This looks indeed like a public relations campaign, it would be helpful to the conversation to contribute your opinion, in a polite way.
This Math 1.0 followed by Math 2.0 framing is wrong. Mathematics did not start a few decades ago when problem solving became the norm. And it will not end now when problem solving turns out to be "easy". Mathematics…
But what if the fundaments of all these, in the human produced literature, actually contain hidden circularities and holes which make very hard the progress? IMO for the moment the greatest value from these AI tools is…
Thanks, I noticed it, see also possible relations with RNA in RNA based combinators, so it is indeed relevant. https://chorasimilarity.wordpress.com/2024/03/11/rna-based-c...
You can play with it. Equivalence with Turing machines is not the point of interest Sorry about this "not A but B", now is one of those situations where is needed. Is not: - cellular automata, - Turing machines…
Every day now I expect that they or somebody alike will discover in our genes that we (ie life) are lambda terms, combinators or something similar to Universally Programmable Intelligent Matter…
A bit more developed, here: https://chorasimilarity.wordpress.com/2026/09/22/a-mathemati...
A mathematician's suggestion: I would push for an audit of the whole mathematical corpus (all articles etc ingested by the present AI) as soon as possible. Since there are of the order of 10^7 articles, compared with…
The title communicates a different idea than the body of the text. I'd rather give a quote from the body, which is very reasonable: "We believe the recent developments have profound implications for mathematics but the…
Yes. The main idea visible through this pile of problems is that human ingenuity (of the management) will find a way to use anything for more money (publishers) or more prestige (academic researchers). The…
Thanks. IMO the most fun is in the CAPTCHA, which turns on its head the Turing test. But it goes even further than their greCAPTCHA and it solves their consumed time problem. Indeed, in their proposal they have a human…
In June 2026 I proposed a CAPTCHA for scientific publications https://chorasimilarity.wordpress.com/2026/06/13/a-captcha-f... At the moment this was seen as a tongue in cheek proposal.
Yes. AI is a useful tool and we are going to adapt and use it. The phd student will be forced to publish 10 breaktrough articles, the university department which does not offer "free" access to AI (for its members) will…
The last days we are served these high goals about understanding, "digestion" and so on. But if you look at the practice of present mathematics, in the last 20 years it is all about publishing solutions to problems.…
This will not happen. The fear comes from the real problem: publication as a measure. The mathematics itself will only benefit from the discovery of cross links from the human created literature. Think about these LLM…
Most mathematicians do compete for funding, based essentially on how many articles they can publish and where. Publication strongly favors problem solving. Universities are ranked on the same criteria. What we see is a…
I feel like Randy Waterhouse in the scene where he was trying to (not) participate to a discussion at the table concerning the internet. Everybody knows what eating the seed corn means. There is no seed corn analog in…
The is no "the mathematicians". Some mathematicians, very influent ones, are mad at AI, for social reasons, because it shows problem solving is "easy". Mathematics is fine and will be fine in the future.
I disagree with this scarcity point of view. Concrete example: Navier-Stokes. I don't make any claims about the truth of the announcement of the proof. But for the sake of the argument le't just suppose we know now that…
Mathematics called and says she's fine. She's curious about how is that possible. Misaligned are the present academic merit system hand in hand with financial interests of academic publishing industry. The system will…
I run such tests since a long time at chorasimilarity open notebook. I always used guest non login accounts. As a mathematician I was able to check two plagiates (by humans) with even such primitive means. But I have to…
This looks indeed like a public relations campaign, it would be helpful to the conversation to contribute your opinion, in a polite way.
This Math 1.0 followed by Math 2.0 framing is wrong. Mathematics did not start a few decades ago when problem solving became the norm. And it will not end now when problem solving turns out to be "easy". Mathematics…
But what if the fundaments of all these, in the human produced literature, actually contain hidden circularities and holes which make very hard the progress? IMO for the moment the greatest value from these AI tools is…
Thanks, I noticed it, see also possible relations with RNA in RNA based combinators, so it is indeed relevant. https://chorasimilarity.wordpress.com/2024/03/11/rna-based-c...
You can play with it. Equivalence with Turing machines is not the point of interest Sorry about this "not A but B", now is one of those situations where is needed. Is not: - cellular automata, - Turing machines…
Every day now I expect that they or somebody alike will discover in our genes that we (ie life) are lambda terms, combinators or something similar to Universally Programmable Intelligent Matter…
A bit more developed, here: https://chorasimilarity.wordpress.com/2026/09/22/a-mathemati...
A mathematician's suggestion: I would push for an audit of the whole mathematical corpus (all articles etc ingested by the present AI) as soon as possible. Since there are of the order of 10^7 articles, compared with…
The title communicates a different idea than the body of the text. I'd rather give a quote from the body, which is very reasonable: "We believe the recent developments have profound implications for mathematics but the…
Yes. The main idea visible through this pile of problems is that human ingenuity (of the management) will find a way to use anything for more money (publishers) or more prestige (academic researchers). The…
Thanks. IMO the most fun is in the CAPTCHA, which turns on its head the Turing test. But it goes even further than their greCAPTCHA and it solves their consumed time problem. Indeed, in their proposal they have a human…
In June 2026 I proposed a CAPTCHA for scientific publications https://chorasimilarity.wordpress.com/2026/06/13/a-captcha-f... At the moment this was seen as a tongue in cheek proposal.
Yes. AI is a useful tool and we are going to adapt and use it. The phd student will be forced to publish 10 breaktrough articles, the university department which does not offer "free" access to AI (for its members) will…
The last days we are served these high goals about understanding, "digestion" and so on. But if you look at the practice of present mathematics, in the last 20 years it is all about publishing solutions to problems.…
This will not happen. The fear comes from the real problem: publication as a measure. The mathematics itself will only benefit from the discovery of cross links from the human created literature. Think about these LLM…
Most mathematicians do compete for funding, based essentially on how many articles they can publish and where. Publication strongly favors problem solving. Universities are ranked on the same criteria. What we see is a…
I feel like Randy Waterhouse in the scene where he was trying to (not) participate to a discussion at the table concerning the internet. Everybody knows what eating the seed corn means. There is no seed corn analog in…
The is no "the mathematicians". Some mathematicians, very influent ones, are mad at AI, for social reasons, because it shows problem solving is "easy". Mathematics is fine and will be fine in the future.
I disagree with this scarcity point of view. Concrete example: Navier-Stokes. I don't make any claims about the truth of the announcement of the proof. But for the sake of the argument le't just suppose we know now that…
Mathematics called and says she's fine. She's curious about how is that possible. Misaligned are the present academic merit system hand in hand with financial interests of academic publishing industry. The system will…
I run such tests since a long time at chorasimilarity open notebook. I always used guest non login accounts. As a mathematician I was able to check two plagiates (by humans) with even such primitive means. But I have to…