And a US-made and likely US-bought GBU-39 Small Diameter Bomb was dropped by Israeli aircraft (also likely US-funded) on a civilian hospital. Reports say it ended up as UXO on a hospital gurney because there was nowhere else to put it. This is barbaric.
Also it was the IDF after all but it was a mistake
Also the IDF did it deliberately and they were carefully targeting Hamas.
Also OK they killed some doctors but why are you focusing so much on Israel? Lots of countries bomb hospitals and schools on a regular basis, you only hear about Israel because the media is so anti-Israel and everyone is an antisemite.
This must be the longest ethnic cleansing in history.
The cleansing of Jews from Arab countries took less than a decade, and it only took a few months to cleanse 100% of the Jews from Arab-controlled areas of Palestine in 1948.
The Zionists must be really bad at ethnics cleansing.
The Arabs have been a minority in Israel since 1948 and their numbers have grown exponentially since then. They have just won 19 seats in the Israeli parliament.
Do you know how many Jewish members of parliament there are in all Arab or Muslim countries combined?
There was no ethnic cleansing of Jews from Arab nations, there was Zionist terrorism and voluntary immigration. The creation of the colony of Israel is being “bad at ethic cleansing”? It’s the most successful ethnic cleansing since the genocide of the Americas!
Arabs just won 19 seats in the Israeli parliament. How many Jewish members of parliament are there in all Arab or Muslim countries combined?
The answer is 0.
But if you want to deny facts we can just swap Jews with Arabs in your statement: There was no ethnic cleansing of Arabs from the Jewish nation. There was anti-Zionist terrorism and voluntary immigration.
The Guardian "forgets" to mention that a Hamas brigade commander (Muhammad Abu Ismail), who commands thousands of fighters, was in the hospital and was among the targets of the strike.
Not that this is true, but even if it was, bombing a hospital is unforgivable. Netanyahu is a far worse war criminal than anyone in Hamas could ever dream of being. Would it be ok to bomb a hospital he was in?
"Bombing a hospital" is a bit of an overstatement - they bombed the room where three Hamas commanders were. Six casualties is probably <1% of the people in the hospital.
Thankfully the authors of the Fourth Geneva Convention understood that a blanket prohibition on hospital strikes was unworkable, since terrorists who don't care about IHL would be untouchable. Hence
> The protection to which civilian hospitals are entitled shall not cease unless they are used to commit, outside their humanitarian duties, acts harmful to the enemy.
And yes, if Netanyahu was directing military operations from an Israeli hospital, it could absolutely be legal to target it, subject to other IHL principles like precautions in attack.
“Israel says” = lies. They bombed a hospital and this type of thing is why they are the most hated country in the world. There’s no semantic twisting that will ever undo that.
28 comments
[ 0.20 ms ] story [ 20.0 ms ] threadAnother billions of dollars incoming from the West to fuel Israel wars.
Also it was the IDF after all but it was a mistake
Also the IDF did it deliberately and they were carefully targeting Hamas.
Also OK they killed some doctors but why are you focusing so much on Israel? Lots of countries bomb hospitals and schools on a regular basis, you only hear about Israel because the media is so anti-Israel and everyone is an antisemite.
The cleansing of Jews from Arab countries took less than a decade, and it only took a few months to cleanse 100% of the Jews from Arab-controlled areas of Palestine in 1948.
The Zionists must be really bad at ethnics cleansing.
Do you know how many Jewish members of parliament there are in all Arab or Muslim countries combined?
Precisely 0.
The answer is 0.
But if you want to deny facts we can just swap Jews with Arabs in your statement: There was no ethnic cleansing of Arabs from the Jewish nation. There was anti-Zionist terrorism and voluntary immigration.
The Guardian "forgets" to mention that a Hamas brigade commander (Muhammad Abu Ismail), who commands thousands of fighters, was in the hospital and was among the targets of the strike.
"Bombing a hospital" is a bit of an overstatement - they bombed the room where three Hamas commanders were. Six casualties is probably <1% of the people in the hospital.
Thankfully the authors of the Fourth Geneva Convention understood that a blanket prohibition on hospital strikes was unworkable, since terrorists who don't care about IHL would be untouchable. Hence
> The protection to which civilian hospitals are entitled shall not cease unless they are used to commit, outside their humanitarian duties, acts harmful to the enemy.
And yes, if Netanyahu was directing military operations from an Israeli hospital, it could absolutely be legal to target it, subject to other IHL principles like precautions in attack.
Suddenly no more victims ... when of course anyone with a brain knows that this will lead to endless massacres.
Assume kindness.