199 comments

[ 3.1 ms ] story [ 107 ms ] thread
"We cannot force hard forks or protocol changes. We are opinionated only so as to advocate and propose what’s best for the mission."

Lol, did the perpetrators commit seppuku after the illegitimate DAO fork?

"What's best for the mission" means making sure they don't lose money, obviously.
It also links to this pdf version, which has the pictures https://ethereum.foundation/ef-mandate.pdf
Wow, this is actually amazing. A lot of art in here.
It looks like a pretty decent layout for an RPG manual, but not for a serious document I'd expect to see at work.
Yeah, they missed their calling. Should have gone into ttrpg design instead.
IMO, this means we should change what we should expect to see in work environments. I'd love to see bold vision and art become the norm.
I guess art is subjective and people are into different styles, but to me, this just looks juvenile.
Man's maturity: to have regained the seriousness that he had as a child at play.
I think it would be much less of a problem if there was an explicit, clear delineation between the legal text and the art. The HTML version is much worse in this regard as well: the license in question reads like part of the text of the document (though any meaning it has is quite ambiguous).
I'd love to see more work documents like this, or that at least aren't boring.

That said, a lawyer really should've reviewed it and told them a contract isn't the place for jokes.

I kind of want my work documents to have a single shared style, so that it's easy to parse when I'm looking for something specific.

Maybe it's just because I'm in my 40s, but I want my job to be boring.

It definitely gives 'cult manifesto' vibes
Is this document sincere or just AI generated and dressed up in something that people are meant to relate to...?
wtf is that, cant be real
This reminds me of anyone who went from normal life with normal funds to extreme wealth at a young age, not surprising, this is just the nerd version of rappers / ball players / young actors etc going through their own rendition of this.
It’s a cult, or at least, the leadership is trying to turn it into one. Cults have done weirder stuff, up to and including actual suicide.

39 members of Heaven’s Gate drank phenobarbital and died, believing this would allow them to escape Earth on the Hale-Bopp comet.

900 members of the People’s Temple (Jim Jones) drank cyanide-laced koolaid (actually FlavorAid) and died. That’s where the phrase “drink the koolaid” came from.

OK, but there's a lot of artwork in here: the opening-page image has lines like WE ARE ALL ONE IN LOVE -- is anyone taking this text too for a legal commitment?

Added: oh, the seppuku is in the HTML version without art, though you have to click to make it visible. Retracted.

(comment deleted)
Interesting, it's still there (end of Section III), though sadly without the winking anime girl and yellow cats.
I wish I had been surprised by what I read in this article.
"a 38-page document outlining leadership’s vision for the foundation for the next 1,000 years."

This would by itself be enough to start packing all your office things into a cardboard box.

A thousand years. I wonder how they settled on that number. Let me guess, it was a joke that shouldn't be taken too seriously.
> "Authors, maintainers, editors and distributors of “this software” would pledge to ensure the software remained free and publicly accessible, and would also vow to “take his or her own life with a sword upon failure to uphold any of the pledges in this license,” the illustration read. It was labeled “Source Seppuku License,” an apparent reference to a traditional Japanese ritual suicide.

When the document went out on that Friday in March, employees were told to commit to the principles in the mandate by Monday or quit their jobs, according to the lawsuit brought by Kayleen Fulton, a Boulder woman who was fired from the Ethereum Foundation after she led employee resistance to the suicide pledge."

.. wow. When your employer starts posting like Yukio Mishima of course you sue them. I have a new entry in "most unprofessional thing I've ever seen". And no, using the "should not be taken seriously" defense is also hugely unprofessional.

It's got to be figurative speech, right? Added for dramatic effect knowing that upholding the license may not always be verifiable or enforceable.
Seppuku is a two person job. Does accepting the contract mean you volunteer to be the second (the person finishing the job by decapitation) for someone else’s ritual suicide?
That sounds like a thankless task, little gain in getting it right but a lot of embarrassment in screwing it up.

I would at least want hazard pay added to my contract if my job description was to include such a role.

Tbh the seppuku thing is the one thing I wouldn't pay attention to among all the other red flags, because of how obviously impractical it is.
I don't care about "being professional" all the time. The most skilled people I know were also the most weird, eccentric and quirky. I've only skimmed the document, but it looks exactly the kind of organization I'd like to work with.

...well, except the fact that they fire people over it, and don't listen to concerns where people don't feel comfortable with some of the clauses. Yeah at this point this crossed into a cult behavior and is unacceptable. But the problem here is not memes, at least for me.

