61 comments

[ 1.8 ms ] story [ 18.7 ms ] thread
Launch stream from ULA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qM5A1ZO9oh8

Seems to cut off near the end for some PR video and doesn't mention anything.

You can actually see a moment at 58:06 in the YouTube video (https://youtu.be/qM5A1ZO9oh8?t=3486) where it switches in the upper right from Live Data to No Data, which is at about the ~+9:24 point. Which somewhat matches the report that it "suffered an anomaly 10 minutes into the flight."
Around 54:22 you see the first and second stage start to roll. After separation, both the first and second stage keep rotating. Then, around 54:33, you see thrusters on the second stage turn on. I'm speculating that is to stop the roll but it could be any number of reasons because by 54:50 it has stopped rotating, and the second stage engines ignite but then the engine nozzles start to move a lot like they are compensating for something, and then settle out. Again, at fairing separation, the nozzles start moving a lot, and the stage is pointed away from the direction of travel.
Eric Berger reports that the fault is likely in the booster stage, not the Centaur upper-stage and not the solid-rocket motors. The means it's either the Vulcan rocket or (more worryingly) the Blue Origin BE-4 engines. If it's the latter, this might also delay the next flight of New Glenn and possibly risk the timelines of the Artemis program.[1]

Irene Klotz reports that this set of BE-4 engines were modified after the New Glenn pad explosion. Specifically, they modified the oxygen valves, which were blamed for the hotfire anomaly (pro-tip: it's always the fucking valves).[2]

The booster shut down about 40 seconds later than the expected timeline, which implies that it had an extra 40 seconds of fuel relative to expectations. It is possible that the modifications somehow caused an under-performance of the booster, which would doom the mission.

[1] https://x.com/SciGuySpace/status/2122070802971385977

[2] https://x.com/Free_Space/status/2122067780543672603

I watched the launch until shortly after the solid-rocket booster separation. Up through the booster separation, things looked pretty good. The boosters didn't have any obvious anomaly and nothing was said in the commentary ~ minute after SRB separation.

I tuned out at that point thinking they had gotten past the hard parts. Genuinely surprised to see this news in post.

Agreed--everything looked good. Booster engine cut-off was ~40 seconds late, though, and stage separation happened lower and at a slower speed than normal. I think at that point, something happened with the Centaur/payload. Either it couldn't handle the aerodynamic forces or maybe it deviated from the corridor and FTS fired.

The ULA animation also showed some strange rotation at stage sep and maybe even a faring bump the Centaur (knocking it off a bit).

Maybe the underperformance of the booster left the upper stage too low and atmospheric drag caused problems at stage separation.

Might honestly be the end of ULA. This is quite a disaster given how shaky everything already was.

And it's another 8 lengths back to Pvt. Smiles (ULA) who is trailing the field ... SpaceX is widening now! He is moving like a tremendous machine! ... Blue is dropping back ... But SpaceX is all alone!

2020s space race, visualized https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfCMtaNiMDM

Probably not ULA entirely for as long as they make Centaur - which was selected as the new upper stage for SLS. They also have a decent number of contracts with Amazon, and also with NASA to bring Starliner to the station.

I wouldn't be surprised if Vulcan goes away, and they survive for a decade on those, and disappear (bought out by Blue or someone else) when SLS is replaced by New Glenn or Starship.

I want ULA to succeed even though I mostly follow SpaceX. A single dominant launch provider is bad for pricing and resilience
Dang it. I feel a sense of despair about yet another failure. We need multiple providers for rockets. I know this is incredibly difficult, endless failures in this difficult world.

Since a lot of the rest of the US space world is struggling to successfully launch, it will be even more of a loss when space x stops the falcon. How much of this is coming from combining and revamping huge existing space companies with a lot of legacy and practies?

I'm with you--space is hard, but Vulcan was supposed to be the easy, reliable rocket.

I'm worried that this is a problem with the BE-4 engines, in which case, New Glenn is also affected.

> space is hard

Per Wikipedia, there must be 100+ orbital launch systems (I didn't count), from 13 countries, going back to 1957:

  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_first_orbital_launches_by_country

  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_orbital_launch_systems

  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_orbital_launch_systems

  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_orbital_launchers_families
It's not hard; lots of people have known how to do it for decades. That's why, as I understand it, NASA handed over orbital launch to the private sector and shifted focus back to the cutting edge of space exploration.
certainly not rocket science
> We need multiple providers for rockets.

We have that? SpaceX, ULA, Blue Origin, Rocket Lab to name a few I can think of.

> Since a lot of the rest of the US space world is struggling to successfully launch

Can you walk me through how you are arriving at this conclusion?

Don’t worry, AST Space Mobile will have reusable rockets in only two years.
Amazon had a deadline, now waived, to deploy over 1600 satellites by the end of last July. Now they need to deploy over 3200 satellites by the end of July, 2029. They are so far behind they need to buy RocketLab?
Rocketlab (neutron) isn't operational yet, far from it. More of Ariane 6 is most likely. The deadline is a floating one, mainly because i think the military see multiple SAT constellations as a national security priority, they have Starlink but thats not enough, 1 is none, 2 is 1.
I’ve been a huge SpaceX fan since back when they were failing to reach orbit with Falcon 1. That said, we (the US, the planet) need more than one successful launch provider. Even Elon (of whom I’m not such a fan) has said things along these lines.

ULA went conservative with the Vulcan design before it was entirely obvious how good Falcon 9 would end up being. And then they’re having awful teething problems anyway. I also wonder if we’re seeing the beginning of the end for them. It’s clear imho that Boeing & Lockheed don’t want to make the kind of investment that would put them back in the front row.

