Hi, I'm an author on the paper. It was definitely a human-AI collaboration, but it is also true that the final simplified formula, Eq. 39 in the paper (which is what we had been seeking, without success), was…
Correct, on both counts!
My pleasure---thank you for your interest!
There are closely related "MHV amplitudes" which naively obey a really complicated formula, but for which there famously also exists a much simpler "Parke-Taylor formula". Alfredo had derived a complicated expression…
That paper from the 80s (which is cited in the new one) is about "MHV amplitudes" with two negative-helicity gluons, so "double-minus amplitudes". The main significance of this new paper is to point out that…
Hi I am an author of the paper. We believed that a simple formula should exist but had not been able to find it despite significant effort. It was a collaborative effort but GPT definitely solved the problem for us.
By "grabbing references" I meant queries of the type "add paper [bla] to the bibliography" -- that seems useful to me!
I am very sympathetic to your point of view, but let me offer another perspective. First off, you can already vibe-write slop papers with AI, even in LaTeX format--tools like Prism are not needed for that. On the other…
About ~5x improvement. Recall that the resolution of an interferometric array is set by the distance between telescopes measured in units of the observation wavelength. BHEX will get a ~3x resolution improvement from…
We're thinking about it! Likely 2025 though.
If you put the source infinitely far away (as we are doing here) and at zero velocity relative to the camera, then there is no redshift effect at all, so you could say that this is the choice of redshift that we made :)…
Not currently. As I mentioned elsewhere, the rotating black hole version that we implemented requires GPU code, and porting that to Android is nontrivial---though we'd love it if someone took our open-source code and…
Excellent! Hope it looked cool.
Hahaha, I half-expected a plasma physicist to complain that GRRMHD is not self-consistent and we need to include non-ideal fluid effects :D
That would be cool, but then you wouldn't be seeing the world around you anymore. In other words, at that point it becomes a GRMHD simulation, and there is no point in using cameras since the user's environment is…
I haven't looked into the equations but I expect the effect of varying the electric charge would be similar to (but less dramatic than) changing the spin of the black hole, which as you can see in our app is not that…
The rotating black hole version that we implemented requires GPU code, and porting that to Android is nontrivial---though we'd love it if someone took our open-source code and ported it! In the meantime, check out this…
What the black hole looks like depends on how you define your field of view. And if the black hole is spinning, then you don't expect a circular shadow at all. But in our app, if you pick the "Static black hole" (the…
Yes, this is one of the wonderful crazy properties of black holes: they get hotter as they evaporate! (More precisely, the Hawking temperature is inversely proportional to the mass!)
Glad to hear that! You'll probably also enjoy reading about the Black Hole Explorer (BHEX): a proposed space mission that will take the sharpest images in the history of astronomy and resolve the "photon ring" of…
I think what he showed you was likely a version of this that was coded up by Harvard graduate student Dominic Chang: https://dominic-chang.com/bhi-filter/ It works very well (and in a browser!) but is limited to a…
Yes, Andy has been very involved in the story of the photon ring and was one of the lead authors on the original paper that started it all: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.aaz1310 (And he was also my PhD…
There are other apps out there for this kind of black hole vision...
Yes, but one issue is that the amount of redshift depends on the motion of the emitter, so we would have to artificially assign some four-velocity to your surroundings in order to give them some redshift. There doesn't…
As Project Scientist for BHEX, I am of course excited about the project and eager to spread the word about it! But as I wrote in my other comment, what this is really trying to "sell" is gravitational physics to…
Hi, I'm an author on the paper. It was definitely a human-AI collaboration, but it is also true that the final simplified formula, Eq. 39 in the paper (which is what we had been seeking, without success), was…
Correct, on both counts!
My pleasure---thank you for your interest!
There are closely related "MHV amplitudes" which naively obey a really complicated formula, but for which there famously also exists a much simpler "Parke-Taylor formula". Alfredo had derived a complicated expression…
That paper from the 80s (which is cited in the new one) is about "MHV amplitudes" with two negative-helicity gluons, so "double-minus amplitudes". The main significance of this new paper is to point out that…
Hi I am an author of the paper. We believed that a simple formula should exist but had not been able to find it despite significant effort. It was a collaborative effort but GPT definitely solved the problem for us.
By "grabbing references" I meant queries of the type "add paper [bla] to the bibliography" -- that seems useful to me!
I am very sympathetic to your point of view, but let me offer another perspective. First off, you can already vibe-write slop papers with AI, even in LaTeX format--tools like Prism are not needed for that. On the other…
About ~5x improvement. Recall that the resolution of an interferometric array is set by the distance between telescopes measured in units of the observation wavelength. BHEX will get a ~3x resolution improvement from…
We're thinking about it! Likely 2025 though.
If you put the source infinitely far away (as we are doing here) and at zero velocity relative to the camera, then there is no redshift effect at all, so you could say that this is the choice of redshift that we made :)…
Not currently. As I mentioned elsewhere, the rotating black hole version that we implemented requires GPU code, and porting that to Android is nontrivial---though we'd love it if someone took our open-source code and…
Excellent! Hope it looked cool.
Hahaha, I half-expected a plasma physicist to complain that GRRMHD is not self-consistent and we need to include non-ideal fluid effects :D
That would be cool, but then you wouldn't be seeing the world around you anymore. In other words, at that point it becomes a GRMHD simulation, and there is no point in using cameras since the user's environment is…
I haven't looked into the equations but I expect the effect of varying the electric charge would be similar to (but less dramatic than) changing the spin of the black hole, which as you can see in our app is not that…
The rotating black hole version that we implemented requires GPU code, and porting that to Android is nontrivial---though we'd love it if someone took our open-source code and ported it! In the meantime, check out this…
What the black hole looks like depends on how you define your field of view. And if the black hole is spinning, then you don't expect a circular shadow at all. But in our app, if you pick the "Static black hole" (the…
Yes, this is one of the wonderful crazy properties of black holes: they get hotter as they evaporate! (More precisely, the Hawking temperature is inversely proportional to the mass!)
Glad to hear that! You'll probably also enjoy reading about the Black Hole Explorer (BHEX): a proposed space mission that will take the sharpest images in the history of astronomy and resolve the "photon ring" of…
I think what he showed you was likely a version of this that was coded up by Harvard graduate student Dominic Chang: https://dominic-chang.com/bhi-filter/ It works very well (and in a browser!) but is limited to a…
Yes, Andy has been very involved in the story of the photon ring and was one of the lead authors on the original paper that started it all: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.aaz1310 (And he was also my PhD…
There are other apps out there for this kind of black hole vision...
Yes, but one issue is that the amount of redshift depends on the motion of the emitter, so we would have to artificially assign some four-velocity to your surroundings in order to give them some redshift. There doesn't…
As Project Scientist for BHEX, I am of course excited about the project and eager to spread the word about it! But as I wrote in my other comment, what this is really trying to "sell" is gravitational physics to…