> In Dark Towers, award-winning journalist David Enrich reveals the truth about Deutsche Bank and its epic path of devastation. Tracing the bank’s history back to its propping up of a default-prone American developer in the 1880s, helping the Nazis build Auschwitz, and wooing Eastern Bloc authoritarians, he shows how in the 1990s, via a succession of hard-charging executives, Deutsche made a fateful decision to pursue Wall Street riches, often at the expense of ethics and the law.
> Soon, the bank was manipulating markets, violating international sanctions to aid terrorist regimes, scamming investors, defrauding regulators, and laundering money for Russian oligarchs. Ever desperate for an American foothold, Deutsche also started doing business with a self-promoting real estate magnate nearly every other bank in the world deemed too dangerous to touch: Donald Trump. Over the next twenty years, Deutsche executives loaned billions to Trump, the Kushner family, and an array of scandal-tarred clients, including convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
Is it dysfunction, corruption, or institutional blindness? Deutsche has had the stink of scandal for decades.
See also Wirecard. To go so far as to prosecute the investigators who uncovered the scam signals an institutional imperative to protect financial agencies rather than regulate them.
Bafin infamously investigated the Financial Times when they credibly accused wirecard of massive fraud and did not investigate wirecard until much later.
I suggest you read the book Dark Towers by David Enrich. It is fully about Deutsche Bank and the culture there, risk taking, chaos, ambitions and disregard for legal compliance on the chase for profits.
Deutsche Bank is kind of famously bad. Germany has a very rules-oriented culture but this doesn't always extend to its biggest corporations who are no strangers to scandal, see also VW.
What typically happens in strict and tight up cultures is that for the most part it stays very strict with a lot of benefits. But, there are usually a "reaction" in that, to a small part (in certain areas of society), you see the total opposite and/or very surprising phenomena. See for example Japanese and German porn (quite famous). Japanese maid cafés, the German techno/rave scene, the Nazi movement and the "Jew" solution (concentration camps), etc.
No scientific references, but based on my personal experience.
One comment mentions Wirecard but doesn't give any details, so I will. A reporter released an investigative piece on the financial company Wirecard for dubious finances. BaFin, the German financial regulator, swiftly filed a criminal complaint... against the reporter. He was also investigated by the state.
The company eventually collapsed, after revealing that €1.9 billion were missing. The CEO was arrested and the COO is believed to have filed to Russia. The Minister of Finance was asked to testify but nothing came out of that - despite being involved in this and another scandal (Cum-Ex), he nonetheless eventually became Chancellor of Germany.
The German (Ex-)chancellor Olaf Scholz was personally involved in the Cum-Ex tax scam. Germany is just as corrupt as any of the Eastern European shit shows they like to claim moral high ground over.
The page needs to summarize critical points without needing to hop into links.
The linked articles require dedicated time to read, (which is good.) Many people will open this, see that it requires time to read, and move on without understanding the major points of the scandal.
A higher level summary will get the point across much more quickly.
> Deutsche Bank's business dealings with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, now US President Donald Trump, and a host of Russian oligarchs.
> Gleaned from nearly 15 million documents leaked [...] the e-mails and meeting minutes trace the bank's aggressive pursuit of business deals in Russia, and with high-profile Russian oligarchs, right up until Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 — despite risk warnings from numerous managers.
They highlight some examples of alleged misbehavior on the /about page but they don't really sound worthy of the scale of this website to me...?
> In Colombia, for example, the bank’s own internal investigation showed that in 2019 it had processed thousands of transactions for companies linked to the adult entertainment business. The money had been sent to women in Colombia through suspicious paths without the bank reporting most transactions to authorities..
So they failed to report some payments that went to porn stars? okay?
> Again and again, internal documents suggest that warnings from the bank’s own experts gave way to commercial interests. This applies in particular to the bank’s Russia business. After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, numerous bank clients almost immediately ended up on sanctions lists — the same clients who had been coveted by the bank for years.
So they had clients in Russia before the invasion... again what is the problem here?
> The documents show Deutsche Bank assisted numerous clients in tax minimisation, including the Siemens corporation. In that case, the then-head of wealth management at Deutsche Bank noted concerns in 2015 about potential adverse media headlines that could arise about banks helping companies dodge their tax obligations. Nevertheless, Deutsche Bank continued; according to internal bank calculations, the German treasury would lose up to 30 million euros per year due to the tax-saving model it promoted.
Isn't it expected that they would help their clients "minimize" their taxes? Isn't that what all accountants do? Note that it doesn't say "evade" but "minimize"
Maybe there's more to it or I'm missing it entirely but none of it sounds groundbreaking to me. Maybe I'm just numb to it.
There are a lot of stories that boil down to journalists not understanding how businesses work or run and writing standard practices as sensationally as possible.
All large banks have such risk/compliance groups. They generally behave like highly risk-averse lawyers, i.e. they will issue warnings about many things that are perfectly legal. I've seen it happen even to small businesses. A friend of mine imported electronics from China to customize and resell to US businesses (i.e. not retail). His small firm was flagged because of "strange foreign transactions" maybe 10 years ago. He said no one at the bank could tell him what was strange about them. As far as I know, he never did anything wrong.
Just looking at the examples they put forward on the /about page:
> then-head of wealth management at Deutsche Bank noted concerns in 2015 about potential adverse media headlines that could arise about banks helping companies dodge their tax obligations
"adverse media headlines that could arise" doesn't sound like it was flagged for potential illegal or even unethical practice. They just thought it might lead to bad press (which it did! ha).
Because their job is to flag everything within reach? Large companies have lots of people that are getting paid to worry, so business decisions can note these concerns and ignore them, if appropriate. Just like big tech getting caught doing some nasty things all the time, the fine is the cost of doing business.
The incentives for internal watchdogs are to flag anything remotely risky. That doesn't mean it's a bad decision to go through with it. The false positive rate is quite high so there is a discussion and then the really bad stuff generally gets stopped after a meeting and the not so bad stuff goes through. But you can look after the fact and find emails that maybe didn't have the full context of the discussions or the record of an accepted risk.
I agree. I don't really like DB much, but these seem like non-issues to me. The porn business is a bit distasteful, IMO, but I don't think they should be denied banking services. Many nations have unsavory governments, but if they're not under sanction, why should a major bank not do business there, especially when their own host nation's gov is doing so? And doesn't everyone try to minimize their taxes? As long as you stay on the right side of the law, I don't see the problem.
I dug into some of the articles in "The Stories" section and found similar conduct. Long story short, they did business with someone who later got accused or investigated for something bad. Since when should a bank close out customer accounts before a criminal conviction or government order to that effect?
It's like the authors think banks (or maybe just DB in particular?) should have a crystal ball that tells them who will later be found wanting.
All that said, I vaguely recall that DB has been involved in criminal activities in the past so they certainly aren't an angelic player. And it wouldn't surprise me if some people within the firm have broken laws. If they break rules or regulations, they should be punished harshly to discourage future rule/law breaking. But honestly, the tone of the website (who's existence itself is sorta odd) seems... well... highly biased and weird.