> “If you reward making a stink with outcomes, then everyone will know that essentially making that kind of show both internally and externally is the way to cause outcomes inside of the EF,” he said, according to the lawsuit, which cited a recorded conversation between the pair.

Well she was too effective at organizing a resistance. Can't have that.

Weirdness used to be a charming aspect of the tech industry. Now it's death cults, fascism, accelerationism, "monarchists," "effective altruism" and whatever other brand of curdled dark perversion haunts Silicon Valley.
All a flavor of lust for power and influence from very bitter, angry, and jealous people.
I don't think that's a very good description of the ethereum foundation document that we are discussing.
A great deal of the problems in the industry are systemic, not personal. If you rely on personalization to understand the problems of the world, you will always be frustrated, because there will always be people ready to step into the role of “evil” thanks to perverse incentives. You can only eliminate the evil by eliminating the incentives.
I have no power to do any such thing. I acknowledge that the system rewards sociopathy and seems to inspire it as well. These types seem to be the shepards of our industry and the world changing technologies its laborers develop, do you disagree?
I agree, but focusing on the personalities involved causes people to misdirect their efforts as a group, and they just end up with a different group of “bad guys” after getting rid of (or disempowering) the current batch.

The pattern that’s currently in tech already existed (and continues to exist) in the world of finance. Tech is just its latest expression.

Sure, for myself, the best I can do is make sure my day to day work does not involve these people, so I do focus on personalities regarding what companies/teams to work for.
To be fair, I find this weirdness much more interesting than the traditional "rapture will occur on X" or "I am Gods chosen fornicator". How cool would it be if there was still some fjord somewhere where they still sacrificed goats to Odin? Christianity really wiped out many the interesting cult themes, and new ones like Scientology have so far just been shameless cash grabs from the gullible and lost.

At least the AI death cults are offering a doomsday scenario which is somewhat plausible. A little more iffy on the details then straightforwards nuclear Armageddon perhaps, but not dismissable out of hand. And compared to traditional human perversions, afaik they haven't gotten much further than summer of love type stuff, just with a bit more of a pessimistic twist. They have nothing on an average crackhouse.

Overall, I think it all qualifies as a pretty fun and interesting weirdness on the scale of human experience, which regularly goes much...much darker than a bunch of kids living in sharehouses and worrying about the future.

If we could relegate effective altruism to the graveyard of terrible but well intentioned ideas to never rear its head ever again to haunt humanity that would be a small win.

  haunts Silicon Valley.
Silicon Valley can be weird sometimes but this isn't Silicon Valley. Vitalik is based in Singapore but travels to Toronto, and European tech hubs like Berlin, Zug, and Prague.

I believe that a good reason why crypto got started was precisely because most people around the world got locked out of Silicon Valley. IE. they couldn't work or invest in high flying SV startups so they gamble their money in crypto rug pulls and shill for crypto shitcoins.

this is cringe, but less cringe than having to wear the nooglers hat
I can't express something better than this observation I read the other day:

>again, something of a banal observation, but i think contributing to the general feeling of powerlessness and rage in america today is the extent to which our elites engage in such flagrant, grotesque, even performative contempt for the rest of america

>i don't exactly think andrew carnegie loved the little guy exactly--he was, at best, the good cop to frick's bad cop--but he at least put on the appearance of charity, decorum, civic-mindedness

>meanwhile today's elites mostly seem interested in apocalypse bunkers and sex cults and getting real jacked on testosterone and ranting about the woke mind virus

>regarding the rest of us as, at best, hogs bound for the slaughter, and not even particularly hiding it

https://bsky.app/profile/sjshancoxli.liberalcurrents.com/pos...

You can't sign away your rights like that in a contract. The contract is invalid.
What "contract"? They're referencing a meme on page 11 of the document, which looks like this: https://imgur.com/a/bSYTJb1

Are people seriously believing the Ethereum Foundation is looking for its members to commit suicide in case they don't publish full source-code? :P Either I'm massively misreading what the outrage is about, or I think this is the point I stop understanding how the world works. Are people taking that image seriously???

> The final published version presented the suicide pledge in an illustration instead of including it in the main body of the mandate, as it had been in the draft version.
ok, so I'm really curious what you think people are suppose to do in the world of "skepticism".

I mean, you've no doubt spent the last 10 years hearing about 4chan and donald trumps connection.

Just because something _could_ be considered some kind of satire, assuming we should all default to that interpretation basically dissolved the social system everywhere.

"its just a joke bro" is not a useful critical thinking skill.

> I mean, you've no doubt spent the last 10 years hearing about 4chan and donald trumps connection.

No, what is the connection?

