The problem is the regulators in the US are in bed with the companies so they can say whatever and do the complete opposite and then get fined a trivial amount of money and just keep doing it
I was disappointed that the article described Apple's answers to some questions as not direct. They should have published the indirect answer. Let the reader judge the answers.
Interesting that in the beginning it says 'We know that many TVs use automatic content recognition (ACR)' but according to answers none of those manufacturers do.
So which TVs do the ACRs, and why Verge did not send those questions to them? Hisense?
None of the manufacturers who answered that question admitted to using ACR via screenshot. LG uses audio samples, which is basically the same. Google admitted that some of their hardware OEMs may install ACR. Sony and Hisense didn't answer, but have both been reported to use ACR. The TCL TVs that come with Roku I assume do it as well.
Wait did they claim to not use screenshots during ACR generation? Or did they claim they don't _store_ screenshots.
I think they're using "collect" to mean something specific and "store" to mean something specific, neither of which fit our definition of collect and store.
Have to make it regulation and law, with penalties for lying. Regime change has made this more likely, call your Congressional representative. Loop in Louis Rossmann and fulu.org if necessary.
It is fundamentally a citizen data security and data privacy issue, which only regulation and the law can solve for (i argue, based on all available evidence and information). But asking nicely or trusting corporations and management? lol, rofl even.
At least we know what their (most anyway) answers are and security researcher can start verifying where they are lying. You also have to look very hard at the language used to answer many of these questions as words can often be misleading...
That the Television Business transformed from a) an advertising conduit to b) a propaganda conduit to c) a live-surveillance technology tells you all you need to know.
Whether the Corporations answer your questions or not, their claims of doing The Right Thing are untrustworthy.
Sony Bravia TVs, at least the 2015 model, bundle the tv.samba.ssm package, and the TV made periodic requests to the samba.tv domain without opting into anything. Samba TV is a spyware company in the ACR business.
FYI I disabled the app (alongside many other undesirable apps) on my Sony TV via adb and there's no longer network requests to samba.tv, and everything I care about is still working fine.
watch videos on TikTok, YouTube, Instagram, Netflix, Apple TV, etc. so that the telemetry at least goes directly to the vendors and their partners in an accurate, compressed channel directly associated with your subscription account
(i am joking but the cognitive dissonance about telemetry is so stupid. you are watching TV on a subscription service, someone already knows who is watching what.)
That's a fine argument if you're watching videos on those platforms, but ACR also phones home when you're watching local content, too. Your Jellyfin server, Blurays, video games, content from your computer, it all goes back to the mothership.
your internet connected videogames on consoles report telemetry
you are running jellyfin on a device, like a NAS. it reports telemetry. docker reports telemetry. you download jellyfin, microsoft gets the telemetry. you update jellyfin, it gets the telemetry. you download radarr, docker and microsoft get the telemetry... all of this stuff reports telemetry. github, you can see your own repositories' usage and telemetry! graphs/traffic. it's all there...
I play games, I know Sony knows about what I play.
I watch netflix, I know Netflix knows what I watch.
Etc...
But there is a difference between the company whose services I use knowing about the service use, and the television mfg knowing about all of my activity.
As others have pointed out, Microsoft does not get to know what I'm watching, when I'm watching it, or that watching it ever occurred. They may know that an IP which is occasionally associated with other things I do pulls a number of container images from GitHub every so often, and that a small minority of those container images are for applications that can host local media content.
Conflating that with actively spying on the content of my television programming is wrong.
you pay for a subscription, the subscription service knows what you are watching. 90% or so of people.
you download a torrent, bro, your IP address is shared in the swarm that anyone, without authorization, can see.
you are in a private tracker, every profile is open!
you visit some website for a stream. the website has tracking.
somebody, somewhere, somebody big and knowledgable and sophisticated in all the scenarios, not some little adversary but all these 1,000 or so ad-tech and analytics companies, knows what the content of you, you specifically, you are watching.
That's not the point. They're all terrible stewards. It's a trade off, as they each provide me services that suit me. It's also why each one only gets a limited slice of my data.
