I seriously doubt the majority of cases are recorded and uploaded to the internet.
No, but "we've got to hunt down every image" isn't really an argument which ends there, so it might go further in the future.
It's not that I don't want to give you a sunny solution which makes the problem go away forever, but this is an extremely difficult problem to solve, especially as someone might be located in some foreign country with…
France has been pushing terrorism as a justification for mass-surveillance in the E.U.
Security by obscurity has never been particularly effective, and there are some articles which allege that detection algorithms can be defeated fairly easily.
There have certainly been busts in the media, including some depraved individuals who have blackmailed teenagers into sending them images, one of which set the dangerous precedent of tech companies developing exploits,…
It's well-known that this algorithm doesn't have a perfect matching rate. It'd be easy to presume that any false positives are not erroneously tagged images, but the error rate of the underlying algorithm, if all the…
The FBI doesn't even have the resources to review all the reports they do get (we learned that in 2019), and yet they want to intrude on everyone's rights to get even more to investigate (which they won't).
As many, many people have pointed out, building a mechanism to scan things client-side is something which could easily be extended to encrypted content, and perhaps, is intended to be extended at a moment's notice to…
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28081184 The NCMEC already had it's problems. But, this takes it to a whole new level.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28081184 It's a bit worse than that.
NCMEC is an private organization created by the U.S. Government, funded by the U.S. Government, operates with no constitutional scrutiny, operates with no oversight / accountability, could be prodded by the U.S.…
But, are they? The Swiss federal police weren't too happy about the reports they received from the Cyber Tip.
A good start would be for the government to stop trying to bully tech companies into compromising on their privacy.
Is there any reason they shouldn't have adoption rights? What's the harm in that?
I don't think it is possible to turn someone who is straight gay, anymore than it is possible to turn someone who is gay straight. The exception would be where they're bi, but they would already have had some interest…
I presume they meant ones who have committed crimes, rather than ones who roughly fit a profile of who might commit homicide. I agree that profiling someone like this could lead into some serious Minority Report…
There's another side. Conversion therapy of any form is inhumane. It makes someone deny their very identity. It may even drive them to suicide. And for what, so someone doesn't get offended by their existence?
My question would be closer to, how would you feel if someone high up decided to strip away your attraction to women, and replace it with an attraction to men, because they deemed this more "appropriate", or positive to…
I don't think it is entirely genetic. There are other factors like development within the mother's body, levels of hormones / chemicals, and so on which could contribute to a different sexuality later on. This doesn't…
It's more that some people think "people choose to do things society greatly disapproves of", that is going out of their way to be difficult, and they want to punish them for this. But, then you would have to consider…
A name which Google isn't familiar with (Riot, as opposed to Element) is a possible reason they were suspended in the first place.
Google is so big that one head doesn't know what the other is doing. Some people probably do know what Matrix is, but that doesn't mean the right people do. It's still a big problem that Google isn't even making the…
Does Europe have the power to split Google? Or does that lie with U.S. regulators?
It's scary how Google can automatically ban a client for a network with millions of users like this without even batting an eye.
I seriously doubt the majority of cases are recorded and uploaded to the internet.
No, but "we've got to hunt down every image" isn't really an argument which ends there, so it might go further in the future.
It's not that I don't want to give you a sunny solution which makes the problem go away forever, but this is an extremely difficult problem to solve, especially as someone might be located in some foreign country with…
France has been pushing terrorism as a justification for mass-surveillance in the E.U.
Security by obscurity has never been particularly effective, and there are some articles which allege that detection algorithms can be defeated fairly easily.
There have certainly been busts in the media, including some depraved individuals who have blackmailed teenagers into sending them images, one of which set the dangerous precedent of tech companies developing exploits,…
It's well-known that this algorithm doesn't have a perfect matching rate. It'd be easy to presume that any false positives are not erroneously tagged images, but the error rate of the underlying algorithm, if all the…
The FBI doesn't even have the resources to review all the reports they do get (we learned that in 2019), and yet they want to intrude on everyone's rights to get even more to investigate (which they won't).
As many, many people have pointed out, building a mechanism to scan things client-side is something which could easily be extended to encrypted content, and perhaps, is intended to be extended at a moment's notice to…
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28081184 The NCMEC already had it's problems. But, this takes it to a whole new level.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28081184 It's a bit worse than that.
NCMEC is an private organization created by the U.S. Government, funded by the U.S. Government, operates with no constitutional scrutiny, operates with no oversight / accountability, could be prodded by the U.S.…
But, are they? The Swiss federal police weren't too happy about the reports they received from the Cyber Tip.
A good start would be for the government to stop trying to bully tech companies into compromising on their privacy.
Is there any reason they shouldn't have adoption rights? What's the harm in that?
I don't think it is possible to turn someone who is straight gay, anymore than it is possible to turn someone who is gay straight. The exception would be where they're bi, but they would already have had some interest…
I presume they meant ones who have committed crimes, rather than ones who roughly fit a profile of who might commit homicide. I agree that profiling someone like this could lead into some serious Minority Report…
There's another side. Conversion therapy of any form is inhumane. It makes someone deny their very identity. It may even drive them to suicide. And for what, so someone doesn't get offended by their existence?
My question would be closer to, how would you feel if someone high up decided to strip away your attraction to women, and replace it with an attraction to men, because they deemed this more "appropriate", or positive to…
I don't think it is entirely genetic. There are other factors like development within the mother's body, levels of hormones / chemicals, and so on which could contribute to a different sexuality later on. This doesn't…
It's more that some people think "people choose to do things society greatly disapproves of", that is going out of their way to be difficult, and they want to punish them for this. But, then you would have to consider…
A name which Google isn't familiar with (Riot, as opposed to Element) is a possible reason they were suspended in the first place.
Google is so big that one head doesn't know what the other is doing. Some people probably do know what Matrix is, but that doesn't mean the right people do. It's still a big problem that Google isn't even making the…
Does Europe have the power to split Google? Or does that lie with U.S. regulators?
It's scary how Google can automatically ban a client for a network with millions of users like this without even batting an eye.