> I dug into some of the articles in "The Stories" section and found similar conduct. Long story short, they did business with someone who later got accused or investigated for something bad. Since when should a bank close out customer accounts before a criminal conviction or government order to that effect?
This is not an accurate summary of the scope of reporting. Simply reading the article title + subheaders available on the landing page of the site reveals that.
> It's like the authors think banks (or maybe just DB in particular?) should have a crystal ball that tells them who will later be found wanting.
Which of the linked article(s) in TFA are guilty of this? Please link it!
It seems like non-issues to you because of a lack of knowledge about the history of DB. It’s pretty wild for me that you wrote such a post. Forgive me my cynicism, but „my money first! I don’t care about others“ would be a proper title to your post being a teacher. Written in red.
You can get a far more accurate summary of the scale and scope of the reporting by reading trough the subheadings for each story. I've posted them here, in the order that they appear on the site:
1. The Inside Deutsche Bank files span some of the bank’s most sensitive functions and activities: anti-financial crime, sanctions monitoring, internal auditing and the units responsible for deciding whether risky clients stay or go.
2. Leaked documents reveal how dealings with royal dynasty blurred traditional boundaries between investor, client and counterparty
3. More than a decade after Jho Low remains elusive a decade after implicated in the world's largest kleptocracy case. Among his enablers was Deutsche Bank, which facilitated at least 24 transactions totalling €172.98 million linked to Low.
4. Documents in the Inside Deutsche Bank leak reveal Deutsche Bank’s role in supplying weapons now used against civilians in Palestine.
5. One of Hungary’s largest banks allegedly platformed a multi-billion-euro money-laundering scheme linked to a Russian oligarch. Deutsche Bank, which processed many of its payments, struggled to curb the wrongdoing.
6. The Inside Deutsche Bank leak reveals the bank's closeness to the war industry, and how it financed arms supplies to "high-risk" or conflict-ridden countries, violating its own internal policies.
7. Deutsche Bank financed blacklisted operations involving Spanish companies under investigation for corruption.
8. “As you know we have a large Russian Oligarchs client population,” an analyst wrote as the bank braced for sanctions against wealthy clients.
9. Deutsche Bank documents connect Trump-owned companies to laundromat schemes.
10. "Crooks don’t improve miraculously as they get older", said Deutsche bank executive about André Esteves, owner of BTG Pactual, the largest investment bank in Latin America.
11. Deutsche Bank leak shows suspicious Epstein payments that double previously known figure.
12. Deutsche Bank secured an investment portfolio worth hundreds of millions of dollars linked to Saudi Prince Mohammed bin Nayef and helped establish offshore corporate structures to manage it.
The discussion of how much there there is there is still open, but I think the reporting there is more than just payments to porn stars, Russian clients before the Ru-Uk war, and tax shelters.
Deutsche Bank seems to have above average amount of scandals and investigations constantly going on. So, probably no, equivalent data dump would not be as bad.
It was definitely be bad, I am not saying they are good people, but Deutsche Bank seems to be leader of the pack.
> A higher level summary will get the point across much more quickly.
This would be such a cool feature to have on HN comment threads at the top.
Perhaps I’m one of few, but I typically don’t open the linked article. Instead I come directly to HN comments, read those first, and then decide whether to open the article or not. Would be cool if HN included a brief AI summary at the top.
Forgive me if that’s considered bad etiquette, it’s purely a personal preference of mine, but for what it’s worth I do refrain from making comments myself unless I’ve read the actual article.
You're not one of few, I'm sure. I'm just like you in that regard - I often don't even read the articles. I'm here for the commentaries which often times are much better than the articles.
The hackernews UI hides vote counts to avoid bandwagonning. Yet people come here explicitly to outsource their thinking to the group (i.e. read comments instead of source material, or at least the material that is one step closer to source).
> Perhaps I’m one of few, but I typically don’t open the linked article. Instead I come directly to HN comments, read those first, and then decide whether to open the article or not.
This is the blueprint for hacking people's first impression.
I do exactly the same as op. The amount of times I was totally convinced by an impeccable top comment, only to be convinced otherwise by an equally impeccable reply.
So, I'd say, it's the opposite, actually. Taught me to give my first impression a benefit of a doubt.
If there are more than 100 comments, or if the title alone doesn't tell me what it's about, then I'll start with the hackernews comments.
If in this one they'd use the full title "Inside Deutsche Bank: Risky Business" I probably would've started with the article, since it was below my comments threshold.
Critical perspective can come from the comments. It is not always in the original piece.
Witness the recent discussion of Nvidia’s Singapore earnings “disappearing” from their statements.
My conclusion from reading the comments is that the way the finances were written is exactly in accordance with US law. The article was making a lot out of insinuation that this was to hide dealings with China.
I am working on an HN client for iOS that uses Apple Intelligence on device to give summaries like that. It is an opt-in setting for supported devices, because some people dislike Ai or might not want to use the battery on that.
I wager there's a larger problem: this recreates the already present negative feedback loop for investigative journalism. I know there's a lot of generalized disdain for the large consortium of individuals dubbed 'journalists' on HN (not to imply you're one of them), but we really do want these people to be paid for their work. The incentive structure of journalism is fragile and its collapse is only to our collective detriment in both short and long timescales. Until we socially grow up wrt how journalism is valued, I think we ought to shy away from completely leeching journalist's content while subverting the monetization strategies (ads and subs) which make it possible.
Distinctively large number of “publishing partners” on this single-purpose publication who, I assume from content signals, are funded by someone other than Deutsche Bank.
I have no doubts that the publishing partners are financed by parties other than Deutsche Bank. I think you may have misinterpreted what I wrote. All I meant to say is that AI summaries break the kneecaps of monetization for journalism, which is a bad thing for everyone.
I built my own reader tool, a recent feature is I can send it a thread from HN and it creates a summary. Works for other forums. It's useful when I just need a jist and want to see if it's worth reading raw threads myself. It can also check for theme drift over time when I send it same thread at different timestamps.
In particular because this looks like some random LLM slop website trying to make something sound very impressive, and uh.. even after "delving" into some of the details, it's not clear to me what justifies the website. Bank doing bank things around the globe? Nothing special sticks out, one would think stealing, err, I meant, to say: finding 15 million documents somewhere should at least lead to a global laundromat or at least a panama files.
The site is just a hub page for a series of articles, which were written due to documents stolen by whisteblowers which were distributed across multiple publishers to ensure quality reporting at scale and scope, in no different of a manner as the Edward Snowden leaks and the Paradise Papers.
> err, I meant, to say: finding 15 million documents somewhere should at least lead to a global laundromat or at least a panama files.
Only you are describing the events dishonestly, even though the implication is you're mocking the article's lack of honety. From the Himal article, the very first link in TFA
> The whistleblowers, whose identities are being protected, copied the files and removed them from the institution.