But my television - bought and paid for - doesn't provide me any service beyond displaying images. It is a commodity, and TV manufacturers are trying to get not just a slice (which would also be too much), but their own copy of the whole pie.
> you are running jellyfin on a device, like a NAS. it reports telemetry
Jellyfin Server is hosted on repo.jellyfin.org, so the Jellyfin organisation gets the data that you're probably still running Jellyfin and want updates, not Microsoft. I will accept that if you use the Dockerised version, Docker or GitHub will get that data instead. None of this is "telemetry", e.g. detailed usage information. It's quid-pro-quo; you want to know if there are updates, you ask the update server, it records that your IP looked for updates.
Jellyfin Server collects data and stores it locally on your device in logs and its database (e.g. viewing data, login sessions). This data doesn't leave your device.
What Jellyfin Server _will_ share a lot of, is data about your collection, to its metadata providers. You chose those when setting up your libraries. In return, they hand back nice metadata and pictures. So TheTVDB.com, OMDB, MusicBrainz and others you've configured, get queried about "Film name (year)" or "TV series S01E01" or "Band name Album name" and thus learn everything that's in your collection... but not whether you've watched it.
> you are running jellyfin on a device, like a NAS. it reports telemetry. docker reports telemetry. you download jellyfin, microsoft gets the telemetry. you update jellyfin, it gets the telemetry. you download radarr, docker and microsoft get the telemetry...
Not if you run one of the "good" Linux distros and FOSS tools like Podman. Then there is no telemetry at all.
The AOSP (Android core) does hardcode some Google services like a fallback DNS. I patched that out of the source for an x86 Android build that runs on my TV box. So there can be zero or very little telemetry if you actively avoid it. You mostly need to avoid Big Tech stuff.
My Jellyfin server is not allowed to contact the internet. Videos are downloaded from Usenet then rsync'd over to the Jellyfin server for viewing. I don't use Docker because it's a black box I don't understand. I don't use Microsoft. The Jellyfin server is updated from my local deb repo. I don't use Github because it's microsoft trash. I don't play games on modern consoles.
Just because you took the easy way out doesn't mean it's hopeless.
Did I consent someplace to having my TV tell its manufacturer that I am using an Amazon fire stick? No? Then it's wrong for my TV to send that info out.
We need to differentiate "actually consented" versus "clicked accept on an intentionally misleading, long EULA that popped up on the screen once".
These companies get away with these things in part because they can point to users accepting some agreement by using the service where clause 12 subsection 4 addendum C says they can do it, using some terminology nobody reads or understands.
Also, how accessible is the EULA before your purchase of a large hardware object which you are not designed to use to read an EULA? Where's my TV EULA?
My LG TV did pop up asking for EULA consent before being able to use WebOS. I did not consent to microphone terms (which has the infamous terms saying it’s your responsibility not to break eavesdropping laws). So the microphone function doesn’t work, which is fine.
The EULA terms I did agree to likely had a clause allowing for returning the TV to not be a contract of cohesion. As for why I consented to ACR, I guess I have a lot going on and privacy (for, say, location data) in a contractual way is difficult.
Supposedly the LG TV does not send ACR data out without agreeing to the EULA. It gets into non-falsifiablity to just say “duh, of course they do.” Well, it’s what they say and there’s no evidence they do if the EULA isn’t agreed.
Now the fire stick and its services have their own EULAs.
The libertarian contractual ideology obviously falls apart in real-world conditions. I had to agree to a lengthy contract to pay for parking after I had already parked. I had to rely on unconscionablity or some practicality (I.e. assuming I didn’t sign over one million dollars in the parking EULA) to get through my day.
I was impressed LG answered every question and quite directly, assuming they’re telling the truth.
I was quite disappointed in Apple for dodging so many of them and giving non-answers. They need to tone down the corporate speak and take a lesson from LG.
When asked if a user can erase everything the correct answer is not a thesis on privacy, it’s saying “Choosing Erase all settings and data will remove everything on the device back to factory fresh state”. They already have the perfect answer.