> ok, so I'm really curious what you think people are suppose to do in the world of "skepticism".

Have an healthy amount of it, but not too much. Lagom skepticism, if you will.

> I mean, you've no doubt spent the last 10 years hearing about 4chan and donald trumps connection.

I have not, I'm not American and only follow news out of the country from afar, unless it's about Trump, then i try to avoid it.

> "its just a joke bro" is not a useful critical thinking skill.

Agreed, but being able to read the context is a useful critical thinking skill.

-----------

What does anything of this has to do with some "suicide pledge" or the Ethereum Foundation?

Read it again. It was in the contract. What skepticism do you have? What aren't you getting?
(comment deleted)
I don't understand the concept of "a meme on page 11 of [a contract]". If it's in a contract, it's part of the contract. Decorations or jokes in a legal document are... Not a thing. Or at least must not be a thing.
The image is in a binding contract. Why would I not take it seriously? Do I think they mean it? No. Would I sign it? No.

This is like the typical nonsense when you're negotiating with a company where their actual practice has diverged from their standard contracts. You point something out, and the response comes back "that's just boilerplate, we don't enforce that." OK, that's cool. If you don't enforce it then you can take it out of the contract. At no point is my response ever to say "OK, I trust you, I'll sign as-is." Even if I do trust them.

>Nearly 80 of the foundation’s 250 or so employees voted to nix the suicide pledge after the draft was released, according to the lawsuit, but leadership at the Ethereum Foundation ignored their objections and included the pledge word-for-word in the final version of the mandate.

Contacts are still contracts even if you put pictures in it. You definitely don't understand how the world works if you don't get that.

I would probably sign if all of the following are true:

- The money is significantly better than my other options

- I believe the company not to be serious about the suicide clause

- I believe the suicide clause to be non-binding in any jurisdiction that applies to myself or the foundation

- I didn't believe the company / foundation would take my refusal to kill myself at a later time as a license to have me killed

The last one is a bit out there, but in the world of crypto, you can never be too sure.

Also, regardless of whether I would sign, I think it's in pretty poor taste and a bright amber flag (but not quite a red flag) if an employer thinks this is a funny or acceptable thing to put into a contract.

It's also in very poor taste and reeks of coercion to send out a manifesto or mandate like this on a Friday and expect people to sign or agree by Monday or lose their jobs. They likely wouldn't be able to have it reviewed by a lawyer over the weekend if they chose to do so.

> Also, regardless of whether I would sign, I think it's in pretty poor taste and a bright amber flag (but not quite a red flag) if an employer thinks this is a funny or acceptable thing to put into a contract.

How is this in any way NOT a red flag? In what universe is this a neutral signal about the health of an organization that manages a significant amount of capital?

> It's also in very poor taste and reeks of coercion to send out a manifesto or mandate like this on a Friday and expect people to sign or agree by Monday or lose their jobs. They likely wouldn't be able to have it reviewed by a lawyer over the weekend if they chose to do so.

In sum total, "this sounds very very bad but not necessarily a red flag". Absurd.

Of course it's a red flag? People only ever work for cryptocurrency companies in the first place because they're scammers themselves and think they can get rich while leaving suckers holding the bag. The whole thing is a red flag from the beginning so I don't know why anyone would expect otherwise.
That a wildly unhinged take, they could just work in payments or finance lol but yes it’s a red flag and with that much at stake an insane individual would “enforce” the contract.
Unfortunately I have worked with smart, nice people who would take this contract literally, are overly invested in their jobs and would be likely to take me out - even preemptive to any order from the company - if I violated my "contract".
Playing fast and loose with the words "smart" and "nice" there.
Getting taken out by an autistic hitman with a namshub installed by a cryptocurrency company IS on my 2027 bingo card.
I dont understand why you have all these requirements. A suicide pledge in a contract is unenforceable (both socially and legally), so signing it or not doesn't really matter.
> A suicide pledge in a contract is unenforceable (both socially and legally), so signing it or not doesn't really matter.

If it doesn't matter, it shouldn't be in the contract. I don't tend to have a lot of drafting power in employment contracts, but pushing back on meaningless contract provisions is a lot easier than pushing back on substantive ones.

It's at least worth getting them on the record, in writing, as 'we absolutely insist on this (bullshit) contract provision being in here, it is required for your continued employment'.

I would be extremely wary of tying a big part of my life to a company that insists on me signing an unenforceable contract.
The one group of people that you should take literally in contracts are the Ethereum / smart contract folks. Code is law is the founding principle of Etherium!
It's worth clarifying, because you absolutely can sign away rights in a contract. You can even sign away constitutionally protected rights, like free speech. This regularly happens vis-a-vis NDA's.
> You can even sign away constitutionally protected rights, like free speech.