No, the dishonest part here is "obtaining" 15 million documents and calling that whistleblowing, its just stealing random data at scale, hoping to make up for the theft by finding something. Desperately so, and that is precisely what the articles look like.
Take for example 'Leaked Files Show Deutsche Bank Protected Russian Profits Despite Warnings' - ok so DB dealt with some Oligarchs before the war, before any sanctions, so... the problem is what, exactly? The inability to see the war coming? The superficial NY Times piece could be summed up as "told you so, Oligarchs bad", knowing how all of this played out, padded to a few paragraphs.
Others just add previously not reported/redacted details to settled cases. And so on.
You didn’t dive deep into the topic, scratching the surface, making pretty wild claims.
As soon it’s about money and damaging others, people behave weird.
I wish you a very good subscription of high quality media to gain knowledge not only about DB but finance, investment and cruel to humanity worldwide. Will take you some years of learning Journey but you’ll made it for sure.
I feel like the whisteblowers own words gives a good summary of what to expect:
> The whistleblowers told us in a written statement: “The information we are providing to you was lawfully obtained. The bank has committed numerous violations of law that are well documented,” they added, referring to the bank’s past issues. “This information sheds light on why these violations occur.”
> One whistleblower said they believe the evidence they have presented demonstrates that, “the c-suite is directly involved” in misconduct at the bank. One said they believe the files contain potential criminal misconduct regarding business relationships with corrupt regimes.
> They specifically referred to Russia, saying that the public "has a right to know of the bank’s involvement with issues such as accounts held by Russian oligarchs.”
> Feels like they should've put direct quotes of those on the landing page.
The transparent (IMO) intent is that people will read the articles at the publisher's venue as to avoid scooping the journalists and leeching off their monetization. TFA is a hub that allows the broader story of the DB leaks to be linked/shared all at once, rather than someone having to send 12 links to 12 articles by 12 publications who all took a separate focus on the leak. The Edward Snowden leaks were handled the same way, for the same reasons.
The major downside to this of course is that the nuance and meat of the articles are linked off site, rather than on the hub.
I remember reading long ago how in the late 90s banks in the USA stopped lending money to Trump because he didn't repay his debts. Where did he turn? Deutsche Bank, of course, just like his pal Putin. It's been a long standing joke between friends and I to use deutsche as an adjective to describe something shady. I hope one day people can be held accountable for white collar crime, it would help society heal a lot.
You ought to clarify what the issue is with their financiers. Also I did not see anyone in the articles or comments implying that Deutsche Bank is the only bank that has scandal. Why the whataboutism? Why are you seemingly trying to suggest via vagueness that there are reasons to skip this reading? Be more forth coming
I assume the potential ties to American intelligence.
The US spooks have infamously helped US corporations for decades, e. g. by alleging corruption from European competitors, leading to US companies instead receiving very lucrative contracts: https://cryptome.org/echelon-cia2.htm
Anything on what Justice Kennedy's son was doing at Deutsche Bank?
I'm still expecting that a sitting US President used extortion and blackmail to cause a SCOTUS judge to step down, there's just no public evidence yet.
The "harm civilians in Gaza" is bad but a mischaracterisation, just as saying "America bombed Japan with two nuclear bombs to kill civilians". If there were only civilians in Gaza then there would be no war.
Deutsche Bank has the wrong name. It should be called American Bank of Qatar. Because these countries hold the most shares. That also explains a lot of issues the bank has.
With all due respect, but this smells like a distraction campaign by a fellow billionaire bank owner whose official rags-to-riches feel good story is that he got rich off south africa's poorest.
Funny how in Le Roux's history various family names from the Epstein universe pop up, such as Wright. His Wikipedia page has been "optimized" so that old versions before 2024 are hidden in the interface.
Michiel le Roux and Epstein were active in international finance during the same time, and they might have worked similar schemes.
> Millennium Trust's funds come from Michiel le Roux, a South African businessman and philanthropist.
> Michiel Scholtz du Pré le Roux (born 20 May 1949) is a South African businessman and philanthropist who fo-founded Capitec Bank
> In its early years Capitec pursued the low-income retail market with substantial success.
> In 1994, Christo Wiese recruited him to serve as managing director of Boland Bank.[1] In around 1998, he resigned under acrimonious circumstances, ultimately culminating in a lawsuit.[3]
> Michiel le Roux, first CE at Boland Bank and later MD of BoE Bank, was a beneficiary to such a scheme. Following his resignation in 1999 a dispute between him and Wiese ended in court. Wiese won the case. [...]
> So on 30 April 1998, at the height of the bull run, Leaf-Wright bought his NBS Boland stock at R10/share. Wiese didn’t disclose his dealings with Le Roux and Leaf-Wright to the Board of BoE. One of Le Roux’s later objections was that Leaf-Wright, who reported to him as financial director of BoE Bank, was incentivised by Wiese.
My DB story: I was hired at DB to a team that supported the mortgage backed securities traders just months prior to the 2008 debacle. It wasn't until early 2010 when I was laid off.
Having worked in large money center bank / investment bank and know a former ceo of one, the truth is that these things are largely unmanageable, the left hand doesn’t know what the right is doing, there are hundreds or thousands of fiefdoms all looking for business / taking risk on the firms behalf, Citigroup has like ~240k employees in like ~160 countries, good luck not breaking the law everywhere even if your trying your best not to, let alone trying to get business in Baku, or Tijuana, or Phnom Penh.
You mean those people have no brain neither moral education?
I do not have to explain a teacher how to behave in front of children in class, right? But why do you kinda write that we have to explain people in finance?
> Our reporters will continue to evaluate the material journalistically over the
> coming months. We will not publish the raw data online.
One of my biggst gripes about journalism today is that biased actors will change the narrative to fit their biases via selective omission of facts, thereby putting forth a misleading version. One doesn't have to actually _lie_ to deceive the public; one can just hide extenuating facts and let the public form their own (misguided) opinion.
This is why I feel like the raw data should be released so we can do our own analyses. Why should I blindly trust a random self-selected, possibly anonymous, group of people?
Because there’s probably a lot of data in there where nothing wrong happened and the people in the data have the right to not have their data published.
It’s not like it’s a tiny cabal, but a huge amount of media companies. If you cannot trust a broad spectrum of journalists then we have a much larger problem.
So instead of journalists “gatekeeping” you’d prefer “influencers” and other professional provocateurs? Because, let’s be honest, Joe Public isn’t going to be trawling through the raw data. Instead they’ll be fed the hottest takes from their preferred bias-bubble distributor.
And so what? Who are journalists to say that they should be entitled to analyze this data and present it to the public and not let anyone they don't approve of to do it?
If Joe Public prefers getting hot takes from influencers, then let them? The public gets what they deserve.
Why not? Many "journalists" are themselves influencers and professional provocateurs, and many non-journalists are, by virtue of being literate in data analysis, much better placed to make sense of huge data dumps than those primarily trained in undergrad journalism programs.