Apple has good answers for many of the questions they skipped too. But they look bad by not even trying to answer.
What makes you defend Apple when they won't defend themselves? If they have good answers why did they evade the question? Is it possible your basis for your belief they have good answers has changed and those answers will no longer be "good"?
I’m not defending them here. I was calling out the contrast between that and how their messaging looks terrible.
I know they do have good answers as I use the Apple TV and know what it does. They may not satisfy super hard-core privacy people, but if you’re willing to opt into the Apple ecosystem then within those constraints I think they’re very good.
But thank you for accusing me of being a fanboy. That was very productive.
My biggest problem with Apple not answering so many of the questions is they heavily market themselves as being privacy first. This seemed like the perfect way to show their advantage in that regard but their choice to skip so many questions I think justifies more skepticism. Additionally basically every response from every company sounded very weaselly.
For instance in the microphone part, Apple says that it only listens to the wake word and you can disable that. But they don’t say that you can disable the far-field microphones entirely. Why not? If it was really good for privacy, couldn’t they have said you can configure it such that the only time any microphone is active is when you’re holding the microphone button? Wouldn’t that be the stronger claim? Why are all these claims so weak?
Disabling using the wake word would disable it entirely. That’s the only time it ever listens. The button thing is because there is a microphone directly on the remote so if you are using the button, there is no point in using the microphones on the Apple TV itself. There’s already one in a better position.
Anyway, I agree with you. If you want to be the “privacy“ company, then choosing not to answer when some of the worst companies in terms of privacy answered lots of stuff is a very bad look. It doesn’t make any sense other than if you’re trying to be ultra careful about not saying the wrong thing, which doesn’t improve my view of you.
When I got to the first question, where Apple didn’t answer, I was like “OK, whatever, you can skip one“. And then they answered like one more in the entire thing and skipped the rest.
Maybe I’m overly skeptical, but my read is that the microphones and a special processor only do one thing and that can be disabled. However they don’t say that the microphones are disabled. They don’t rule out the microphones being used in another way, with a different processor. Or am I wrong? A AND B does this. What about A and C? “No comment”.
I trust it because this is the same thing they’ve been doing on every product since you started being able to say “Hey Siri”.
People have always worried they’re doing more, but Apple has repeatedly put out descriptions of exactly how it works because they don’t want people to think the devices are spying on them. I don’t see why it would change for this one product. They already have to fight that rumor that comes up every couple years that phones are listening to people to show them advertisements.
The answer also seemed exactly the same to me as Google and Samsung’s answers about how they listen for wake words.
Yeah, sure. I'll buy a powerstation while I'm at it. Why not? My TV doesn't even fit in my car, so I guess I'll have to buy a bigger car too. Just so I can figure out if the TV connects to any random open AP.
I don't really many (or any?) people suggesting that they're currently using 5G modems. Just that it is a likely next step assuming hardware costs go down to make it worth the hassle as a secondary channel.
The public wifi one is funny. It seems totally like something they'd do, but totally open wifi doesn't really exist anymore so the window for that scam is likely closed. I doubt they'll bother with it at this point.
More likely would be cutting Comcast in on things in return for using the public wifi channels they have on their customer's routers that they already use for cell service. But it might be easier/cheaper to just make not connecting to wifi more and more painful for customers instead though, you only need to trick/wear down one user of the household to win this battle so if they just slowly turn up the harassment feature they'll get 99% of people in the end.
Many ISP-provided routers also include, by default, a completely separate WiFi network (that, as far as I know, is usually separate from your plan bandwidth) for other customers of the ISP to be able to use while they're out and about. It would be trivial for TV manufacturers to enter into agreements with those ISPs authorizing them to connect to those SSIDs.
Amazon also could try connecting to their sidewalk network that many of their ring/Alexa devices use to connect to a neighbors 'internet' via LORA. so asking specifically about wifi is not broad enough of a question.
LG: No. ACR in LG TVs does not collect or store screenshots, screen images, screen recordings...
