95 comments

[ 2.6 ms ] story [ 71.5 ms ] thread
This is... just crazy. One of those mostly boring bits of plumbing that has been left to professionals throughout the entire 50 years of my life - and they're trying to wreck it.
Holy shit.

So our monetary policy will be just set at the arbitrary whims of the president if this new scheme works.

Why does all of this feel like it's just sliding completely out of hand? Am I just being a doomer?

Unprecedented times call for unlikely youtube heroes.
(comment deleted)
He certainly doesn't beat around the bush here. Very nice too see someone of his stature stand up and call out these shenanigans for what they are.
His term ends on May 15, 2026, so it's almost pointless to file these charges now.

I see what's happening now as game-theory signaling, not as a real threat to Powell. I would suggest that this action is better seen as a latent threat to the next Fed chairman to let them know that they will either enact Trumps desired Fed policies or they will be prosecuted for anything that the administration can manufacture.

It's also important to remember that Powell is not the only Federal Reserve Board of Governors to have very odd accusations of wrongdoing and investigations launched. He's also done this with Lisa Cook. It seems pretty blatant at this point what's really happening.

> His term ends on May 15, 2026, so it's almost pointless to file these charges now

His term as chairman ends in May. He remains on the Board of Governors after that. Following this fight, he may remain the most prominet voice despite losing the chairmanship.

Many times I've disagreed with Powell, but major props for this statement.
Economists: The interest rate on US Treasuries is often used as a benchmark for the “risk free rate”

Trump: Hold my beer.

Wild. Some kind of fucking banana republic.
"The threat of criminal charges is a consequence of the Federal Reserve setting interest rates based on our best assessment of what will serve the public, rather than following the preferences of the President."

Thank you, Mr. Powell. We really want interest rates set to serve the people, not the whims of the President.

It seems like they learned a lot from the Letitia James and James Comey cases, which are going great (not in the way they intended).
Exciting two weeks to start the year!
Its crazy how you can see where things are heading and still be surprised when they arrive there.
I’m of the opinion from the old Yiddish proverb: “when the cat and dog are fighting, the mouse is safe”.

If the admin is fighting with the Federal Reserve, it means they are not focused on figuring out how to further screw us over…

What's a pleb supposed to do now? Convert every paycheck to BTC, gold, or EUR?
Terrible. Trump was even the person who nominated Powell in 2017, and now he’s being squeezed for doing the job of Federal Reserve Chair instead of bending to demands.
Does anyone have a steelman argument for this?
I hate Trump but Treasury control over central banks and interest rates is not a particularly revolutionary thing. Independent central bank is a relatively new invention and a non-independently controlled central reserve bank did not always lead to immediate implosion in all cases. The concept of independent central bank only became popularized in the 1920s. The world existed before that.

The dire thing here is that Trump himself is a maniac, so him taking control is very scary, but a non-independent central bank itself is not as big a calamity as 1000 other problems we're facing in society.

History: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_bank_independence

You can find many criticisms of the job performance of many of the past chairs of the US fed, the Fed is not infallible. The current Everything Bubble / Too Big to Fail situation we are in is largely of their creation.

So I'm sitting here as a Canadian wondering what the American people are going to do? I understand a lot of what the President of The United States says - I even agree with some of it, the problem is I don't feel like we're engaging with the American people anymore. I really wonder where you guys are headed and what it means for the rest of us, I spent 15 years in the states, built a public company there, I really like the Americans, but I don't want annexation. I wonder where you guys are headed.
How many people have sat down and "war gamed" this out? e.g.

Let's say that opposition to... Trump's unilateral rule, disregard for the constitution, interference with free and fair elections, building a private army and using it increasingly against immigrants and citizens alike, as long as they are "opposition" to Trump, etc... decides to get as organized and impactful as possible? What does that look like?

Some kind of public, open communication portal? A closed sign-up portal where you have to put in your information?

Some kind of plan to put a lot of bodies in one place? Peaceful protest? Armed and violent protest? (Literally insurrection against the authoritarian regime.)

Even the peaceful protest option which is scattered across 50 states, hundreds of cities, has resulted in some violent reaction by Trump's army, National Guard, even local law enforcement.

What are next steps for the American people?

I think those that are protesting by trying to keep it peaceful are holding onto hope that power is still somewhat distributed, and that elections still function enough to displace Trump loyalists (MAGA / Republicans) with Democrats that have at least paid lip service to being opposed to Trump. And maybe given a majority in Congress, they could at least enact impeachment.

But what else are the American people meant to do?

The problem is that a lot of what is happening is within the executive branch's power and/or democratic. A nontrivial number of Americans support everything that has been happening. The expectation at a time like this would be that you have checks and balances working, but all other branches have yielded their power. I find that jaw dropping personally, but it's where we are. Midterms are happening soon and are the right place to disrupt congress.
And of course equity futures immediately dropped on the news
So this is the bar for the next country to surpass the US as the world's economic super-power, if this continues it's most likely going to be China to surpass the US.

An opportunity for the EU to stop its bureaucracy and cleanup its act. If it cannot convince anyone that they are next, then one can argue that democracy is completely finished.

If this nonsense continues it will be the UAE + Saudi Arabia + China, cutting off the west and that's that.

[flagged]
The titanic amount of generational neglect that has allowed even a fraction of voters to look at Trump for more than a second and find him qualified for any public office is truly fantastic.

This is one of the clear examples that Trump is seeing Putin's Russia as a model for his vision for the USA.

Remember early in his first term when he tested waters but the governmental system pushed back and kept him in check? It feels like an out of body experience to look at this and contemplate how much he’s changed about how the U.S. government conducts itself.