However, there is value in having a distinction between "establishment" journalists and "anyone" influencers. The idea here is not to get all competent and conscientous people into the establishment and keep everyone else out - of course that cannot work, not in areas that are so contested and where it is impossible to take an objective stance. But some sort of quality assurance can be achieved this way, and a bit of fog can be cleared. Because with time, those who have status can be judged and recognized as actually being competent or not. And they can be kicked out. That is what someone in the thread above called "building a reputation".
Of course this will always be contestable, echo-chambers can form, and "revolutions" are in order once in a while. But this is much better than not having any distinction at all, and just living in the fog, where anyone can report anything and I have no means to judge their competence. Asking for this seems to me like an overreaction to the fact that there is no bias-free reporting (which is trivial, but nonetheless elicits the most radical reactions).
(Now to the hot take:) The nice thing is that these kinds of structures don't even need to be artificially build, they emerge on their own. And they would emerge again, after Trump and friends shut down all media houses. New diatinctions will arise in new forms, with time. Trust will be built. And fog will clear again. Why else are you on hacker news rather than truth social?
Well considering that you don't seem to have a problem with it, why don't you start? Just release all your banking history, credit card details, mortgages etc. publically for us to sift through?
The Snowden leaks didn't result in raw data being dumped for the same reason that these internal files won't be. The cowboy method of truly unfiltered access is dangerous and irresponsible. Wikileaks learned this lesson in a very public manner and even Wikileaks didn't escape issues of injecting personal narratives into their reporting that was dubbed objective. Surely we don't need to explain the difference between white hat and black hat actors to HN, right?
Raw data is only a piece too. Journalism is more than rewording a stolen document. It's following leads, establishing sources, and connecting both public and private data points into a narrative that otherwise wouldn't be discoverable.
I find your gripe attributes a blanket presumption of incompetence and malice on journalists. It reads as condescending.
The reason why this story is distributed across so many publications is to quell concerns of deception by omission or similar. Perhaps all the publications fell for the same trick or are in on the same lie, but this is as close to "compile from source" as you can get with reporting on sensitive, stolen, and secret information.
Shorter video showed maga hat wearer was complete asshole, while in longer version one might argue that the drummer was the one testing the boundaries and patience.
Was it reported by a professional serious journalist with good reputation? I don’t know, but it definitely was covered by serious news outlets.
News outlets, even the most reputable ones, have been found to withhold stories to curry favor with those in power. For example, in September 2004, CBS News postponed a completed 60 Minutes investigation questioning the Bush administration's pre-war WMD intelligence (including forged Niger uranium documents).
And before the 2003 Iraq war, the NYT (the "gold standard" of journalism) published numerous front-page stories, many co-authored by Judith Miller, claiming Saddam Hussein possessed active weapons of mass destruction (WMD) programs, relying heavily on administration officials and Iraqi defectors such as Ahmad Chalabi.
And before the November 2004 U.S. presidential election, New York Times reporters James Risen and Eric Lichtblau uncovered the Bush administration's secret National Security Agency (NSA) warrantless domestic surveillance program. Executive Editor Bill Keller and Washington Bureau Chief Philip Taubman decided not to publish the investigation prior to the 2004 election following meetings with White House and intelligence officials who argued publication would compromise national security. The Time held the story for over a year, finally publishing it in December 2005.
I really strongly disagree with this. Let's say you have all the data. You release it. How many people are going to go audit it? Not many. So instead of you, a journalist who actually has a professional interest in this and a reputation to build, you're handing analysis off to clout chasers. Suddenly whoever can find the most explosive viral take will win. Not the most accurate take. The most viral. And the most viral is often something just wrong enough to engage those who want to believe it whilst also engaging those who know enough to refute it - that's where you hit the sweet spot of engagement. Sure someone could go back to the original published data and debunk it - well done, you're driving engagement and uninformed people aren't going to see you debunking it, they're going to 90% see the original false claim, and 10% see a debate they know nothing about which is 50:50 on what they end up believing.
Far more effective is for you to listen to different journalists opinions and reporting over time and answer two questions: "Is this person acting with integrity?" and "What are their biases that I need to factor into my analysis". It is much more important to be listening to journalists who have clear ethical standards - even if you disagree with them.
This sounds like the old argument: Is it gambling or investing? In the short term, it is very difficult to decide, but in the long term most people will agree on one or the other. Also, to be extra tricky, you can actually do both in parallel.
the simple fact is that the data that leaked re: Deutsche Bank, most of it is meaningless IT-related noise. the second most parsimonious explanation is that it would reveal the origin of the leak (almost certainly an IT worker who misused credentials) by the nature of what it doesn't see.
this was the case with Disney's leaked Slack channels. meaningless IT noise, clear who it came from, little newsworthy value.
it's interesting to me that ProPublica is not on their list. i can see from their stories why.
> One of my biggest gripes about journalism today is that biased actors will change the narrative to fit their biases via selective omission of facts, thereby putting forth a misleading version.
So... welcome to being a human being?
How is this different than decades previous? All journalism and journalists have biases. This is a fundamental idea that is widely taught in university journalism courses.
No one else mentioned protecting whistleblowers, so I will:
We all know that our printers carry tracking dots, and similarly there's a good chance that all kind of fingerprinting shenanigans are going on inside these big companies. Or maybe there's a file that only five people are supposed to have and everybody knows who the other four are. Every time you release an original document you risk it being traced back to the leaker.
This is not theoretical, BTW, this is (as far as we know) how Reality Winner was identified:
I was involved with this project as a reporter, though others from my organisation did most of the work.
HN readers may be interested to know a bit about the tech stack. The 15 million or so documents, mostly Outlook mailbox exports, were provided to partners in the consortium via a tool called OpenAleph [1], which is maintained by DARC and based on ElasticSearch and a schema called FollowTheMoney [2], developed specifically for the investigative journalism use case. A lot of the original work on this was done by Friedrich Lindenberg (@pudo), who now runs OpenSanctions [3].
The timing was v. interesting given where we are with LLMs -- it's the first major leak I've worked on where it was possible to leverage local models to do some of the heavy lifting, and this only got more possible as the project went on. The coordinators provided a centrally hosted chatbot with RAG, but I also managed to get some surprisingly useful material using Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on my 24GB M2 MBA via a custom agent harness for Aleph/OpenAleph. [4]
Happy to answer any questions about techy stuff, though I'm not a spokesperson for the project by any means. Seen a few people saying "just release the data!", but I think that slightly misunderstands what this work is. The whole point of forming a consortium of hundreds of journalists and sifting through the dump is to identify the bits that are in the public interest to report on -- especially important in jurisdictions like the UK, where I'm based, which have very strong defamation laws. Think Panama Papers, not Wikileaks.
> especially important in jurisdictions like the UK, where I'm based, which have very strong defamation laws.
So, naturally, will you not err on the side of caution and not say anything that could remotely be used to file a defamation case against you? You will self-censor for the exact reasons you state!
UK is not a domain of free speech. People are being jailed for SM posts[1]. And you expect UK journalists to speak freely?