Hold on, we already know this is not true. There is even an option in the settings to disable this (which is usually automatically reverted by LG within a week).
I work in marketing. LG literally offers to target people who've recently watched a competitor's ad. When I asked how that's possible the sales guy openly admitted that "they know what's showing on their panels."
Maybe he just said that to make a sale, but yeah the fact they offer that targeting alone is quite telling.
"own the glass" refers to the very last step in the advertising display chain. You might not notice it because it's invisible to the end user, but basically every step in the signal chain from studio to eyeball is trying to rip out the previous step's ads and overwrite them with its own. Glass is the last step before eyeballs, so it gets ultimate authority.
I don't think they're denying anything. I think they're muddying the technologies. They're saying "we don't need the screenshot to know what's displayed on your screen". With ACR, you don't need screenshots because you know what the content is. My understanding is that ACR is basically a fingerprint of the screenshot.
> ACR in LG TVs does not collect or store screenshots, screen images, screen recordings, or video recordings from the TV. Instead, it uses audio fingerprints generated from content audio using the TV’s internal soundboard (not a speaker) to identify the content being viewed.
So based on the fingerprint they know what content is being displayed, but they can say they're not recording your screen.
not sly. it's 2026. my neighbor got into a Bundeskriminalamt active assets list after learning GPT3 for 5 years or so .... even runs workshops for minors who are into editing porn for psyOps purposes. different standards, ma dude. different definitions. your sly falls under today's omniscient, prescient, nescient, conscient, scient ... all encompassing definition of "slop". make sure to keep your subconscious where it belongs. don't be a Jungian/Freud-ish simp. Don't HÆll Berlin. Don't HÆLL Bouji Brass.
not the guy who downvoted you, but you shoehorned in something you wanted to talk about 4 comments deep on a chain as a counter point to a very casual remark that was fully appropriate in its context and didnt call for a hard counter
and the topic you wanted to talk about was so information dense (if steel manning) as to be seen as gibberish
the topic itself or my comment? I'm kidding. It's the same thing.
Because you see, context is king except if you are religious or prescribing to dogmas, which is the same thing. So when you have a TV manufacturer exposing "backdoors", you are exposing teens, minors, parents ... you are ridiculing parents, teens, minors ... YOU ARE EXPOSING AND RIDICULING lawyers, judges, engineers, engineers, engineers, teachers, parents, teens, MINORS ...
even before AI, devices were insecure and tons of people online blogged about it, and some, .... SOME OF "YOU" even sued ...
now, post-AI, those fucking fucks of you who know and have skill .... .... .... ... can get augmented enough to ..... sue
WAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA OFF TO VEGAS BABY, YEEEEEEHAAAA something pop cultural paranoid schizo conspiratorial big dick i know legos that go bzzz
its not that deep, you are using your own short hand language that no one else is familiar with - it is the equivalent of saying a bunch of corporate buzzwords together. thats not to say there is no meaning behind it, just that the information cannot be discerned from the signal.
your message is encrypted, so it looks like gibberish. people will downvote that. i could run this through a hashing function and give you the result and you would downvote it because it would mean nothing to you. it doesnt matter what the truth of the message is if the actual communication does not exist
> it doesnt matter what the truth of the message is if the actual communication does not exist
"I asked every TV manufacturer 17 questions about how they spy on you (theverge.com)"
This was published on 'The Verge' ... and I was going to briefly examine their last few or last years few posts but then I visited the site ... so we are going to skip that ...
I made my points clear. It might require a second of processing but this is HN, even the lurkers are not fucking stupid prime time news aficionados. Half of the centenarians on this forum could wreck havoc in half the fucking world within a few days.
