This was an extremely interesting paper to me, about a topic that I see as economically and sociologically fundamental. I was actually impressed by the methods they used. I found myself thinking "this is what I'd really…
There's kind of two issues at least. One is the continuous-discrete issue and the other is the moment issue. As for the moment issue, the short story is that as you get into three or four moments, there isn't a general…
This is such an unrecognized part of the problem: overcredentialing. It's rampant: it's explicit in areas like healthcare and law, and implicit in the HR practices of many corporations. We bitch about people going into…
Am I missing something or are parts of this article really distorted? For example, this seems to set up most of the article: "Economics involves a lot of math and statistics. The most commonly used tools to crunch…
Not sure if I'm left-leaning or not, but the problem is that we need increased competition. The reason why this is a problem is that sometimes it means decreased regulation, and sometimes it means providing more…
As someone who does research in this area, broadly defined, I think you're on to something, but I also think there are some misleading things about this article (which I nevertheless think is interesting) and caveats to…
My same concern about the ethics of this. I might have felt a little differently if this AI startup had paid for all of the data collection proactively (although I would have still had concerns about the exclusivity of…
It's been said before but needs to be said again: this is happening everywhere in the biomedical and related fields. The neurosciences, oncology... the list goes on and on. Anyone take a look at AI research lately? How…
I think the issues go deeper than the degree program per se. Often the humanities are part of a liberal arts degree, which differs from other degrees not just in the major subject, but also in that it is broad in focus.…
I'm skeptical of citation rate as well, although I'm not sure I have anything better to offer in terms of metrics. Hype, after all, is related to citation rate. I think what we need is something that is more like…
I have mixed reactions to pieces like this. It's very salient to me because I fit the stereotype being discussed. At 43, I did my first triathlon and am, I suppose, training to do more (the season for them is basically…
This was an extremely interesting paper to me, about a topic that I see as economically and sociologically fundamental. I was actually impressed by the methods they used. I found myself thinking "this is what I'd really…
There's kind of two issues at least. One is the continuous-discrete issue and the other is the moment issue. As for the moment issue, the short story is that as you get into three or four moments, there isn't a general…
This is such an unrecognized part of the problem: overcredentialing. It's rampant: it's explicit in areas like healthcare and law, and implicit in the HR practices of many corporations. We bitch about people going into…
Am I missing something or are parts of this article really distorted? For example, this seems to set up most of the article: "Economics involves a lot of math and statistics. The most commonly used tools to crunch…
Not sure if I'm left-leaning or not, but the problem is that we need increased competition. The reason why this is a problem is that sometimes it means decreased regulation, and sometimes it means providing more…
As someone who does research in this area, broadly defined, I think you're on to something, but I also think there are some misleading things about this article (which I nevertheless think is interesting) and caveats to…
My same concern about the ethics of this. I might have felt a little differently if this AI startup had paid for all of the data collection proactively (although I would have still had concerns about the exclusivity of…
It's been said before but needs to be said again: this is happening everywhere in the biomedical and related fields. The neurosciences, oncology... the list goes on and on. Anyone take a look at AI research lately? How…
I think the issues go deeper than the degree program per se. Often the humanities are part of a liberal arts degree, which differs from other degrees not just in the major subject, but also in that it is broad in focus.…
I'm skeptical of citation rate as well, although I'm not sure I have anything better to offer in terms of metrics. Hype, after all, is related to citation rate. I think what we need is something that is more like…
I have mixed reactions to pieces like this. It's very salient to me because I fit the stereotype being discussed. At 43, I did my first triathlon and am, I suppose, training to do more (the season for them is basically…