> Only if you are completely clueless on what marginalization means, which by the rest of your comment, it appears you are. It would make for a more substantive discussion if you explained why you disagree with my…
Which aspect of this video convinced you that when men like Levine identify as women, they actually are women, not just men who want to be women? I watched the whole piece and didn't find a persuasive argument in favor…
> while the other is criticizing the person for their core identity Can this really be considered a core identity though? When a man such as Levine assumes an identity of a woman, is this not a form of identity fraud?
Someone appointed to a highly responsible and prestigious government role after a highly successful career, as Levine has, can hardly be described as marginalized. The Bee's article is more broadly a commentary on how…
> actually, ascribed gender—assigned at birth No, it is actually an observation of sex - often observed prenatally, then confirmed at birth.
The wider philosophical point is, if a man has gender dysphoria, does that mean he is a woman, or just wants to be a woman? If the latter, there should be no issue in a satirical publication making the point that a man…
> The award is only ridiculous if you think trans people shouldn't exist in public as openly trans. I mean you even referred to her as "her" so you seemingly recognize that her being eligible for "Woman of the Year" is…
What about if it was someone pretending to be gay, or pretending to be Catholic, or wearing blackface? That would be a more appropriate analogy to what this official is doing.
> Only if you are completely clueless on what marginalization means, which by the rest of your comment, it appears you are. It would make for a more substantive discussion if you explained why you disagree with my…
Which aspect of this video convinced you that when men like Levine identify as women, they actually are women, not just men who want to be women? I watched the whole piece and didn't find a persuasive argument in favor…
> while the other is criticizing the person for their core identity Can this really be considered a core identity though? When a man such as Levine assumes an identity of a woman, is this not a form of identity fraud?
Someone appointed to a highly responsible and prestigious government role after a highly successful career, as Levine has, can hardly be described as marginalized. The Bee's article is more broadly a commentary on how…
> actually, ascribed gender—assigned at birth No, it is actually an observation of sex - often observed prenatally, then confirmed at birth.
The wider philosophical point is, if a man has gender dysphoria, does that mean he is a woman, or just wants to be a woman? If the latter, there should be no issue in a satirical publication making the point that a man…
> The award is only ridiculous if you think trans people shouldn't exist in public as openly trans. I mean you even referred to her as "her" so you seemingly recognize that her being eligible for "Woman of the Year" is…
What about if it was someone pretending to be gay, or pretending to be Catholic, or wearing blackface? That would be a more appropriate analogy to what this official is doing.