I read that as, dumping a bunch of raw data without context with names of people that might or might not be bad actors can lead to defamation lawsuits in places like the UK
It harps on about the old canard that a politician’s wife being arrested for a social media post - yes, one in which she directly incited the burning down of hotels full of people.
Linehan’s case was indeed police overreach, and the courts supported him and have awarded him damages.
And yes, the UK has restrictions on what people can do around abortion clinics after years of campaigns of harassment of women masquerading as protest.
This sort of hysterical write up is worthless, and seems only to exist to try to make Americans feel good about themselves, which right now they really shouldn’t be doing.
So let me see if i understand it right; you fed 15 million illegally obtained internal company emails from one of the worlds largest banks into a llm; and this is all you got?
Where are the crimes? Where are the actual breaches?
It’s quite sad that this is what passes for journalism these days. This is not “reporting” and you are no reporter; although I wish misfortune on deutsche as much as the next guy I do hope you have a good lawyer.
> Where are the crimes? Where are the actual breaches?
Well, I think for a start it's a pretty big thing that Deutsche Bank CEO Sewing _actively_ helped Springer head Döpfner with evading taxes for a billion Euro deal by setting up credits and whatnot, overruling internal guidelines and warnings.
Looking to see what else bubbles up from that leak.
If there was actual tax evasion, then sure -- let the heads roll. Megabank finds way to minimize tax on a big deal? Nothingburger. Happens every day.
This all just screams to me like the reporters have very little understanding on how banks actually operate and what they do (source: I work for a different european bank, and have been in banking for some years).
You'll find this behavior in all of them, none of it is news.
When everyone involved says "that was a complicated deal, but we're absolutely not doing it to avoid paying taxes" and the internal discussion begins with "how can we avoid paying taxes on this?" it is pretty damning.
Neither criminal tax revision nor surprising, but pretty hypocritical when they (the springer press papers) frequently rally against heat pump subsidies and social security because the state doesn't have the funds.
You're welcome to your opinion on the findings, which led the front page of the FT today and have been picked up by outlets worldwide.
On "fed 15 million emails into an LLM", that's not quite right -- we performed targeted searches within the leak using research agents operating the same tooling human reporters were using (OpenAleph), focussed on topics which we knew would be in the public interest to report on (based on previous reporting, etc.).
Curious how, specifically, you wove the local models into your process. Were you using them in agentic harnesses? Were they writing code or analyzing text themselves?
Also, presumably you used local models so the stories wouldn't leak via cloud providers but do you mind very clearly spellinf out the value proposition local models gave you for the benefit of all world people reading these comments?
I started off just running Qwen in hax [1], a minimal coding harness, and having it use the OpenAleph API to read documents (Aleph does OCR already), emails, etc. in a free-form session based on hypotheses I had -- kind of like a smart search engine, but context length was limited so these stalled early. I then used Claude to write a harness in Swift (CLI/menu bar app, see above) that uses one model session to queue a load of tasks for short follow-ups, followed by summarisation, which generated pretty useful Markdown reports on my queries, with links through to Aleph for the originals. These mostly related to the bank's involvement with the oil and gas industry (the focus of my research).
On the value prop of local models, it's very important with projects like these to have the data touch the absolute minimum number of machines, both for security against leaks and subpoenas as you say, but also to demonstrate responsible handling practices in case of legal pushback from the subject of the investigation.
DARC is the german ham radio club, equivalent to use US' "ARRL". It stands for Deutscher Amateur Radio Club. It's in use since ... probably right after WW2 then ham radio was again allowed in Germany.
This is the reason why their web address is darc.li, because darc.de is used by the ham radio people.
And if I read their impressum right, they aren't some "Data and Research Center", they are "IDIO Daten Import Export GmbH" based in Berlin.
I'd be very interested in how you instructed the local model. Did you give it specific tasks like "Search for person XY" or did you provide more general/abstract instructions like "show me indications of money laundering in the data"?
Huh, I suppose LLMs should be clever enough to understand "money laundering", but that query seems to need a lot of education.
My guess is it's quite useful to see money movements (e.g. 43,200 Eur transferred to account $FOO, a few hours later the same amount moves from $FOO to $BAR, a few days later a bill of the same amount appears in someones's inbox, etc.
This tech stack probably is the inheritor of alot of work done with the Enron Corpus - the first big body of text data from a large company that could be analysed using machine learning techniques:
But those were the good old days when the public had access. Now companies like Google get that type of data for $10MM and don't have to share any of it:
Thank you for sharing. One question that pops up is the following:
Given that you can organize the data as a weighted graph (if I wrote an email to you there is now a link and the amount of exchanges can be seen as the edge weight), are you guys planning to link those subgraphs/graphs components to other leaked dataset (Panama paper, Epstein emails, ...). Or at least to release such graph so that we can see if person A was in contact with Person B which, for example, was a buddy of a Russian Oligarch.
I believe that could be really useful if and when investigators will look into the heap of corrupted fucks that sit at the top.
And it is not enough. Germany has built up a huge backlog of public investments over the years and this is generally agreed on. What is not agreed on is how to pay for this. In reality, as Germany is unable to make any significant cuts on the spending side, it boils down to the question of higher taxes (for whom?) or higher debt.
This piece of journalism shows that the existing tax laws applied more evenly across the board with fewer loopholes for the wealthy would already bring some of the required income without increasing the tax burden on 99% of the population.
171 comments
[ 4.8 ms ] story [ 87.5 ms ] threadSo important ourdays. Thanks!
> In Dark Towers, award-winning journalist David Enrich reveals the truth about Deutsche Bank and its epic path of devastation. Tracing the bank’s history back to its propping up of a default-prone American developer in the 1880s, helping the Nazis build Auschwitz, and wooing Eastern Bloc authoritarians, he shows how in the 1990s, via a succession of hard-charging executives, Deutsche made a fateful decision to pursue Wall Street riches, often at the expense of ethics and the law.
> Soon, the bank was manipulating markets, violating international sanctions to aid terrorist regimes, scamming investors, defrauding regulators, and laundering money for Russian oligarchs. Ever desperate for an American foothold, Deutsche also started doing business with a self-promoting real estate magnate nearly every other bank in the world deemed too dangerous to touch: Donald Trump. Over the next twenty years, Deutsche executives loaned billions to Trump, the Kushner family, and an array of scandal-tarred clients, including convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
* https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/45730424-dark-towers
* https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/feb/16/dark-towers...
* https://archive.ph/https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/th...
* https://www.npr.org/2020/02/18/806984703/dark-towers-is-a-ca...
See also Wirecard. To go so far as to prosecute the investigators who uncovered the scam signals an institutional imperative to protect financial agencies rather than regulate them.
Bafin infamously investigated the Financial Times when they credibly accused wirecard of massive fraud and did not investigate wirecard until much later.
With an ex-Blackrock employee currently running the show, snowflakes and hell come to mind.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/blackrock-hires-former-merkel-d...
You can say that again. Although sometimes it feels like it's more letter-of-the, rather than spirit-of-the.
