It’s just the hype train is excessive and in everyone’s faces and anything that’s like that genuinely becomes hated.
Imagine if I saved the lives of hundreds of people everyday. And I would throw this fact in your face everyday via TikTok, email spam, YouTube, social media.
Pretty soon you’ll become sick of it. You’ll not care for anyones life. Thats what is happening with ai. Ai is genuinely from a logical standpoint, incredible. But all of that is diluted by overhype.
> It simply does not do the magical stuff people claim it does.
What are you even talking about? You can see it do the magic yourself for like $20. The lean proof of the exponential time hypotheses disproof for exampe is straight up on github right now for you to look at.
What magical thing are you waiting for? It is literally currently revolutionaizing all engineering work.
It's just fantastic, to think the cost of running the Stasi was once 20% of national GDP and now that same oppressive all seeing surveillance and data collation is available for pennies on the dollar.
For clarity, I'm more or less indifferent to AI, I do understand how it all works - it's humans with AI I don't trust and that I don't see being adequately reigned in.
Did the centuries of work of scientists and philophers in chemistry put food on any groups table? Do you think haber bosch would have just dropped out of the sky one day randomly?
I can understand a triangle and how come Pitagora’s work might have been worthwhile, but I cannot even begin to understand what this Navier thing is about. You seem to believe in higher maths putting food on our tables, care to delve more into that?
If you don't know how and what kinds of math is needed in every tech and science we use, then I have nothing to say. I should have recognized when you said this and stopped interacting further.
The reason USSR failed was because its economic system was as we know in hindsight incorrect...and literally unscientific theories like Lysenkoism foisted by the government. If you wanted to argue the USSR failed due to science and tech, then you would be wrong. You also have to prove the USA didn't succeed due to tech.
Except AI isnt saving lives. It isnt even usually improving lives. For the most part it is being used to justify laying people off, to heap more responsibility on those that remain, to destroy the livelihood of artists, and to flood public spaces with slop. Even if the capabilities are incredible, the average lived experience of it is awful.
It's not the hype we are tired of. We're tired of the hype being wrong, and pro-AI people being quasi-religious zealots about, while ignoring the massive costs and harms. And if you question the AI dogma, you are accused of being either a Luddite who doesn't understand, or a victim of a Chinese influence campaign.
The hype is not wrong. It’s just too much. Navier stokes and hundreds of other unsolvable math problems were solved. That is genuinely real and worth the hype.
My entire company now uses AI to code. Nobody writes code by hand at my company anymore. At this point if you can’t see how incredible and horrifying it is then you’re delusional.
I get it though. One year ago you’d be right. The paradigm shift is happening so fast people haven’t updated their priors. What you believed to be true just changed. It flipped several times this year and people who keep up to date had to completely flip their understanding of the world and the nature of AI several times. This is not an easy thing to do and thus many people like you just missed the boat.
There’s no doubt that there is a financial ai bubble. But that bubble is completely orthogonal to the complete paradigm shift of the actual capabilities of AI.
I think the point is not that AI is not great, but it's less than what was promised.
Very good analogy with Tesla FSD. Is it great tech- yes, of course. Is is the thing that was promised to come out 10 years ago? Far from it.
If you expect AI to do everything for you, it's still not there. And if you're sceptic or even neutral to this topic- AI is just causing more problems (especially in security) by the day.
The effects of all of those those changes that you mentioned were not that drastic when it came to getting food off the table of those millions of people, I'm saying that those millions won't remain like sheep and will make things right sooner rather than later, that's what always happens (see Polanyi, for example).
But, yeah, you AI zealots on forums like this one can keep thinking that we, those millions, will just remain like sheep taken to the slaughterhouse while you enjoy your higher comps while in the service of today's AI masters.
You are the zealot who got frenzied into psychosis by one of the biggest accelerators of math and science that we invented.
And changes were in fact drastic, thr fact that countries like UK and Germany for several years became the most powerful countries in the europe due to the industrial revolution.
