It always baffles me when people say something like "I'm guessing..." or "they probably..." followed by their own image of the evil others, in a context where the example is trivially disproven.
That's because almost no one bothers to RTFA, they just project their own assumptions into the title, make some boilerplate political hot take then move on.
Reading the reasons why some of these people were "cancelled" is utter madness. How we really become the nation that is so easily offended that reverse racism against you that has you on the defensive to begin with gets your fired? These snow flakes need to spend some time abroad and get a good dose of reality instead of making up their own here....
> These snow flakes need to spend some time abroad and get a good dose of reality instead of making up their own here....
Are you referring to the authors of this list, or the people on it, or the people firing the people on it? Everybody would claim someone else is the one making up their own reality.
The sourcing of the “database" claims in the few I checked is sketchy and indicates heavy spin (e.g., one cites a news article that indicates that certain claims were made in a just-filed lawsuit, the “database” reports those claims as settled fact.)
This seems to be an attempt to put a facade of neutrality over political propaganda about the extent and impact of “cancel culture”.
EDIT: Oh, and it falsely, with no support at all even in the article it cites as its source, states that the City Manager fired in the wake of the Duante Wright shooting waa fired for his appearance after the event where he said city employees are entitled for due process, instead of because he oversees and is responsible to the council for the police department and its failings.
There is a version of this list that is reasonable, but the nature of the sourcing has obviously turned it into petty social politics (i.e. "X person I sympathize with is being oppressed by the evil people who are ruining my society", "thought crime", etc).
This list mentions Graham Linehan and implies that he was cancelled for a single seemingly innocuous tweet. It glosses over the fact that he devoted years of his life to using Twitter as a platform for harassing trans people.
"Cancel culture" is AFAIK a term coined by the right against the supposed power of "liberals" to ruin the lives of people with nothing more than "non-liberal" opinions.
A cursory glance at this list reveals something else IMO, a "cancel culture" that may "cancel" anyone on a whim. It deserves to be tracked and contemplated. The question is: is social media going to replace the the judiciary now? With no right to appeal?
While this particular "database" might need to be better curated, the ambition certainly seems to be in the right direction.
17 comments
[ 4.6 ms ] story [ 58.1 ms ] threadOnce a member, there is no 'Please, I can explain' or 'It's not what you think it is'. There is no redemption for high crimes of wrong-think.
Are you referring to the authors of this list, or the people on it, or the people firing the people on it? Everybody would claim someone else is the one making up their own reality.
This seems to be an attempt to put a facade of neutrality over political propaganda about the extent and impact of “cancel culture”.
EDIT: Oh, and it falsely, with no support at all even in the article it cites as its source, states that the City Manager fired in the wake of the Duante Wright shooting waa fired for his appearance after the event where he said city employees are entitled for due process, instead of because he oversees and is responsible to the council for the police department and its failings.
A cursory glance at this list reveals something else IMO, a "cancel culture" that may "cancel" anyone on a whim. It deserves to be tracked and contemplated. The question is: is social media going to replace the the judiciary now? With no right to appeal?
While this particular "database" might need to be better curated, the ambition certainly seems to be in the right direction.
This submission did not deserve to be flagged.