With wide spread adoption of digital devices, that has now become “computer says no, so I can’t do anything”-spirit.
Germans blindly follow the rules made for them by others.
No scientific references, but based on my personal experience.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirecard_scandal
The company eventually collapsed, after revealing that €1.9 billion were missing. The CEO was arrested and the COO is believed to have filed to Russia. The Minister of Finance was asked to testify but nothing came out of that - despite being involved in this and another scandal (Cum-Ex), he nonetheless eventually became Chancellor of Germany.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirecard_scandal
Look him up, Jan Marsalek. If his story would have happened in a Bond movie, audiences would have laughed because it was too crazy.
I'm all for uncovering unambiguous bad behavior. I don't like attack ad-style emotional manipulation.
The linked articles require dedicated time to read, (which is good.) Many people will open this, see that it requires time to read, and move on without understanding the major points of the scandal.
A higher level summary will get the point across much more quickly.
> Deutsche Bank's business dealings with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, now US President Donald Trump, and a host of Russian oligarchs.
> Gleaned from nearly 15 million documents leaked [...] the e-mails and meeting minutes trace the bank's aggressive pursuit of business deals in Russia, and with high-profile Russian oligarchs, right up until Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 — despite risk warnings from numerous managers.
https://www.dw.com/en/deutsche-bank-under-fire-after-interna...
> In Colombia, for example, the bank’s own internal investigation showed that in 2019 it had processed thousands of transactions for companies linked to the adult entertainment business. The money had been sent to women in Colombia through suspicious paths without the bank reporting most transactions to authorities..
So they failed to report some payments that went to porn stars? okay?
> Again and again, internal documents suggest that warnings from the bank’s own experts gave way to commercial interests. This applies in particular to the bank’s Russia business. After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, numerous bank clients almost immediately ended up on sanctions lists — the same clients who had been coveted by the bank for years.
So they had clients in Russia before the invasion... again what is the problem here?
> The documents show Deutsche Bank assisted numerous clients in tax minimisation, including the Siemens corporation. In that case, the then-head of wealth management at Deutsche Bank noted concerns in 2015 about potential adverse media headlines that could arise about banks helping companies dodge their tax obligations. Nevertheless, Deutsche Bank continued; according to internal bank calculations, the German treasury would lose up to 30 million euros per year due to the tax-saving model it promoted.
Isn't it expected that they would help their clients "minimize" their taxes? Isn't that what all accountants do? Note that it doesn't say "evade" but "minimize"
Maybe there's more to it or I'm missing it entirely but none of it sounds groundbreaking to me. Maybe I'm just numb to it.
> then-head of wealth management at Deutsche Bank noted concerns in 2015 about potential adverse media headlines that could arise about banks helping companies dodge their tax obligations
"adverse media headlines that could arise" doesn't sound like it was flagged for potential illegal or even unethical practice. They just thought it might lead to bad press (which it did! ha).
I dug into some of the articles in "The Stories" section and found similar conduct. Long story short, they did business with someone who later got accused or investigated for something bad. Since when should a bank close out customer accounts before a criminal conviction or government order to that effect?
It's like the authors think banks (or maybe just DB in particular?) should have a crystal ball that tells them who will later be found wanting.
All that said, I vaguely recall that DB has been involved in criminal activities in the past so they certainly aren't an angelic player. And it wouldn't surprise me if some people within the firm have broken laws. If they break rules or regulations, they should be punished harshly to discourage future rule/law breaking. But honestly, the tone of the website (who's existence itself is sorta odd) seems... well... highly biased and weird.
This is not an accurate summary of the scope of reporting. Simply reading the article title + subheaders available on the landing page of the site reveals that.
> It's like the authors think banks (or maybe just DB in particular?) should have a crystal ball that tells them who will later be found wanting.
Which of the linked article(s) in TFA are guilty of this? Please link it!
1. The Inside Deutsche Bank files span some of the bank’s most sensitive functions and activities: anti-financial crime, sanctions monitoring, internal auditing and the units responsible for deciding whether risky clients stay or go.
2. Leaked documents reveal how dealings with royal dynasty blurred traditional boundaries between investor, client and counterparty
3. More than a decade after Jho Low remains elusive a decade after implicated in the world's largest kleptocracy case. Among his enablers was Deutsche Bank, which facilitated at least 24 transactions totalling €172.98 million linked to Low.
4. Documents in the Inside Deutsche Bank leak reveal Deutsche Bank’s role in supplying weapons now used against civilians in Palestine.
5. One of Hungary’s largest banks allegedly platformed a multi-billion-euro money-laundering scheme linked to a Russian oligarch. Deutsche Bank, which processed many of its payments, struggled to curb the wrongdoing.
6. The Inside Deutsche Bank leak reveals the bank's closeness to the war industry, and how it financed arms supplies to "high-risk" or conflict-ridden countries, violating its own internal policies.
7. Deutsche Bank financed blacklisted operations involving Spanish companies under investigation for corruption.
8. “As you know we have a large Russian Oligarchs client population,” an analyst wrote as the bank braced for sanctions against wealthy clients.
9. Deutsche Bank documents connect Trump-owned companies to laundromat schemes.
10. "Crooks don’t improve miraculously as they get older", said Deutsche bank executive about André Esteves, owner of BTG Pactual, the largest investment bank in Latin America.
11. Deutsche Bank leak shows suspicious Epstein payments that double previously known figure.
12. Deutsche Bank secured an investment portfolio worth hundreds of millions of dollars linked to Saudi Prince Mohammed bin Nayef and helped establish offshore corporate structures to manage it.
The discussion of how much there there is there is still open, but I think the reporting there is more than just payments to porn stars, Russian clients before the Ru-Uk war, and tax shelters.
It was definitely be bad, I am not saying they are good people, but Deutsche Bank seems to be leader of the pack.
This would be such a cool feature to have on HN comment threads at the top.
Perhaps I’m one of few, but I typically don’t open the linked article. Instead I come directly to HN comments, read those first, and then decide whether to open the article or not. Would be cool if HN included a brief AI summary at the top.
Forgive me if that’s considered bad etiquette, it’s purely a personal preference of mine, but for what it’s worth I do refrain from making comments myself unless I’ve read the actual article.
substituting TFA with HN comments is a whole different level, especially when it's investigative journalism.
what a dire and bizarre perspective.
Like a headline "LLMs make people dumber" and the article is so nuanced and takes you on a really good ride, opening up a number of perspectives.
But all hackernews comments just read like people showing up to the bookclub without reading the material.
If you haven't had that feeling yet, read the full article and then read the comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48387270
This is the blueprint for hacking people's first impression.
So, I'd say, it's the opposite, actually. Taught me to give my first impression a benefit of a doubt.
If in this one they'd use the full title "Inside Deutsche Bank: Risky Business" I probably would've started with the article, since it was below my comments threshold.
Witness the recent discussion of Nvidia’s Singapore earnings “disappearing” from their statements.