Solving abstract mathematical puzzles and enganhing in pointless research into substances for crnturies gave us ultimately the Haber-Bosch process, which literally keeps the human race from starving. You would prefer humans starve just to protect som jobs.
On the topic of farming, that used to be the occupation of most of thr population in olden times, today its barely 2 percent. Agriculture tech has already killed millions of jobs.
No amount of technology can solve the starvation in those countries. The starvation in those countries aside from physical blockades and wars like in Palestine if not usually due to lack of tech or agriculture. In any case, even if the land is bad, Israel itself is another example of crap land turned fertile by new technologies they were forced to invent during the course of the 40s and ahead by scientists like Bass. Here you want to block the biggest engine of technological and science development that has ever been invented.
The AI companies do what they must to market themselves, there is no reason to think it should be much different from other past mass disruptive technologies (today agriculture is down to just 2% of the population from 60-80% earlier for instance).
And if it solved most labor and jobs, then what? Would you rather block it than try to see how we can transition to a economic and government system that will actually let us enjoy it.
And I doubt we will ever run out of problems, there is always outer space as an endless source of new problems.
Agriculture as a job went from 70% of the population to under 2% in 200 years. Why are you not complaining about agriculture tech causing mass job killings?
Literally every technological advance till now has led to massive abundance and increase of food, and of the carrying capacity of agriculture itself till now. You have to explain why you think now technology will do the opposite of what it has done for millenia continually increasing the amount of and variety of food available worldwide. You have to show how this engine of science and tech research will do the literal opposite of what science has always done to food availability.
Well agriculture was not selling itself with "we will nake humans obsolete, replace all humans and make all people except few richest poor". Agriculture improvements did not came with "hahaha you looser artists you are not needed anymore, all art will be done with AI you loosers".
Agriculture selling point was and is "we will feed you"
I am also really not interested in alternative history. Nor in debate where people who know literally nothing about actual historical events make up fictional past out of imagination and movies and use that as argument.
> You have to explain why you think now technology will do the opposite of what it has done for millenia continually increasing the amount of and variety of food available worldwide
The destruction and desperation for average person is what AI companies sell. It is what THEY claimed will happen.
What is there alternative abour agriculture going from 70 percent to 2 percent of the population? Why do you think 8t had to be spelled out to the jobs that were killed that we are replacing you. The inventor of the tractor, thresher, etc didn't have to see what the point of these techs were. And it already made megafarms more profitable than small plots. Again, you failed to prove why technology wouls suddenly do the opposite of what it has done for centuries.
You still failed to prove how technology is to blame for corript countries or countries being bombarded wnd blockaded. Instead you lie and imply technology causes starvation.
Starvation is a tech problem too, without haber bosch we would probably had mass starvations in history. Without Israel inventing new forms of soil treatment and irrigation, the country wouldn't support agriculture at any reasonable rate. Why would you want to block the biggest killer of starvation as if doing that would solve the problem of corrupt governments?
Yes so why do you think if a job going from 70 to less than 3 percent hasn't caused mass unemployment worldwide, thr current newest tech should be any different? All new revolutionary techs feel devastating the first time they are introduced.
Luddism in my view is a civilization ending disease. These same types of thinking will ban advances in medicine because its "unnatural" and prevent the steps needed to become an interplantetary and further civilization eg because autonomous and intelligent nav is "evil" and steals jobs.
Silicon valley wants me to be completely 100% dependent on Silicon Valley to do anything. That's their goal, it's what they've been working toward this whole time.
"Trust me bro", they say. They have new and dangerously powerful tools to get me to trust them harder. Me, one of the dumb fucks.
Anyone who believes in infinite imaginary beings and imaginary things that supposed being wants you to do has no right to call anyone else religious. If you are not one of those, then a meaningful discussion can begin.
So glad the public hates this stuff in journalism. I hope all the news agencies that use it are left with the same kind of remnant audience that found Q-Anon so inspiring.
