My impression with this space is that you'd need to fundraise startup-style, which I'm assuming you'll do, to catch up with everyone that is doing a similar thing. The problem space and solution has been around for a…
Why stop at restricting pull requests? I wouldn't want spam issues either. New issues and contributors should be gated at the "discussion" stage.
Impressive looking project generated with AI help. Have similar goals of having an artifacts system myself. I think the approach of multi-format, multi-UI, and new (to you) programming language isn't optimal even with…
Yes, it is huge to spread the work out on embedded UIs in chat interfaces. But I think the design direction is going, is exactly the same direction of how Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, or any of the other assistants…
If your binary has a small function set, probably not. But in a use case if you want to proxy/intercept cloud APIs, then something like Google APIs has 34K message types: git clone…
Yes, I agree that protos usually should only be used at the serialization boundary, as well as the slightly off-topic idea that the generated code should be private to the package and/or binary. So to reflect the…
IMO, not a fair benchmark. I can see the source of an 10x improvement on an Intel(R) Xeon(R) Gold 6136 CPU @ 3.00GHz, but it drops to 3x improvement when I remove the to/from that clones or collects Vecs, and always…
Is 4096 types enough for everyone? https://github.com/apache/fory/blob/fd1d53bd0fbbc5e0ce6d53ef...
Are the benchmarks actually fair? See: https://github.com/apache/fory/blob/fd1d53bd0fbbc5e0ce6d53ef... It seems if the serialization object is not a "Fory" struct, then it is forced to go through to/from conversion as…
Yes, from https://www.txse.com/solutions: TXSE's goal is to provide greater alignment with issuers and investors and address the high cost of going and staying public. The alignment part translates IMO to avoiding…
Right, for example, there are no comments on why something there is something called a PromiseIdAllocator that starts with the magic number "1": https://github.com/currentspace/capn-rs/blob/a816bfca5fb6ae5... Yet there…
Regarding the concept, it's cool to see you using LLMs to quickly generate protocol versions. But asking the community to review an AI-generated implementation week-old announced protocol, is more or less putting the…
How long ago did you try SQLx? Not necessarily promoting SQLX, but the `query_as` which lets one make queries without the live database macro has been around for 5 years [1]. For lower level libraries there is also the…
I'm assuming that the PaaS/IaaS providers already have solutions for secrets. So a new centralized system may help with just dev and DIY bare metal? But the centralized method, as in secretspec, not everyone will accept…
That's correct, the example you are giving represents bike-shedding among request path variations. I assumed most readers of my comment would get that the idea that /users/signup is ambiguous whether or not that is…
The system won't be able remember why the user was created unless the content of the post includes data saying it was a signup. That's important for any type of reporting like telemetry and billing. So then one gets to…
I wouldn't recommend Cargo as something to copy for a real project, even though I've a fan of and have been using Rust exclusively lately. It suffers from not being able to handle global features without…
The VR version of network management already existed [1]. It was called CA [2] Unicenter TNG. It really could use an update with some rendering with Unreal Engine! :D Unrelated but could be confused with what was seen…
Task is in a similar problem space. Unlike Just which clearly states it is not a build system [1], Task can be told about expected files so tasks can be skipped to avoid unnecessary work [2]. So if your task is to build…
For the audience that would be looking to use the WASM Component Model, and not be an infrastructure implementer of it, whether or not they meet some definition of a method, the component model does define things called…
Yes, in retrospect I should have mentioned "Components" in my comment and just compared it to "Java" in general instead. I felt that was implied due to the thread and topic of discussion. From a pragmatic end-user…
Yes, its great to see progress in the tooling [1] so that the component building is easier. Although I do like to think of the component model as the "ABI linking model". You can only bind one implementation to an…
WASM is basically similar to JVM bytecode. So the comparison would be like using compiled code from Java, Scala and/or Kotlin for example. The source language only determines how the code is expressed in WASM and…
I don't miss variable substitution at all. For my setup anything that needs to be variable or secret gets specified in a custom json/yaml file which is read by a plugin which in turn outputs the rendered manifest if I…
IMO this boils down how one gets paid to understand or misunderstand something. A telemetry provider/founder is being commoditized by an open specification in which they do not participate in its development -- implied…
My impression with this space is that you'd need to fundraise startup-style, which I'm assuming you'll do, to catch up with everyone that is doing a similar thing. The problem space and solution has been around for a…
Why stop at restricting pull requests? I wouldn't want spam issues either. New issues and contributors should be gated at the "discussion" stage.