My conclusion from reading the comments is that the way the finances were written is exactly in accordance with US law. The article was making a lot out of insinuation that this was to hide dealings with China.
Here's a TestFlight link if anyone wants to try it out: https://testflight.apple.com/join/HqmgYvUF
Problem is, much like people just reading the title today, folks will argue about what they read in the AI summary and not TFA.
Meanwhile on the HN front page: AI is killing All About Berlin [1]
AI summaries are destroying people's livelihoods. Let's not encourage them further.
1.https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50542705
> err, I meant, to say: finding 15 million documents somewhere should at least lead to a global laundromat or at least a panama files.
Only you are describing the events dishonestly, even though the implication is you're mocking the article's lack of honety. From the Himal article, the very first link in TFA
> The whistleblowers, whose identities are being protected, copied the files and removed them from the institution.
Take for example 'Leaked Files Show Deutsche Bank Protected Russian Profits Despite Warnings' - ok so DB dealt with some Oligarchs before the war, before any sanctions, so... the problem is what, exactly? The inability to see the war coming? The superficial NY Times piece could be summed up as "told you so, Oligarchs bad", knowing how all of this played out, padded to a few paragraphs.
Others just add previously not reported/redacted details to settled cases. And so on.
I wish you a very good subscription of high quality media to gain knowledge not only about DB but finance, investment and cruel to humanity worldwide. Will take you some years of learning Journey but you’ll made it for sure.
With all respect.
> The whistleblowers told us in a written statement: “The information we are providing to you was lawfully obtained. The bank has committed numerous violations of law that are well documented,” they added, referring to the bank’s past issues. “This information sheds light on why these violations occur.”
> One whistleblower said they believe the evidence they have presented demonstrates that, “the c-suite is directly involved” in misconduct at the bank. One said they believe the files contain potential criminal misconduct regarding business relationships with corrupt regimes.
> They specifically referred to Russia, saying that the public "has a right to know of the bank’s involvement with issues such as accounts held by Russian oligarchs.”
https://www.inside-db.com/the-leak/#the-whistleblowers
Feels like they should've put direct quotes of those on the landing page.
The transparent (IMO) intent is that people will read the articles at the publisher's venue as to avoid scooping the journalists and leeching off their monetization. TFA is a hub that allows the broader story of the DB leaks to be linked/shared all at once, rather than someone having to send 12 links to 12 articles by 12 publications who all took a separate focus on the leak. The Edward Snowden leaks were handled the same way, for the same reasons.
The major downside to this of course is that the nuance and meat of the articles are linked off site, rather than on the hub.
https://www.propublica.org/article/trump-inc-podcast-deutsch...
https://www.alabseries.com/episodes/episode-14-epsteins-bank
For a deep dive into the compliance mess from years ago
Open Society and NED, the CIA cutout.
It's amazing how fast American Midterms are yielding results.
PS: If you think that this bank is problematic but other Western banks aren't I got a lot of bridges to sell to you.
The US spooks have infamously helped US corporations for decades, e. g. by alleging corruption from European competitors, leading to US companies instead receiving very lucrative contracts: https://cryptome.org/echelon-cia2.htm
I'm still expecting that a sitting US President used extortion and blackmail to cause a SCOTUS judge to step down, there's just no public evidence yet.
Original clip: https://www.c-span.org/clip/white-house-event/user-clip-a-wa...
Slowed down: https://vimeo.com/294491308
Why is this pile of turds on the HN front page?
I can’t tell whether this is a scoop at all or somebody just told an AI to make a hit site about Deutsche.
Funny how in Le Roux's history various family names from the Epstein universe pop up, such as Wright. His Wikipedia page has been "optimized" so that old versions before 2024 are hidden in the interface.
Michiel le Roux and Epstein were active in international finance during the same time, and they might have worked similar schemes.
From https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Michiel_le_Roux&o... - From https://www.news24.com/business/boes-leaf-wright-goes-wrong-...What does the word 'like' mean here?
> Our reporters will continue to evaluate the material journalistically over the
> coming months. We will not publish the raw data online.
One of my biggst gripes about journalism today is that biased actors will change the narrative to fit their biases via selective omission of facts, thereby putting forth a misleading version. One doesn't have to actually _lie_ to deceive the public; one can just hide extenuating facts and let the public form their own (misguided) opinion.
This is why I feel like the raw data should be released so we can do our own analyses. Why should I blindly trust a random self-selected, possibly anonymous, group of people?
It’s not like it’s a tiny cabal, but a huge amount of media companies. If you cannot trust a broad spectrum of journalists then we have a much larger problem.
If Joe Public prefers getting hot takes from influencers, then let them? The public gets what they deserve.
However, there is value in having a distinction between "establishment" journalists and "anyone" influencers. The idea here is not to get all competent and conscientous people into the establishment and keep everyone else out - of course that cannot work, not in areas that are so contested and where it is impossible to take an objective stance. But some sort of quality assurance can be achieved this way, and a bit of fog can be cleared. Because with time, those who have status can be judged and recognized as actually being competent or not. And they can be kicked out. That is what someone in the thread above called "building a reputation".
Of course this will always be contestable, echo-chambers can form, and "revolutions" are in order once in a while. But this is much better than not having any distinction at all, and just living in the fog, where anyone can report anything and I have no means to judge their competence. Asking for this seems to me like an overreaction to the fact that there is no bias-free reporting (which is trivial, but nonetheless elicits the most radical reactions).
(Now to the hot take:) The nice thing is that these kinds of structures don't even need to be artificially build, they emerge on their own. And they would emerge again, after Trump and friends shut down all media houses. New diatinctions will arise in new forms, with time. Trust will be built. And fog will clear again. Why else are you on hacker news rather than truth social?
"Today"?
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Randolph_Hearst#Spanis...
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism
Raw data is only a piece too. Journalism is more than rewording a stolen document. It's following leads, establishing sources, and connecting both public and private data points into a narrative that otherwise wouldn't be discoverable.
I find your gripe attributes a blanket presumption of incompetence and malice on journalists. It reads as condescending.
The reason why this story is distributed across so many publications is to quell concerns of deception by omission or similar. Perhaps all the publications fell for the same trick or are in on the same lie, but this is as close to "compile from source" as you can get with reporting on sensitive, stolen, and secret information.
I think, things like this forms somewhat distrusting nature of the news agencies.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Lincoln_Memorial_confront...
Shorter video showed maga hat wearer was complete asshole, while in longer version one might argue that the drummer was the one testing the boundaries and patience.
Was it reported by a professional serious journalist with good reputation? I don’t know, but it definitely was covered by serious news outlets.
And before the 2003 Iraq war, the NYT (the "gold standard" of journalism) published numerous front-page stories, many co-authored by Judith Miller, claiming Saddam Hussein possessed active weapons of mass destruction (WMD) programs, relying heavily on administration officials and Iraqi defectors such as Ahmad Chalabi.