If this is a BE-4 issue, ouch. Really hoping it’s something else in the system if it does turn out to be a booster stage issue.

The real question is how do you build an enduring organization doing complex technical work “at the front row” while not being a cult of personality?
I am not sure if you do, tbh. I’d like to think it’s possible. Having a charismatic focal point sure seems to make it easier, based on observation of the world around us.
Regardless, you need someone to own the vision in its totality for the organization to be effective. Visionary leadership is critical for organizations like this. You can't do vision by committee.

Humans naturally form cults of personality around strong visionary leaders. It is downstream of the necessity of organizing endeavors in this way.

How about "cult of the vision" or "cult of the mission"?
More doing complex technical work, less bemoaning cults of personality?

Or accepting that cults of personality are necessary, you may never be at the center of one and that is OK?

Because in reality, if you look at any of those soberly, that seems a pretty shitty role to play even if the media circle jerks them its because they use it to brag and that bragging is rooted in trying to make themselves feel better about the low-quality reptile they actually are and know they are. That is not something I envy at least.

You can have someone smart and competent run a company without needing the cult bit.
In the Gemini-Apollo programs, who would you say had the role of the center of a cult of personality?

It was a bit before my time, but I don't recall or recall reading about any such behavior on those teams. (Serious question)

> a huge SpaceX fan ... Elon (of whom I’m not such a fan)

You don't get one without the other.

I've read 3 biographies of Musk. He is an extreme risk taker, putting his entire fortune on the line, more than once. At one point he was just hours from total bankruptcy. Would you do that with your $200m fortune? Not me.

He lives in a trailer, not some billion dollar castle.

> You don't get one without the other.

Sure you do. Ask a Yankees fans what they think of Steinbrener.

Agree and disagree. Without getting too deeply into politics (hat tip to Hacker News), let’s just say that while some of Elon’s nature is essential to the success of SpaceX, some of it very much is not.

I used to be a big Elon fan, I assure you.

It was essential, maybe not so anymore. Leadership team is strong.
I don't buy that all his politics are necessary for his success as a fundraiser and risk taking businessman.
I think the left started him into politics with all the threats against him, he kind of had no chance after that
The left doesn’t go after rich people merely for being rich. (You never saw Warren Buffett being hounded.) They go after them for saying awful things.
Yes, being a Nazi is clearly the logical outcome of getting some flack from Democrats.
Not to be that guy, but money is just a number.

I would probably do that because I am doing that right now with my modest low level millions net worth.

I spend less than 10k a year on leisure now. Money isn’t all it is cracked up to be, and I was a paper millionaire when I was late 20s. I had hella fun, but I’m just as happy in a studio now if not more where I can work on my ideas instead of “having experiences” because there is a ceiling.

I don’t think another few millions, or billion or 100 would change my life much.

I commend Elon for his intellectual and business pursuits. I don’t know him but I liked my Tesla.

Oh please. He’s rich beyond failure, something pedestrians will never understand. There’s no such thing as bankruptcy when you’re that rich.
Eh, great man theory has been argued fairly strongly on either side with plenty of concrete examples. I don’t know if he’s even the strongest example.
Glazing a trillionaire for free is hilarious. He doesn't live in a trailer, he owns MULTIPLE million dollar properties. He isn't some humble down to earth person.
A first stage issue is bad for Blue Origin since they supply the BE4s and have been having their own problems with their variants. But a second stage issue is bad for NASA’s Artemis plans since they just announced an expanded Centaur for missions after Artemis 4. So it’s a disaster either way.
“An anomaly”? What actually happened, did it explode? Crash? Burn up in the atmosphere?
The first stage seems to have some sort of problem which resulted in it being lower and slower than it needed to be when the second stage separated. The second stage and payload would have fallen back into the atmosphere and burned up
Just read the wiki on Vulcan, and it's not encouraging, 3 different fuels and types of engines, a lot of ancient technology and production equipment used to build the same part numbers from 1972,and by random sub contractors, the best of which may be wanting out now, and most of the rest will be mainly focused on stuff thats supposed to explode every time, not every second time. snark asside, there are too many moving pieces here to compete with spacex where everything is verticly integrated, like yesterday where the cute chick doing part of the naration for the Starship landing, is also the chief engineer for doing the flaps construction and clearly if anyone there has a question about integration, they just walk over and say , hey! got a minute? and if there is a problem it gets bumped up now! solved, now!, and they build more stuff,now! but look the fuck out because they have terrifying overachiving women running around who can do a convincing to the unwarry, imitations of big hair!, the atrition for under achivers and drop outs must be brutal, but awsome for those that thrive on doing. still hyped from watching them bring it home! vulcan aint got ANY of that vibe and no way to get it.
>> This was the first total mission failure in United Launch Alliance’s 20-year history.

That must be hard for their engineers. That too after a successful launch news from a competing company.

Ricket science is still hard. Kudos to ULA for quietly doing the work.

> Ricket science is still hard.

Spell check isn't though...

Wait wait wait, Amazon has satellites now?
Does ULA launch test flights or just swing for the fences every time? It seems like managing expectations and payload value allowed SpaceX to iterate faster and do things you wouldn't do on a contracted mission.
Why does Amazon have 40 satellites?
Am I the only one weirded out by the sheer volume of satellites is part of the Amazon Leo effort?

Then again hotels and bluetooth beacons (not to mention Xfinity and this new home security sonar wifi router creepier fest) weird me out but no one else seems bothered, maybe its a me thing...

Amazon continues to have major setbacks in its attempts to catch up to Starlink. At this rate they may never catch up.