80 comments

[ 2.3 ms ] story [ 130 ms ] thread
Backstory: I built this last year and forgot all about it. Re-discovered it on my junk server last month and I've been using it ever since.

Polished overnight and now released to the lions den.

Take a look, feedback welcome. What do you think?

+1, good sir. Thank you for releasing this out in the wild!
That is a really huge list.
I know right, yet the site still weighs in at just 46.29kb thanks to the wonders of gzip compression (156kb without).

Any ideas on feeds worth adding?

The Verge
Yeah, weird thing about the verge, they use "entry" instead of "item" in their feed so it breaks. Anyone know why they do this?
The Next Web

This is very useful. Thank you for sharing this.

What are your plans for this?

The Next Web added, should show on the next db refresh.

Plans is an interesting question, thanks for asking.

When I built it originally I had this huge project in mind (as we all do :) ), bookmarks, saved articles in a user area, FB login, link tracking for a "most popular links box", live stream, recommendation algos, the works.

I guess this scale is one of the reasons I originally dropped it.

After the rediscovery I thought "let's go MVP on this". So I cut everything back. What you see is what surivived. Literally, just the news links, on a html page, that is quick to load with no server hit.

Future plans - let's see how it goes eh. If the hosting bill enters the trips I'll drop a few ads in, but I like the cleanness of it all for now.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Have you considered putting in a donation button as well?

I've not tried it yet but hopefully this also works on mobile phones (I have a Blackberry specifically)

Have you considered releasing the source code?

Any chance you could just store the images in a single local image and use CSS sprites, instead of loading favicons from every different site. The front page does 62 HTTP requests and they're all over the place...
I could do, but the way it's built is using a master array in the page creator file. To add a feed, I just add the new feed and favicon location into the array. Storing the images would mean more work each time a new feed is added.

Having said that, CSS Sprites is something I don't know much about and will be looking into.

It'd take a tiny bit more work on the frontend, but instead of saving the favicon location, you could save a data-uri of the favicon image. That would then completely eliminate all of the external HTTP requests.
Thanks for the list. I have an organized list here, at http://talll.com. I have tried to place the reading list under various groups - I thought this might be relevant to this discussion.
Nice work and thanks for sharing.

If you can add hyperlinks to each title, it will be helpful (e.g clicking on "Make" should take me to make.com).

I like it. May I suggest getting rid of the fixed social sharing buttons? The ones at the bottom do the job well enough. I find the top ones a little bit distracting. Good font choice.
I used jimmyr.com all these years. Might as well switch to this. Hate those fixed social buttons though.
The fixed socials are only on for today, I've made a note to remove them.

Good to have you on board, Let me know if there's any feeds you'd like added.

Very nice collection. Few sites I never heard of. Thanks for sharing. Btw, You Mentioned Amazon and Google Ad-sense in Privacy policy. I don't see any Ads, have any plan to keep Ads on this site and make revenue?
Ads depends on the hosting bill, but I like the clean interface so we'll see how it goes.

The privacy policy is a copy, paste, find, replace from another site I run, didn't expect this heat. Added to todo.

You have a few escaping issues, that Firefox nicely hi-lights if you view the source. For example, if the title of an article contains a ", you don't quote it, so in the html you end up with attributes like this:

  title="something "something else""
You also don't escape ampersands. Eg:

  <a href="http://example.com/foo?x=1&y=2">x & y</a>
Should be:

  <a href="http://example.com/foo?x=1&amp;y=2">x &amp; y</a>
I imagine there is a more general issue with a lack of escaping, but these are just a couple of examples I found.
I saw these issues last night but couldn't work out what was causing them. Thanks for the explanations Mike, added to todo.

Update: Fixed. I think, but those &amp; are still showing up red in source.

This is great! It would be great, if I could see my google reader O/P in skimmed format as opposed to sources curated by you!
There was another news reader on HN recently, but this one is much better on the iPhone (where I seem to be doing much of my reading lately).