The text of the first amendment only asserts that "Congress shall make no law [...] abridging the freedom of speech", so signing away your ability to speak isn't in conflict with the Constitution.

to put a finer point on it, the government can't pass laws or take actions to abridge free speech.

you sure as shit can of your own volition and/or with a private company

If you go deep into the crypto world you'll find that this messaging resonates well with "degens" (as they sometimes call themselves). They love this stuff, it signals how "pilled" you are. It may or may not have to do with a large proportion of them being high on drugs (weed, psychedelics, cocaine), in addition to obviously being terminally online and bubbled.

And they often will drive millions and millions of dollars of crypto toward these ventures, often anonymously.

You have to read these kinds of things in the context of the target audience, which is very real.

Source: I made it out.

wtf I love ethereum now
> They are also extremely anti-authority

Don't say it isn't so!? The community founded on circumventing existing financial structures are anti-authority? Next you're gonna tell me anarchists don't like individual leaders, or that socialists care about healthcare.

Source: I suppose also "made it out" although it wasn't hard, I left my job, like any other industry. Worth knowing as well that the cryptocurrency ecosystem isn't nearly as "internally" aligned as some people want you to believe, there is a large range in weirdness in the ecosystem, not just what parent above shared.

> Next you're gonna tell me anarchists don't like individual leaders, or that socialists care about healthcare.

There's an irony embedded in both positions. Everyone cares about government, anarchists care about overthrowing the existing government in order to replace it with their own version. Similarly, everyone cares about healthcare, socialists care about other people paying for their healthcare.

> The community founded on circumventing existing financial structures are anti-authority?

But that's the thing; they aren't. They just want to be the authority.

Ethereum in particular has some history with that. A long time ago they espoused this principle called "code is law", and then one time the code for something called "The DAO" did something they didn't like, so they overrode the code. To this day the Ethereum consensus rules specify that a certain hardcoded transaction ID should not do what it literally says it does.
The transition from PoW to PoS is another example, espoused the open ideals of Bitcoin mining, right up until the moment they had gathered sufficient power and members, at which time they closed the gates of ascension behind them.
Hopefully we can agree that PoW is bad
I like it, literally revolutionary, to my eyes BTC owes more to PoW than Blockchain. You start seeing it everywhere, related to Taleb's skin in the game concept, or costly signaling in zoology.
How much would you increase the world's temperature by to have bitcoin?
Probably 0 if I had a choice. But is global warming a problem that is exclusive to bitcoin? Or does bitcoin highlight and accelerate an existing problem that is already a problem through other means, like car/plane emissions and AI datacenters.

Whatever solution we come up with, will work against all sources of warming or environmental damage. Although if one of those measures is banning Bitcoin mining, I wouldn't complain about it.

I think "degen" for "degenerate gambler" refers specifically to those who make wild, all-in bets without any more research than a quick scan of twitter and telegram memes. Not those who would actually parse a multi-page manifesto document.
> They are also extremely anti-authority

Alright we will see how long that lasts. If they want to enforce their “contracts” they will need a court (i.e. an authority) to order the opposite party to abide by their contract and if they don’t, police (i.e. an authority) will force them to court and enforce what the court says.

The idea with crypto is not to need courts, the court would be the "global computer", contracts (actual cryptocurrency term) are computer programs running in the Ethereum VM.

Bitcoin originally imposed this idea on payments, and Ethereum attempts to create this computational contract system for the non monetary consideration of contracts (the harder half of the contract).

>> They are also extremely anti-authority

There's a big difference between anti-authority and a-hole, knee-jerk opposition defiance disorder, but even if you're right wouldn't the people being asked to sign this contract be the last people to do so?

> You have to read these kinds of things in the context of the target audience

No, this is a legal document. You need to rip subculturally-driven context out of your mind and read it as a legal document.

I feel like it has to be a joke, but I wonder if such a clear "joke" would make other things in the contract possible to be invalidated in court given that if one assumes that part is a joke how can one tell what other parts are also supposed to be or not to be a farce in the contract.
nah, contracts sometimes even explicitly call out a severability or savings clause (where if one part is deemed illegal or unenforceable, it shouldn't impact the rest)

Contract law is surprisingly reasonable, typically focused on enforcing what people expect to be enforced and not standing on weird arcane rituals

tbf, severability clauses tend to be designed for *the rest of the contract is still valid even if clause 3b is ruled to be incompatible with state law or inconsiste with other agreements" not "the rest of the contract is still valid even if a prominent part of it so fundamentally unserious people could reasonably believe the wider document was a mission statement or joke rather than a legally binding contract".