And before the November 2004 U.S. presidential election, New York Times reporters James Risen and Eric Lichtblau uncovered the Bush administration's secret National Security Agency (NSA) warrantless domestic surveillance program. Executive Editor Bill Keller and Washington Bureau Chief Philip Taubman decided not to publish the investigation prior to the 2004 election following meetings with White House and intelligence officials who argued publication would compromise national security. The Time held the story for over a year, finally publishing it in December 2005.
Far more effective is for you to listen to different journalists opinions and reporting over time and answer two questions: "Is this person acting with integrity?" and "What are their biases that I need to factor into my analysis". It is much more important to be listening to journalists who have clear ethical standards - even if you disagree with them.
I don't agree with it but it's not crazy ...
However there is no good justification for not releasing the raw data eventually, which it appears will not occur.
the simple fact is that the data that leaked re: Deutsche Bank, most of it is meaningless IT-related noise. the second most parsimonious explanation is that it would reveal the origin of the leak (almost certainly an IT worker who misused credentials) by the nature of what it doesn't see.
this was the case with Disney's leaked Slack channels. meaningless IT noise, clear who it came from, little newsworthy value.
it's interesting to me that ProPublica is not on their list. i can see from their stories why.
How is this different than decades previous? All journalism and journalists have biases. This is a fundamental idea that is widely taught in university journalism courses.
We all know that our printers carry tracking dots, and similarly there's a good chance that all kind of fingerprinting shenanigans are going on inside these big companies. Or maybe there's a file that only five people are supposed to have and everybody knows who the other four are. Every time you release an original document you risk it being traced back to the leaker.
This is not theoretical, BTW, this is (as far as we know) how Reality Winner was identified:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner#Role_of_The_Int...
But if it stealing or killing then unlikely new info will change a base - it's bad.
Even journalists releasing full data can be gamed by someone.
World would be much better if not just bad peoples doings...
HN readers may be interested to know a bit about the tech stack. The 15 million or so documents, mostly Outlook mailbox exports, were provided to partners in the consortium via a tool called OpenAleph [1], which is maintained by DARC and based on ElasticSearch and a schema called FollowTheMoney [2], developed specifically for the investigative journalism use case. A lot of the original work on this was done by Friedrich Lindenberg (@pudo), who now runs OpenSanctions [3].
The timing was v. interesting given where we are with LLMs -- it's the first major leak I've worked on where it was possible to leverage local models to do some of the heavy lifting, and this only got more possible as the project went on. The coordinators provided a centrally hosted chatbot with RAG, but I also managed to get some surprisingly useful material using Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on my 24GB M2 MBA via a custom agent harness for Aleph/OpenAleph. [4]
Happy to answer any questions about techy stuff, though I'm not a spokesperson for the project by any means. Seen a few people saying "just release the data!", but I think that slightly misunderstands what this work is. The whole point of forming a consortium of hundreds of journalists and sifting through the dump is to identify the bits that are in the public interest to report on -- especially important in jurisdictions like the UK, where I'm based, which have very strong defamation laws. Think Panama Papers, not Wikileaks.
[1] https://darc.li/openaleph/ [2] https://followthemoney.tech/ [3] https://www.opensanctions.org/ [4] https://github.com/data-desk-eco/sift
So, naturally, will you not err on the side of caution and not say anything that could remotely be used to file a defamation case against you? You will self-censor for the exact reasons you state!
UK is not a domain of free speech. People are being jailed for SM posts[1]. And you expect UK journalists to speak freely?
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/steveforbes/2025/09/09/people-a...
It harps on about the old canard that a politician’s wife being arrested for a social media post - yes, one in which she directly incited the burning down of hotels full of people.
Linehan’s case was indeed police overreach, and the courts supported him and have awarded him damages.
And yes, the UK has restrictions on what people can do around abortion clinics after years of campaigns of harassment of women masquerading as protest.
This sort of hysterical write up is worthless, and seems only to exist to try to make Americans feel good about themselves, which right now they really shouldn’t be doing.
Where are the crimes? Where are the actual breaches?
It’s quite sad that this is what passes for journalism these days. This is not “reporting” and you are no reporter; although I wish misfortune on deutsche as much as the next guy I do hope you have a good lawyer.
Well, I think for a start it's a pretty big thing that Deutsche Bank CEO Sewing _actively_ helped Springer head Döpfner with evading taxes for a billion Euro deal by setting up credits and whatnot, overruling internal guidelines and warnings.
Looking to see what else bubbles up from that leak.
This all just screams to me like the reporters have very little understanding on how banks actually operate and what they do (source: I work for a different european bank, and have been in banking for some years).
You'll find this behavior in all of them, none of it is news.
Neither criminal tax revision nor surprising, but pretty hypocritical when they (the springer press papers) frequently rally against heat pump subsidies and social security because the state doesn't have the funds.
On "fed 15 million emails into an LLM", that's not quite right -- we performed targeted searches within the leak using research agents operating the same tooling human reporters were using (OpenAleph), focussed on topics which we knew would be in the public interest to report on (based on previous reporting, etc.).
He is: https://tcij.org/person/louis-goddard/
Also, presumably you used local models so the stories wouldn't leak via cloud providers but do you mind very clearly spellinf out the value proposition local models gave you for the benefit of all world people reading these comments?
On the value prop of local models, it's very important with projects like these to have the data touch the absolute minimum number of machines, both for security against leaks and subpoenas as you say, but also to demonstrate responsible handling practices in case of legal pushback from the subject of the investigation.
https://github.com/OleksandrChekhovskyi/hax
Can you add a little detail on how you implemented/prompted the search-task-summary loop?
DARC is the german ham radio club, equivalent to use US' "ARRL". It stands for Deutscher Amateur Radio Club. It's in use since ... probably right after WW2 then ham radio was again allowed in Germany.
This is the reason why their web address is darc.li, because darc.de is used by the ham radio people.
And if I read their impressum right, they aren't some "Data and Research Center", they are "IDIO Daten Import Export GmbH" based in Berlin.
Weird.
My guess is it's quite useful to see money movements (e.g. 43,200 Eur transferred to account $FOO, a few hours later the same amount moves from $FOO to $BAR, a few days later a bill of the same amount appears in someones's inbox, etc.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enron_Corpus
But those were the good old days when the public had access. Now companies like Google get that type of data for $10MM and don't have to share any of it:
https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/google-buy-spirit-a...
Given that you can organize the data as a weighted graph (if I wrote an email to you there is now a link and the amount of exchanges can be seen as the edge weight), are you guys planning to link those subgraphs/graphs components to other leaked dataset (Panama paper, Epstein emails, ...). Or at least to release such graph so that we can see if person A was in contact with Person B which, for example, was a buddy of a Russian Oligarch.
I believe that could be really useful if and when investigators will look into the heap of corrupted fucks that sit at the top.
> German treasury would lose up to 30 million euros per year due to the tax-saving model it promoted
Saving tax in Germany is time honored tradition. Why do you think companies like Taxfix exist?
Although I did forget the euros v. dollar thing, so in fact it’s just above one Musk.