What do you want me to repeat? Why people want dumb phones, dumb TVs? Why some turd nuggets of people are proud their grand daddies prepared audiences for their "sly" ad targeting and retargeting via nothing but satellite and cable TV and some basic psycho-linguistics? Should I explain networking and big telco companies hardware easy support features? Or the social engineering required to make their dicks go brrr and share some civilians' data? Should I tell about the law enforcement employees I studied with that would the same in the blink of an eye? Or that I know what "aging" means and that it has nothing to do with experience, principles, or what enough ancestors did to create a pretty damn safe world? I absolutely can go super fucking basic and watch porn for a year straight while writing 27 books about it all ... if you like I'll do it live ... let's call it falsified history, basic facts and horny mnemonics ...
It seems to be little known to people, but when you go through airport security simply say "I decline to have my photo taken" and they won't ask you to take the stupid photo. They look at you, they still scan your DL, but no photo.
I've never had any pushback and apparently it's a legal right to not have a photo taken.
Correct. You can even go through with an ID. I have.
A couple other notes of interest. There is an active bill[1] that seeks to codify a prohibition of involuntary biometrics for citizen travel. And I suspect that as many conservative Amish, Mennonites, Jews and Muslims have religious objections to having their photo taken, a first amendment protection against facial biometric collection may continue to exist for some time as a bare minimum.
I think this answer might be one of ‘technically the truth’, as in they might not be doing it BUT:
i know my LG TV(made in Q1 2026) has the capability to capture inputs(regardless of the input)….I know because I rooted it and built an out of band vnc server using the image capture binary.
(Its slow and limited resolution.My best guess that the intent was to ACR)
There's a lot of "carefully written" nonsense going on.
For example, I remember when whatsapp was end-to-end encrypted. However the app could analyze the images for specific patterns like CSAM and send notifications-about-the-image-that-are-not-the-image out-of-band.
I would expect this could also coincidentally analyze messages/images for other patterns like other keywords. This way you could have end-to-end encryption that could still build up advertising profiles.
They are lying through their teeth. We know from independent investigations and reverse engineering efforts that the TVs capture audio/video for the mothership. Also, the devices are effectively remotely controlled and can be updated at a moment's notice to suit the current commercial strategy of the true owner of the device (it's not you).
Every word in that statement is key for it to be true.
For example, if they screen-scrape locally and extract/collect metadata, then the statement is true technically true. I'm sure you can think of many other subtle variations of the truth where the statement is not false but still misleading.
Practically speaking I would just buy whatever and then not connect it to the internet. (Theoretically if there's an unsecured wifi network with no login requirement in the vicinity the TV could still connect to it and send your data, but no one has demonstrated any TVs actually doing that.)
Spectre still sells dumb TVs. The panels are fine, though they don't have any OLED options. Sound quality is...Well, most people don't use TV audio anyway.
You can pay a significant premium for a "business" TV but the cost effective option is to get a consumer grade television and never allow it to connect to the internet.
I don't have a TV in the house.
Just a laptop (works for 95%) and a projector (in the 1* per week case we watch a movie)
Really don't see the use of a specific device, especially if it is spying on you.
Well well well, we know now which cat has had their face in the cream (aka who is clearly visible most guilty).. that would be Hisense, who got caught today and had nothing to say.
For all the company’s who had reponses along the lines of “we don’t do thing X that some others are doing”.. full bets it’s Hisense doing each of these things.
I think it is better to use AI to root the devices, get them to run linux and run an open source media app. The TV manufacturer's default OS is low value.
Apple did/does not want to take the Sony/Samsung product diversification path, but it is a shame for them not to branch out more. An actual Apple branded TV under Tim Cook probably would have honestly respected our privacy. I blocked my LG TV's MAC address from accessing our wifi.
> I asked every TV manufacturer 17 questions about how they spy on you
OK, but why? Just so you can write an article? All those answers are useless. Even if they were true, a company's policy can change over night. It even says so in the legalese.
147 comments
[ 0.22 ms ] story [ 87.3 ms ] threadOr is the bigger problem that there is no privacy-friendly consumer grade TV available on the market?
Toshiba.
Hmm. Not in this list.
If you're in the US it was almost certainly made by Hisense. If you're in Europe it'll be Vestel.
There's Samsung, LG, Sony designs TVs but has them made elsewhere, and Vestel. All of the cheaper brands are made by Vestel.