I suspect a good lawyer in most jurisdictions could get someone out of a "breach of contract" suit by arguing their client reasonably believed that what they had signed was not actually a contract since it was decorated like a DnD manual and included an obligation to commit seppuku...

My falling out of love with crypto was due to the realization that these 'foundations' were effectively governing bodies participating in the minimum level of decentralized theater to grant them plausible deniability in a court of law. Bitcoin is still extremely interesting, as it has no such body, only a bunch of anarchy minded anti-social but very smart group of volunteers fighting each other. At least they practice their anarcho libertarian experiment in the mailing list, to its huge detriment.
EF are not the ones in charge. They have a lot of influence, to the point them rejecting a proposal can be enough to bury it, but very little hard power. Kind of like the Stroustrup and C++26 situation.

The people who actually control Ethereum are client dev teams. There are two groups, one for the execution layer that runs code and the other for the consensus layer that handles the actual blockchain part. No proposal can get marked as stable and entered into an official hard fork unless they approve it.

The foundation has no say over these decisions. In fact they decided not to make their own consensus client on purpose, to make sure everyone is running non EF controlled code after the merge. And they do everything they can to encourage client diversity. It's not perfect but you can't compare it to Tezos or Polygon where one company runs everything.

Has the EF ever pushed something that failed to gain miner/staker consensus?
This really changes the meaning of the catchphrase "HODL"
> An email to the foundation seeking comment on this story was not immediately returned Thursday, but a foundation leader at the time told employees the suicide pledge was not meant to be taken literally, according to the lawsuit. After employee pushback, managers updated the commitment form to clarify that the form had “nothing to do with literal seppuku,” according to the lawsuit.

Oh see it was just a joke - a joke, get it? ha ha, see by watching how many employees were complaining, we retracted it - just a "joke", right? after we put it out there saying nothing whatsoever and demanding a yes/no loyalty pledge.

it was boundary testing. this company should go out of business.

(comment deleted)
Where is the endorsement? I see a corporate mandate, not an employment contract.

Corporations put out all sorts of fluff. If employees took it seriously then everyone working at facebook should have a VR helmet on their head 24/7.

Employees were required to agree to the document or be fired, with only a few days to decide.
That is insane, but totally believable in modern corporate cultures. I have heard of lawfirms in the 90s organizing non-optional hunting weekends, to identify any manager not a sufficient "meat eater". I cannot imagine anyone getting away with such things today.
A weekend, told on Friday, had to decide before Monday. Absurd.
What if they changed it to something friendlier, like a pledge to drink a refreshing glass of Kool-Aid should management request as such?
Neurotics do neurotic things.

>the author, maintainer, editor or (re)distributor… shall uphold the following… to take his or her own life with a sword upon failure to uphold any of the pledges in this license, or upon modification or removal of any part of this license.

Fits with Crypto philosophy. To let working class people to die so billionaires can use crypto for tax avoidance and crime payments. Not surprised at all.
Billionaires have plenty of other means of tax avoidance; crypto gives the working class the means to avoid tax and pay for illegal things.
> working class the means to avoid tax and pay for illegal things

Peanuts. It is still the rich that spend the most in illegal things from bribes, tax evasion, etc. even for countries trying to avoid international sanctions.

The bigger the more they profit from crime and lack of accontability.

"Crypto foundation" in headline is Ethereum Foundation and I do not like them.
I'm instantly suspicious of anyone who thinks a 1000 year ~~reich~~ plan is a good idea.
Remember when this here orange website thought that Buterin was a magical super-genius, as opposed to some sort of crazy person?

Like, seriously, what the hell? Did he get jealous of all the attention the Zizians were getting or something?

Crypto is the original LLM, "do anything but improving the product", "do anything but make it better to use for regular people".

Just take the money and funnel it into useless already rich people that do crap like this and are incapable of doing anything useful

If that's your definition then I think LLMs and crypto are the exact opposite.

LLMs are helpful to regular people from the start with the ChatGPT launch.

They are both very useful to me personally but I mean to point out the people that vacuum the vast majority of the investment into those sectors.
> After demanding that employees agree to the mandate, Bastian Aue, co-executive director of the Ethereum Foundation, defended the suicide pledge to employees as “part of the artwork of the mandate.”

This is insane. Is this something like a judgment or reverse loyalty test? “If you sign something like this, you’re too dumb to stay?”

A: Do you agree to suicide pledge? B: Sure . . B: Buddy