syntax, tidyverse-compatible, and has gentle…