This is an hallucination. We all know humans hallucinate just like LLMs and this is another form of it.
It’s like if I asked you if you enjoy talking shit about people or saying things and gossiping without people knowing about it.
Most people would say no they don’t enjoy it. But most people would be lying. Not lying to you but lying to themselves. It’s one of the most obvious lies because everyone can definitely think back and recall themselves talking shit.
People say they don’t want to use LLMs and they say they hate ai and they say they appreciate human art and effort and human endeavor and all of this is true and at the same time not true as the same people who say they don’t like it use it all the time. It’s both true and not true. Human brains like LLMs did not evolve to enforce strict logical conclusions because such a thing is not absolutely necessary for survival. You can hold contradictory opinions and beliefs in your mind.
Did they type "Write a news article make no mistakes?" and hit Publish
or
Did they use it to find secondary sources for a set of details to then manually go check them? Or use it for copy-editing or have a discussion with a frontier model about the best term to describe a concept (something I find them very good at!)? Or a myriad of such interventional uses.
Are those considered the same by the audience? Was the difference explained in this survey? I'm betting the audience is a lot more accepting of the latter and the former is what everyone imagines "Use Gen-AI" means.
I hate to be the "there is nuance" guy, but...there is significant nuance here.
It sounds like this is the exact discussion happening within software world: Vibe code one shot app make no mistake push to prod, or write boilerplate, discuss architecture, assist migrations and vulnerability research?
I think we lost all nuance in the world, though. Everything has to be black or white, otherwise nothing sells anymore.
There absolutely is nuance here, but you have to consider the pressures operating on newsrooms, which are already a shadow of their former selves after the internet hit.
The pressure is intense to save money, there have been decades of cuts, and they’re now operating on trimmed budgets and rarely do real journalism any more.
So for most newspapers and online news sources generative ai will be used to the hilt, to simply replace employees, or by freelancers on a deadline. The pressure will be for ever faster news. It will be used for writing not research because of these pressures, and already is in many places.
It’s already flooding some online spaces like Apple News on the stocks app with dross from simply wall st or generated bitcoin price articles. In the case of financial news it was always full of nonsense of the form ‘stocks rise today because of factor X’.
If I ask an AI for help to download some public data to make a graph, and then I publish the graph on my website, is that consuming or producing? Seems like both?
> If I ask an AI for help to download some public data
They only describe the LLM as helping withdownloading data, this means the creation of the plot could be done by hand.
I agree that the rest of the post then proceeds to ask a question in a way implying the machine also created the plot, but that's not actually in the stated premise.
You have a deterministic path from published data to graph output which you signed off on, and the AI wrote the code. In my view the AI did not produce the news any more than the script did.
For me at least, an AI "produces" when it makes meaningful decisions. Do if you found the data, understood it, chose how you wanted it presented, but got the AI to write the code that generated the actual graph, then the scope of AI decision making is relatively small - it's reasonable to say that you produced that graph (with AI assistance). But if you got the AI to find some data that supported your article and present it as a graph, then it's making pretty much all the decisions there - which data set to use, how to graph it, even which parts of the article to support with that data. That's an AI-produced graph, for me at least.
Not a very well accepted or reasoned Philosphic counter answer, but to keep it simple, current LLMs consume information and regurgitate it without understanding.
So they currently sit somewhere in the neighborhood of the infinite monkey theorem. Toward the better side of it than pure Random. But you need to take that with a grain of salt with things leaking out about human intervention, and the Hallucinations we still get.
That is true, in the send that it is bad at producing useful quality information. But the sat truth is that AI is great to produce large volumes of text. It's its main thing.
To stop using AI to generate professional sounding but empty of meaning text requires disciple or regulations. In the current state of things corporations go for more is better and governments are slow to act. So, neither seem to be an option.
> AI is good for consuming public information
As far as it lasts. Public information is already been poisoned by bad actors. That was harder to do when it was more costly to generate text. But AI allows to create large quantities of misinformation at a cheap price tag.