I'll be using this page from now on. Nice work.

Although I like the idea, I personally prefer Pulse.me. It has pictures and resized articles according to their significance.

Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/W1NKw.png

Pulse looks like a neat idea, but I can't stand the layout. Where should my eyes go?

I'm a big fan of "significance", "buzz", and "personalization" in theory, but I find it easier to skim some text myself.

Re: "Where should my eyes go?"

I find that I can skim more easily with a few images that provide additional visual cues other than those of textual information. Pictures require a different visual focus, and might allow me to focus on the "bigger picture" (e.g. whether it is coming from WSJ), or "smaller picture" (i.e. more specific examples).

Additionally, I like that you can mix the sources together, with not too much of anything; instead emphasising a more holistic view.

great point about the sources.
Yes, you can skim more easily with images, but those images are leading your eyes to what? The best articles or just a random article with images? I say it's the second one.

I'd argue title words are much better at showcasing an articles potential value than a stock image of a carrot.

My biggest gripe with Pulse and similar readers is that clicking on a headline takes me to an article stub with an option to click a link to the full article. Just take me to the article!
I really like this, it makes skimming the major news sites very easy. It looks like a quick way to view the news in the morning. I could probably scan all those and open the ones I want to read in under a minute. The only thing I would change is the social buttons at the top but from the other comments I can see you're going to remove them.

Nice work.

This is cool. Can you make the HN links point to the HN pages? Besides getting easy access to the discussion, it sorta de-dupes the links.
Thanks for making me chuckle with the comments at the top of the source.
It's neat, but I find things more useful when they're not separated by source/author, but in how interesting I'll find them. I don't read an Ars Technica article just because it's from ars.

To me it would be much better to get rid of the origin altogether to help eliminate bias and focus on the actual story.

Great collection of sources, but please, mark :visited links!
The more time I spend consuming, the less time I spend producing. And this is an online content firehose. It looks very nice and tempting, but thanks, but no, thanks.
I say you need a mix of both. Abstinence is not the answer.
I agree with you: 90% of the value of a developer is knowing what to type, which includes what NOT to type. Knowing the difference comes (IMHO) from being aware of what is out there and stories learned from the experience of others.

So yes: perhaps less cat videos is a good thing, but less exposure to information is not.

jimmyr.com has been my homepage for three years and counting.
May i suggest line-height: 160%

I know it will take away a few links from the viewarea but you will be able to read them faster IMHO.

Yes, this ^ please!

Perhaps a toggle of some sort?

How did you come to the 160% figure? Golden triangle?
Golden triangle is nonsense for design, by the way. Please don't let it inform your decisions. Most examples of it in nature are bogus.
This is pretty good. Currently I use NetVibes, which is buggy and actually TOO customizable. I like the strict grid layout.

If you made this a service, here's what would make me switch:

- customizable feeds (kind of obvious I guess)

- ability to mark items as read/unread (link color is not enough - I want to skip some items, or just read them all from the blog itself without clicking individual items)

- have individual feed header be a link to the feed's main page (it's the <link> element in RSS) - customize number of items per feed (e.g. I'd want more items for feeds which update frequently)

Nice to haves:

- tabs (I have LOTS of feeds - would be easier to manage instead of long scrolling)

- along with using the <link> element above, ability to override this, because I've noticed lots of feeds that don't set it properly (link to the domain root instead of the blog root, e.g.)

I currently use netvibes too. to customize rss feeds.. i use Yahoo Pipes. You can provide bunch of feeds to pipes, then add custom filters, sorts, terms and generate a custom RSS address. Add this address to netvibes.

and with this process, you will hardly ever visit any of the homepages except netvibes.

Nice project though.

Look at BBC's headlines compared to everyone else's. Someone explain this to me.
My 2 guesses: SEO or that little sidebar box they have showing popular articles has a character limit to look good.