Impressive looking project generated with AI help. Have similar goals of having an artifacts system myself. I think the approach of multi-format, multi-UI, and new (to you) programming language isn't optimal even with…
Yes, it is huge to spread the work out on embedded UIs in chat interfaces. But I think the design direction is going, is exactly the same direction of how Google Assistant, Amazon Alexa, or any of the other assistants…
If your binary has a small function set, probably not. But in a use case if you want to proxy/intercept cloud APIs, then something like Google APIs has 34K message types: git clone…
Yes, I agree that protos usually should only be used at the serialization boundary, as well as the slightly off-topic idea that the generated code should be private to the package and/or binary. So to reflect the…
IMO, not a fair benchmark. I can see the source of an 10x improvement on an Intel(R) Xeon(R) Gold 6136 CPU @ 3.00GHz, but it drops to 3x improvement when I remove the to/from that clones or collects Vecs, and always…
Is 4096 types enough for everyone? https://github.com/apache/fory/blob/fd1d53bd0fbbc5e0ce6d53ef...
Are the benchmarks actually fair? See: https://github.com/apache/fory/blob/fd1d53bd0fbbc5e0ce6d53ef... It seems if the serialization object is not a "Fory" struct, then it is forced to go through to/from conversion as…
Yes, from https://www.txse.com/solutions: TXSE's goal is to provide greater alignment with issuers and investors and address the high cost of going and staying public. The alignment part translates IMO to avoiding…
Right, for example, there are no comments on why something there is something called a PromiseIdAllocator that starts with the magic number "1": https://github.com/currentspace/capn-rs/blob/a816bfca5fb6ae5... Yet there…
Regarding the concept, it's cool to see you using LLMs to quickly generate protocol versions. But asking the community to review an AI-generated implementation week-old announced protocol, is more or less putting the…
How long ago did you try SQLx? Not necessarily promoting SQLX, but the `query_as` which lets one make queries without the live database macro has been around for 5 years [1]. For lower level libraries there is also the…
I'm assuming that the PaaS/IaaS providers already have solutions for secrets. So a new centralized system may help with just dev and DIY bare metal? But the centralized method, as in secretspec, not everyone will accept…
That's correct, the example you are giving represents bike-shedding among request path variations. I assumed most readers of my comment would get that the idea that /users/signup is ambiguous whether or not that is…
The system won't be able remember why the user was created unless the content of the post includes data saying it was a signup. That's important for any type of reporting like telemetry and billing. So then one gets to…
I wouldn't recommend Cargo as something to copy for a real project, even though I've a fan of and have been using Rust exclusively lately. It suffers from not being able to handle global features without…
The VR version of network management already existed [1]. It was called CA [2] Unicenter TNG. It really could use an update with some rendering with Unreal Engine! :D Unrelated but could be confused with what was seen…
Task is in a similar problem space. Unlike Just which clearly states it is not a build system [1], Task can be told about expected files so tasks can be skipped to avoid unnecessary work [2]. So if your task is to build…
For the audience that would be looking to use the WASM Component Model, and not be an infrastructure implementer of it, whether or not they meet some definition of a method, the component model does define things called…
Yes, in retrospect I should have mentioned "Components" in my comment and just compared it to "Java" in general instead. I felt that was implied due to the thread and topic of discussion. From a pragmatic end-user…
Yes, its great to see progress in the tooling [1] so that the component building is easier. Although I do like to think of the component model as the "ABI linking model". You can only bind one implementation to an…
WASM is basically similar to JVM bytecode. So the comparison would be like using compiled code from Java, Scala and/or Kotlin for example. The source language only determines how the code is expressed in WASM and…
I don't miss variable substitution at all. For my setup anything that needs to be variable or secret gets specified in a custom json/yaml file which is read by a plugin which in turn outputs the rendered manifest if I…
IMO this boils down how one gets paid to understand or misunderstand something. A telemetry provider/founder is being commoditized by an open specification in which they do not participate in its development -- implied…