So which TVs do the ACRs, and why Verge did not send those questions to them? Hisense?
They definitely do, I have a little snippet on their image recognition ACR from when I hacked my Roku TV here: https://blog.ammaraskar.com/roku-tv-philips-hues/#reverse-en...
I think they're using "collect" to mean something specific and "store" to mean something specific, neither of which fit our definition of collect and store.
It is fundamentally a citizen data security and data privacy issue, which only regulation and the law can solve for (i argue, based on all available evidence and information). But asking nicely or trusting corporations and management? lol, rofl even.
That the Television Business transformed from a) an advertising conduit to b) a propaganda conduit to c) a live-surveillance technology tells you all you need to know.
Whether the Corporations answer your questions or not, their claims of doing The Right Thing are untrustworthy.
Here's the APK in case you'd like to take a closer look: https://files.zajc.tel/unlist/6361bb6b86f2ed10e2e75a0deb3269...
(i am joking but the cognitive dissonance about telemetry is so stupid. you are watching TV on a subscription service, someone already knows who is watching what.)
you are running jellyfin on a device, like a NAS. it reports telemetry. docker reports telemetry. you download jellyfin, microsoft gets the telemetry. you update jellyfin, it gets the telemetry. you download radarr, docker and microsoft get the telemetry... all of this stuff reports telemetry. github, you can see your own repositories' usage and telemetry! graphs/traffic. it's all there...
Etc...
But there is a difference between the company whose services I use knowing about the service use, and the television mfg knowing about all of my activity.
Conflating that with actively spying on the content of my television programming is wrong.
you pay for a subscription, the subscription service knows what you are watching. 90% or so of people.
you download a torrent, bro, your IP address is shared in the swarm that anyone, without authorization, can see.
you are in a private tracker, every profile is open!
you visit some website for a stream. the website has tracking.
somebody, somewhere, somebody big and knowledgable and sophisticated in all the scenarios, not some little adversary but all these 1,000 or so ad-tech and analytics companies, knows what the content of you, you specifically, you are watching.
No, I don't.
> you download a torrent, bro, your IP address is shared in the swarm that anyone, without authorization, can see.
Who torrents from a residential IP without a VPN in 2026?
> you visit some website for a stream. the website has tracking.
1) No, I don't but 2) even if I did, who browses the web in 2026 without at LEAST client-side tracker blocking, if not DNS-based?
But my television - bought and paid for - doesn't provide me any service beyond displaying images. It is a commodity, and TV manufacturers are trying to get not just a slice (which would also be too much), but their own copy of the whole pie.
Jellyfin Server is hosted on repo.jellyfin.org, so the Jellyfin organisation gets the data that you're probably still running Jellyfin and want updates, not Microsoft. I will accept that if you use the Dockerised version, Docker or GitHub will get that data instead. None of this is "telemetry", e.g. detailed usage information. It's quid-pro-quo; you want to know if there are updates, you ask the update server, it records that your IP looked for updates.
Jellyfin Server collects data and stores it locally on your device in logs and its database (e.g. viewing data, login sessions). This data doesn't leave your device.
What Jellyfin Server _will_ share a lot of, is data about your collection, to its metadata providers. You chose those when setting up your libraries. In return, they hand back nice metadata and pictures. So TheTVDB.com, OMDB, MusicBrainz and others you've configured, get queried about "Film name (year)" or "TV series S01E01" or "Band name Album name" and thus learn everything that's in your collection... but not whether you've watched it.
Not if you run one of the "good" Linux distros and FOSS tools like Podman. Then there is no telemetry at all.
The AOSP (Android core) does hardcode some Google services like a fallback DNS. I patched that out of the source for an x86 Android build that runs on my TV box. So there can be zero or very little telemetry if you actively avoid it. You mostly need to avoid Big Tech stuff.
Just because you took the easy way out doesn't mean it's hopeless.
These companies get away with these things in part because they can point to users accepting some agreement by using the service where clause 12 subsection 4 addendum C says they can do it, using some terminology nobody reads or understands.