Reliable sources will be as important as ever if not more. Your AI should be connected to your subscriptions to independent newspapers, to official government sources, etc. Quality output requires quality input.
AI is worthless if it just reads text generated by another AI.
What does AI for news even mean? In what world are people using it for search, but not for news? Search looks at and summarizes the news! If I ask why Nvidia dropped today, is that the news?
The comments here are enlightening. All the anti-ai hype posts are downvoted. I think justifiably, this is a transformational moment. But what we can surely agree on is two fold, it is built on theft, and the regular non-hn people are increasingly likely to demand a reckoning for that theft.
It’s interesting to see the general public is trying to bestow a secular “original sin” onto AI. It could’ve been climate change. It could’ve been job loss. But I think we’ve converged on copyright and theft - ironically from people who usually don’t think highly of copyright.
For some definitions of theft I guess. Humans educate themselves by reading stuff and answer questions - OK, AIs educate themselves by reading stuff and answer questions - theft. But you are going to have a job enforcing that.
The reckoning may be along the lines of taxing them for UBI or similar.
A certain pattern I’ve noticed: people are vary of and condemn AI use in many domains; complain about hallucination and inaccuracies. In just a few years, the use of AI in these domains will become mandatory and not using AI will be almost seen as risky.
Example: if you don’t use AI as a reviewer for your code to check for vulnerabilities, it will be seen as risky - as compared to a year ago when people were complaining about hallucination.
Expect the same pattern for healthcare as well. Also journalism
I'd say the same thing - it is careless to not have an LLM review your news article or opinion piece but its also probably not good for LLM to write it completely.
I've been thinking about the sheer volume of information I am interested in being produced every day. At current rates, I may need a few hours to thoroughly go through the entire stream in the morning.
As this rate of information production increases, this will become a full time job.
Obviously, this is not a full time job, and I think agents will fill in the "menial" work-load.
Personally I have resorted to batching, narrowing my scope, raising my quality threshold and making peace with missing out. Summarizing tools don’t interest me in the least, I read to think. News are inessential, opinions are good brain food.
Right. But my point was that newer and newer sources will start popping. "Missing out" will become the dominant mode. But maybe this is just a misguided interpolation on my behalf.
I don't have a good concept of how this can be solved at the moment.
Missing out has been the dominant mode since language was invented, we've just never had as much access or been as aware of what we were missing out on. But you could have read Newton's thoughts instead of the news today or any yesterday in your life. Which is more valuable? Given a limited capacity for information processing I find it's best to spend the least amount I can on worry and the most on the stuff that I will actually enjoy wrestling with.
> At current rates, I may need a few hours to thoroughly go through the entire stream in the morning.
When was that not true? There are more books in the world that I want to read that the ones I can realistically (or even in the ideal case) be able to read. Magazines, newspapers, Youtube videos, ... AI has not changed anything.
Summarizing removes information. It is like just reading the titles instead of commenting on the content. Saves you time, but it is not the same.
80 comments
[ 0.35 ms ] story [ 28.7 ms ] threadPeople is the gateway, their effort, their experience, to learn from.
It’s just the hype train is excessive and in everyone’s faces and anything that’s like that genuinely becomes hated.
Imagine if I saved the lives of hundreds of people everyday. And I would throw this fact in your face everyday via TikTok, email spam, YouTube, social media.
Pretty soon you’ll become sick of it. You’ll not care for anyones life. Thats what is happening with ai. Ai is genuinely from a logical standpoint, incredible. But all of that is diluted by overhype.
It is literally incredible, that is, the claims people make about it are not believable. It simply does not do the magical stuff people claim it does.
What are you even talking about? You can see it do the magic yourself for like $20. The lean proof of the exponential time hypotheses disproof for exampe is straight up on github right now for you to look at.
What magical thing are you waiting for? It is literally currently revolutionaizing all engineering work.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stasi
For clarity, I'm more or less indifferent to AI, I do understand how it all works - it's humans with AI I don't trust and that I don't see being adequately reigned in.
