Ask HN: Am I wrong to think this is disrespectful?

Unless you two had discussed it in some prior conversation, it is a red flag IMO and I'd be cautious with this person in any capacity. Doing this without having a chat about it, is disrespectful IMO as well. It also shows a lack of foresight into what might cause team issues too. So it is a warning sign on multiple levels, at least to me.

Yeah I had a friend that started pulling titles and ranks even before the first slide was ready. I think he watched The Social Network one too many times.

Great friend, but had to say no to working with him.

Whether or not it is disrespectful, it is a red flag that the two of you are not communicating well. In the case of choosing a co-founder, "Maybe" means "No.", so I'd step away from working with him.

You should thank them and move on.

This is the type of person whose first move will be to remove you from the company.

Do not ever, ever work with this person. Ever again.

It looks like a red flag, but just in case you want to go on, remember "4 year vesting with 1 year cliff".

Is your ego more important than moving the company forward?

Good luck.

I think that it all depends on how the communication between you two works. If, for example, you are used to such inner jokes, like giving yourselves exaggerated titles, or maybe even if this is his bold way of asking to join you, it's completely fine.

However, you felt the need to come and ask other people. It means you don't feel comfortable talking to him. You two don't communicate well together and you don't trust him. Communication and trust are the most important things. I would have probably avoided.

I would say that if this is a misunderstanding or a joke, and you’re able to directly communicate that he’s not a cofounder yet, then you may be able to work together.

If you can’t bring yourself to say that to him, you won’t have a productive relationship (and you will also have trouble dealing with employees well.)

If he did this as an overt power grab, that’s obviously not okay, but that’s so straightforward that I don’t think it’s what’s prompting you to ask, here.

I wouldn't say it's disrespectful, but I'd bring it up with him, and explain: "You've been helpful, but the CEO role will be mine." If he balks, move on. Simple as that. You don't have to be assume this is a huge issue until a conversation is had, and even then, if he tries to make it into a big issue you can choose to move on from him.

I think if you can’t both have a conversation about this easily then getting into business together might not be a good idea. Times are going to be tough and you need to not sweat the small stuff together.

If you can sit down and have a chat then all good and do so. Go have fun.

Don't ever make a person show you who they really are, twice.

If you decide to move forward with this person, this is the type of behavior you are always going to have to look out for. You shouldn't allow yourself to every be surprised, nor should you leave any ambiguity with anything.

Then, ask yourself, "Is this the type of person I want to co-found a business with?"

Good luck.

Huge red flag. Run.

Wow a lot of strong advice here. If he's your friend sit down and talk. This may have been a miscommunication. Just be up front and open about your concerns. Don't make any rash moves until you know what happened.

Disrespectful and unprofessional. Like another commenter said, this is exactly the kind of person who will kick you out of your own company.

You've given us a few paragraphs about the situation. No one here can tell you if he was attempting to disrespect you.

I'll note that you've called this person a friend in your post, so it's likely you know them pretty well. Instead of asking strangers on the internet with only a very reduced understanding of your relationship dynamic and past conversations, why not have a chat with your friend and ask them directly?

If you're considering this person as your cofounder, you're going to need a strong communication foundation. Getting offended by a perceived lack of respect (which could be valid, but it doesn't sound like you're sure they meant offence since you're asking the question here) is not a good place to start any business relationship.

Red flag.

Seems like a huge red flag. Also it comes off as unprofessional. This is something you are showing to investors. You need to be very accurate with your slides. If it says he is a cofounder and CEO and he is not, then what does that say about your company? It makes you seem like you are not serious.

It sounds like a misunderstanding on his part. Maybe he misinterpreted something you said. Have you brought it up with him?

Ask them why they added it. It could be a poorly received joke, or a serious misunderstanding.

Until you talk with them assume joke (prior knowledge you haven't shared not withstanding). It's not clear who poorly communicated, and the worst thing you can do is say nothing after having posted here. Part of clearly communicating is catching when you're making assumptions, and asking questions directly to the person to learn more.

Stupid question, but does he understand the weight of what he did?

I say this because I was working on a startup several years back and one day I got chatting with my friend's brother about it. He seemed interested and I suggested he could help out if he wanted. Anyway a few days later I found that he listed himself as a "co-founder" of my startup on Linkedin.

I wasn't mad or anything - it was in such early stages it's not like it really mattered. But I spoke to him about it a few days later and he seemed really embarrassed about it and acknowledged he should have asked me first, but explain he was just really excited to be part of it and got carried away. I thought was kinda cool if anything because I sensed he didn't mean any harm by it and he just wanted to put his name to something he was excited about and the "co-founder" title sounds cool to some people.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that some people really just like titles and he may not realise why what he is doing is wrong. I'm guessing that's not the case, but worth getting his perspective first maybe?

Otherwise I'd echo what others have said here. Seems like a red flag if he understands what he's doing.

I'd double check with him that it isn't a joke. I have a dumb sense of humor and could see myself doing something like this to a friend :)

Nip this one in the bud right now. Be transparent with your partners, always, and expect the same. Don't be surprised if he has some feedback for you as well :) and you might not like hearing it at first, but you have to do this stuff. It's better to find out now, far far better. It's usually miscommunication and not a character flaw. The human mind tends to drift to the more negative "why" rather than just "miscommunication probably".

Also I found with my first business keeping a journal for the business was also useful so I could refer back. The human mind isn't really photographic so much as a fuzzy merge algorithm and memories change over time, and it's useful to write these critical points down, and some things won't seem "critical" right now but will become so. I am a journal-whore though and I advocate keeping a few different ones. Don't write a novel, I tend to write bullet points as it keeps me from rambling, like I am currently.

Whay cant you 2 just have an open sincere conversation about this?

Considering how little (none) we know about the two of you and the details of the situation described — how can you possibly expect any advice worth anything from here?

I am really curious what was your internal dialogue and intentions about posting this?

Sorry if it sounds rude.

I think that's the kind of a joke I would pull, but it also depends on the situation. Doing that right in front of an important pitch is a bad idea per-se.