The EULA terms I did agree to likely had a clause allowing for returning the TV to not be a contract of cohesion. As for why I consented to ACR, I guess I have a lot going on and privacy (for, say, location data) in a contractual way is difficult.
Supposedly the LG TV does not send ACR data out without agreeing to the EULA. It gets into non-falsifiablity to just say “duh, of course they do.” Well, it’s what they say and there’s no evidence they do if the EULA isn’t agreed.
Now the fire stick and its services have their own EULAs.
The libertarian contractual ideology obviously falls apart in real-world conditions. I had to agree to a lengthy contract to pay for parking after I had already parked. I had to rely on unconscionablity or some practicality (I.e. assuming I didn’t sign over one million dollars in the parking EULA) to get through my day.
Literally, LG's answer in TFA says they do, despite the mealy-mouthed-ness around not capturing screenshots.
I was quite disappointed in Apple for dodging so many of them and giving non-answers. They need to tone down the corporate speak and take a lesson from LG.
When asked if a user can erase everything the correct answer is not a thesis on privacy, it’s saying “Choosing Erase all settings and data will remove everything on the device back to factory fresh state”. They already have the perfect answer.
Apple has good answers for many of the questions they skipped too. But they look bad by not even trying to answer.
I know they do have good answers as I use the Apple TV and know what it does. They may not satisfy super hard-core privacy people, but if you’re willing to opt into the Apple ecosystem then within those constraints I think they’re very good.
But thank you for accusing me of being a fanboy. That was very productive.
For instance in the microphone part, Apple says that it only listens to the wake word and you can disable that. But they don’t say that you can disable the far-field microphones entirely. Why not? If it was really good for privacy, couldn’t they have said you can configure it such that the only time any microphone is active is when you’re holding the microphone button? Wouldn’t that be the stronger claim? Why are all these claims so weak?
Anyway, I agree with you. If you want to be the “privacy“ company, then choosing not to answer when some of the worst companies in terms of privacy answered lots of stuff is a very bad look. It doesn’t make any sense other than if you’re trying to be ultra careful about not saying the wrong thing, which doesn’t improve my view of you.
When I got to the first question, where Apple didn’t answer, I was like “OK, whatever, you can skip one“. And then they answered like one more in the entire thing and skipped the rest.
People have always worried they’re doing more, but Apple has repeatedly put out descriptions of exactly how it works because they don’t want people to think the devices are spying on them. I don’t see why it would change for this one product. They already have to fight that rumor that comes up every couple years that phones are listening to people to show them advertisements.
The answer also seemed exactly the same to me as Google and Samsung’s answers about how they listen for wake words.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_inference
And they still managed to answer them in multiple sentences, and sometimes multiple paragraphs.
Why not run hostapd in open mode with logging on and see if it bites?
The public wifi one is funny. It seems totally like something they'd do, but totally open wifi doesn't really exist anymore so the window for that scam is likely closed. I doubt they'll bother with it at this point.
More likely would be cutting Comcast in on things in return for using the public wifi channels they have on their customer's routers that they already use for cell service. But it might be easier/cheaper to just make not connecting to wifi more and more painful for customers instead though, you only need to trick/wear down one user of the household to win this battle so if they just slowly turn up the harassment feature they'll get 99% of people in the end.
The setting has the obvious name of "Live Plus".
Maybe he just said that to make a sale, but yeah the fact they offer that targeting alone is quite telling.
You may do LG, or maybe you just think you do. Either way, I won't ever buy your TVs
Am I misinterpreting their answer?
> ACR in LG TVs does not collect or store screenshots, screen images, screen recordings, or video recordings from the TV. Instead, it uses audio fingerprints generated from content audio using the TV’s internal soundboard (not a speaker) to identify the content being viewed.
So based on the fingerprint they know what content is being displayed, but they can say they're not recording your screen.
and the topic you wanted to talk about was so information dense (if steel manning) as to be seen as gibberish
the topic itself or my comment? I'm kidding. It's the same thing.