The what now? I don't know what that is. Can AI help me put food on the table and pay my bills? That thing I can understand.
If you don't know how and what kinds of math is needed in every tech and science we use, then I have nothing to say. I should have recognized when you said this and stopped interacting further.
My entire company now uses AI to code. Nobody writes code by hand at my company anymore. At this point if you can’t see how incredible and horrifying it is then you’re delusional.
I get it though. One year ago you’d be right. The paradigm shift is happening so fast people haven’t updated their priors. What you believed to be true just changed. It flipped several times this year and people who keep up to date had to completely flip their understanding of the world and the nature of AI several times. This is not an easy thing to do and thus many people like you just missed the boat.
There’s no doubt that there is a financial ai bubble. But that bubble is completely orthogonal to the complete paradigm shift of the actual capabilities of AI.
Very good analogy with Tesla FSD. Is it great tech- yes, of course. Is is the thing that was promised to come out 10 years ago? Far from it.
If you expect AI to do everything for you, it's still not there. And if you're sceptic or even neutral to this topic- AI is just causing more problems (especially in security) by the day.
Not of course. I'll call it good to great the day it gets beyond level 2, and no sooner.
And LLMs are similar in a lot of use cases.
Does that put food on the table? It does not, to the contrary, this AI thing is taking food off the table for many, many people.
But, yeah, you AI zealots on forums like this one can keep thinking that we, those millions, will just remain like sheep taken to the slaughterhouse while you enjoy your higher comps while in the service of today's AI masters.
And changes were in fact drastic, thr fact that countries like UK and Germany for several years became the most powerful countries in the europe due to the industrial revolution.
Solving abstract mathematical puzzles and enganhing in pointless research into substances for crnturies gave us ultimately the Haber-Bosch process, which literally keeps the human race from starving. You would prefer humans starve just to protect som jobs.
On the topic of farming, that used to be the occupation of most of thr population in olden times, today its barely 2 percent. Agriculture tech has already killed millions of jobs.
>You would prefer humans starve just to protect some jobs.
a.) What are you talking about here. b.) the stated goal of AI companies is to make majority of people obsolete, dependent and ... well starving.
The AI companies do what they must to market themselves, there is no reason to think it should be much different from other past mass disruptive technologies (today agriculture is down to just 2% of the population from 60-80% earlier for instance).
And if it solved most labor and jobs, then what? Would you rather block it than try to see how we can transition to a economic and government system that will actually let us enjoy it.
And I doubt we will ever run out of problems, there is always outer space as an endless source of new problems.
Literally every technological advance till now has led to massive abundance and increase of food, and of the carrying capacity of agriculture itself till now. You have to explain why you think now technology will do the opposite of what it has done for millenia continually increasing the amount of and variety of food available worldwide. You have to show how this engine of science and tech research will do the literal opposite of what science has always done to food availability.
Agriculture selling point was and is "we will feed you"
I am also really not interested in alternative history. Nor in debate where people who know literally nothing about actual historical events make up fictional past out of imagination and movies and use that as argument.
> You have to explain why you think now technology will do the opposite of what it has done for millenia continually increasing the amount of and variety of food available worldwide
The destruction and desperation for average person is what AI companies sell. It is what THEY claimed will happen.
The selection of agriculture specifically is completely odd here.
Why don't you deranged organic code cultist switch to TempleOS?
"Trust me bro", they say. They have new and dangerously powerful tools to get me to trust them harder. Me, one of the dumb fucks.
It’s like if I asked you if you enjoy talking shit about people or saying things and gossiping without people knowing about it.
Most people would say no they don’t enjoy it. But most people would be lying. Not lying to you but lying to themselves. It’s one of the most obvious lies because everyone can definitely think back and recall themselves talking shit.