Because you see, context is king except if you are religious or prescribing to dogmas, which is the same thing. So when you have a TV manufacturer exposing "backdoors", you are exposing teens, minors, parents ... you are ridiculing parents, teens, minors ... YOU ARE EXPOSING AND RIDICULING lawyers, judges, engineers, engineers, engineers, teachers, parents, teens, MINORS ...
even before AI, devices were insecure and tons of people online blogged about it, and some, .... SOME OF "YOU" even sued ...
now, post-AI, those fucking fucks of you who know and have skill .... .... .... ... can get augmented enough to ..... sue
.... but you go "gibberish"
#walledGardenDesigner #walledGardener #inclusiveSociety
WAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA OFF TO VEGAS BABY, YEEEEEEHAAAA something pop cultural paranoid schizo conspiratorial big dick i know legos that go bzzz
your message is encrypted, so it looks like gibberish. people will downvote that. i could run this through a hashing function and give you the result and you would downvote it because it would mean nothing to you. it doesnt matter what the truth of the message is if the actual communication does not exist
"I asked every TV manufacturer 17 questions about how they spy on you (theverge.com)"
This was published on 'The Verge' ... and I was going to briefly examine their last few or last years few posts but then I visited the site ... so we are going to skip that ...
I made my points clear. It might require a second of processing but this is HN, even the lurkers are not fucking stupid prime time news aficionados. Half of the centenarians on this forum could wreck havoc in half the fucking world within a few days.
What do you want me to repeat? Why people want dumb phones, dumb TVs? Why some turd nuggets of people are proud their grand daddies prepared audiences for their "sly" ad targeting and retargeting via nothing but satellite and cable TV and some basic psycho-linguistics? Should I explain networking and big telco companies hardware easy support features? Or the social engineering required to make their dicks go brrr and share some civilians' data? Should I tell about the law enforcement employees I studied with that would the same in the blink of an eye? Or that I know what "aging" means and that it has nothing to do with experience, principles, or what enough ancestors did to create a pretty damn safe world? I absolutely can go super fucking basic and watch porn for a year straight while writing 27 books about it all ... if you like I'll do it live ... let's call it falsified history, basic facts and horny mnemonics ...
I've never had any pushback and apparently it's a legal right to not have a photo taken.
A couple other notes of interest. There is an active bill[1] that seeks to codify a prohibition of involuntary biometrics for citizen travel. And I suspect that as many conservative Amish, Mennonites, Jews and Muslims have religious objections to having their photo taken, a first amendment protection against facial biometric collection may continue to exist for some time as a bare minimum.
[1]https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/169...
i know my LG TV(made in Q1 2026) has the capability to capture inputs(regardless of the input)….I know because I rooted it and built an out of band vnc server using the image capture binary.
(Its slow and limited resolution.My best guess that the intent was to ACR)
For example, I remember when whatsapp was end-to-end encrypted. However the app could analyze the images for specific patterns like CSAM and send notifications-about-the-image-that-are-not-the-image out-of-band.
I would expect this could also coincidentally analyze messages/images for other patterns like other keywords. This way you could have end-to-end encryption that could still build up advertising profiles.
Technically not sending audio or video.
For example, if they screen-scrape locally and extract/collect metadata, then the statement is true technically true. I'm sure you can think of many other subtle variations of the truth where the statement is not false but still misleading.
65" VA (not edge-lit, DLED) without any OS (doubt), $1000
Or go a step further and build your own Linux HTPC.
Of course if you are already sharing everything about yourself with Google/Amazon/OpenAI/Anthropic then who cares?
No screen doesn't imply no surveillance -- https://www.engadget.com/2227777/roku-how-to-stop-tracking-e...
I've heard other people do this sometimes, too.
For all the company’s who had reponses along the lines of “we don’t do thing X that some others are doing”.. full bets it’s Hisense doing each of these things.
That won't alter behavior positively.
OK, but why? Just so you can write an article? All those answers are useless. Even if they were true, a company's policy can change over night. It even says so in the legalese.