People say they don’t want to use LLMs and they say they hate ai and they say they appreciate human art and effort and human endeavor and all of this is true and at the same time not true as the same people who say they don’t like it use it all the time. It’s both true and not true. Human brains like LLMs did not evolve to enforce strict logical conclusions because such a thing is not absolutely necessary for survival. You can hold contradictory opinions and beliefs in your mind.
Did they type "Write a news article make no mistakes?" and hit Publish
or
Did they use it to find secondary sources for a set of details to then manually go check them? Or use it for copy-editing or have a discussion with a frontier model about the best term to describe a concept (something I find them very good at!)? Or a myriad of such interventional uses.
Are those considered the same by the audience? Was the difference explained in this survey? I'm betting the audience is a lot more accepting of the latter and the former is what everyone imagines "Use Gen-AI" means.
I hate to be the "there is nuance" guy, but...there is significant nuance here.
I think we lost all nuance in the world, though. Everything has to be black or white, otherwise nothing sells anymore.
The pressure is intense to save money, there have been decades of cuts, and they’re now operating on trimmed budgets and rarely do real journalism any more.
So for most newspapers and online news sources generative ai will be used to the hilt, to simply replace employees, or by freelancers on a deadline. The pressure will be for ever faster news. It will be used for writing not research because of these pressures, and already is in many places.
It’s already flooding some online spaces like Apple News on the stocks app with dross from simply wall st or generated bitcoin price articles. In the case of financial news it was always full of nonsense of the form ‘stocks rise today because of factor X’.
They only describe the LLM as helping withdownloading data, this means the creation of the plot could be done by hand.
I agree that the rest of the post then proceeds to ask a question in a way implying the machine also created the plot, but that's not actually in the stated premise.
So they currently sit somewhere in the neighborhood of the infinite monkey theorem. Toward the better side of it than pure Random. But you need to take that with a grain of salt with things leaking out about human intervention, and the Hallucinations we still get.
We all know the specific situation matters, we already know, we also know thats not what we are talking about.
That is true, in the send that it is bad at producing useful quality information. But the sat truth is that AI is great to produce large volumes of text. It's its main thing.
To stop using AI to generate professional sounding but empty of meaning text requires disciple or regulations. In the current state of things corporations go for more is better and governments are slow to act. So, neither seem to be an option.
> AI is good for consuming public information
As far as it lasts. Public information is already been poisoned by bad actors. That was harder to do when it was more costly to generate text. But AI allows to create large quantities of misinformation at a cheap price tag.
Reliable sources will be as important as ever if not more. Your AI should be connected to your subscriptions to independent newspapers, to official government sources, etc. Quality output requires quality input.
AI is worthless if it just reads text generated by another AI.
It's also the destructive nature of data centers both ecologically and to people's neighborhoods and other ways.
Honestly, I think that's a more serious side than the IP side.
AI is a public good created from personal information. Its output cannot be copyrighted, the models themselves should be opened for everyone by law.
That is the reckoning. Give back the information to the people that created it.
The reckoning may be along the lines of taxing them for UBI or similar.
Funny how they call mass surveillance these days. /s
Example: if you don’t use AI as a reviewer for your code to check for vulnerabilities, it will be seen as risky - as compared to a year ago when people were complaining about hallucination.
Expect the same pattern for healthcare as well. Also journalism
As this rate of information production increases, this will become a full time job.
Obviously, this is not a full time job, and I think agents will fill in the "menial" work-load.
So interesting times ahead.
I don't have a good concept of how this can be solved at the moment.
Quite the opposite, IMHO. Opinions are cheap filler. They're like revision notes for Shakespeare's plays before an exam.
News, actual news, is important but expensive to gather and produce. Only a few agencies such as Reuters and AP actually work at that level.
When was that not true? There are more books in the world that I want to read that the ones I can realistically (or even in the ideal case) be able to read. Magazines, newspapers, Youtube videos, ... AI has not changed anything.
Summarizing removes information. It is like just reading the titles instead of commenting on the content. Saves you time, but it is not the same.