Given the tiny size of avian brains compare to mammals, particulary humans, it's hard to ascribe a lot of intelligence to them. But for what they can do, they seem quite well optimized.
Brain size is not a decisive factor in estimating intelligence and corvid brains pack twice the neurons per volume compared to humans. The factor is: effective "Information Processing Capacity" (IPC), which is high for body size and rivals great apes on specific executive tasks.
Extreme miniaturization eliminates travel distance, giving near-zero latency and high metabolic efficiency despite 1/5th the neurons of a chimp.
if it is possible to pack more neurons into the same space, you have to wonder what sort of tradeoffs there are with such things. Nutrient efficiency? Do they have to eat proportionally more to maintain their intelligence?
Or something really weird like some emergent property of intelligence is traded off? something about connections between distant neurons being harder? Perhaps its harder for them to learn entirely novel things quickly?
I'm not sure why you get downvoted for pointing out that some people have a belief that is not shared by most other people.
Seems that some posters would rather shoot the messenger that delivers information that they don't agree with.
From interacting with domestic and wild animals for most of my life I figured out a long time ago that they understand their own world and their place in it way better than many of us understand the world we have created for ourselves.
The chicken with its head cut off saying extends beyond the south. I grew up hearing it in the Midwest. Since chickens do run around when their heads are cut off, I think anywhere with chickens would end up with this phrase.
The Always Sunny thing is more about her looks. When they call her dumb, they tend to just call her dumb/stupid/etc.
I would imagine the Dodo is a big reason for the birdbrain insult meaning dumb. Since Dodo itself can be used to mean dumb, and since they weren't afraid of humans they were easy targets and hunted to extinction. That may say more about humans than the Dodo.
> Corvids and parrots and raptors are remarkably smart, yet not every bird species is. Some are incredibly stupid.
Raptors are pretty stupid. They don't _need_ to be smart. They're solitary and they are typically apex predators.
I have a great view out of my window, and I have a family of crows living nearby. They cooperated to drive out owls and eagles that were nesting in a nearby park. Right now it's raining with pretty strong gusty winds and the crows are flying outside, doing pretty crazy aerobatics. They are clearly having a lot of fun!
That's from an anthropomorphized angle though? In their evolutionary niche, their level of expressed intelligence seems to be spot on, otherwise they'd have evolved or been outcompeted long ago.
In fact, some of those species that you might consider "incredibly stupid" may have existed long before humans and might easily outlive us if we follow some not-very-unlikely paths that we have opened up with technology and (lack of) social maturity. Who is "incredibly stupid" then?
There's some bias from how you measure intelligence but bias only goes so far.
> In their evolutionary niche, their level of expressed intelligence seems to be spot on, otherwise they'd have evolved or been outcompeted long ago.
Thinking is expensive. Being "spot on" for a niche doesn't imply much about stupid or not-stupid.
> In fact, some of those species that you might consider "incredibly stupid" may have existed long before humans and might easily outlive us if we follow some not-very-unlikely paths that we have opened up with technology and (lack of) social maturity. Who is "incredibly stupid" then?
The ones that can't figure out problems/puzzles are the ones that are stupid, using the definition everyone else in the conversation has been using.
A pigeon might be perfectly optimised for doing pigeon things, but it’s still almost as dumb as a rock, and I don’t even mean a particularly smart rock.
Chickens will run around with their heads cut off. It's the nerves going haywire after being chopped. Similar observations were made of guillotined corpses twitching after death (and heads trying to speak, but that's just until the blood runs our), human bodies are just too heavy and unbalanced to move effectively without coordination.
I think you're basically right. I might phrase it differently: the connotation of "birdbrain" to negative intelligence isn't disproven by noting quick read and react capabilities to certain problems, as intelligence is about more than that.
Some birds have impressive specializations, and corvids clearly punch above their brain mass weight due to impressive efficiencies with their brain architecture, but I think the framing of the article is more wrong than right to frame it around speedy information processing of particular problems.
Even moreso when this can be trivially disproven. Given a 'smart' human an hour to solve some cognitively intense task. Give a 'dumb' human 10 hours to do the same task. The former's results are going to be dramatically more on point.
Intelligence isn't like a computer competing on processing speed.
Though lots of humans' "slow decisions" are really just the conscious mind working hard to justify something that the fast path had already decided long ago. We are exceptional in lying to ourselves.
If the decisions are not routine then it is fast problem solving. You have to own a bird to understand that they are in fact capable of problem solving in their own universe.
From an engineering point of view their control loop must be much faster. Things that fly need much tighter loops than we do that lumber about on the ground.
Watch a bird come in fast and then land on a narrow twig.
Bird neurons are roughly half the length of mammal neurons. This means you can pack in around 8x more neurons in a given volume.
Why? There aren't very many obstacles at altitude. Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground. (Obviously, airplanes go even faster, but similarly benefit from a lack of obstacles.)
> Why? There aren't very many obstacles at altitude.
Most birds don't spend their time flying at high altitudes. Most of the time they're remarkably close to the ground, and there are lots of obstacles when you're close to he ground. Some of those are trying to avoid being eaten, and others are looking for dinner.
> Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground.
That's just within the last 150 years, and has no relevance for our evolutionary history.
I guess you may not have spent much time watching birds or other wild animals navigate their environments. Many birds routinely fly at maximum speed through trees, dodging branches, leaves, and twigs that would knock them off course and lighting suddenly on small limbs or branches that you can't even see until you are deep into the foliage. Maybe they can see them from outside the leaf envelope. It would explain how they are able to navigate such a cluttered environment in shadow at full speed. Birds may crash into window glass regularly but their innate understanding of navigation around and through natural obstacles is pretty remarkable.
Watching drone racing videos gives an idea of just how complicated the task turns out to be - flitting through narrow openings at speed and zipping around obstacles that suddenly appear. Birds were doing this millenia before anyone programmed a drone.
If I had mentioned bird swarms then I would've needed to mention by extension that fish were also just as intelligent, and gnats, and mosquitoes, and wasps, wildebeests, and bison, and on and on through the animal kingdom.
We may even need to throw in humans if one mentioned group dynamics of pedestrian swarms inside transport terminals. I'm not sure that we can say at this point that all the members of a group like that are intelligent. It seems more likely that most are minimally sentient without any understanding of why they do what they do when they do it and probably none could offer a formulaic description of how they do it that would stand up to scrutiny. I think most would just SWAG it.
I feel that swarms are easier than trees since you just have to rotate slightly for the most part, following the critter in front of you. If you bump, you correct. Trees on the other hand are much less forgiving.
Oh yeah. I feed my crow family raw peanuts in the shell. They know me and watch me when I am outside working on anything. One of them taught itself to mimic me. Each time I would put out peanuts for them I would loudly say "peanut" a couple of times. When the group wants a peanut that crow will fly over to a nearby perch and clearly say "peanut". Crows are really intelligent.
Humans actually change the environment to meet their sensory slowdowns at that sort of speed. E.g. spacing of road signs and even their size depends on the speed of the road, in anticipation of you needing more distance to make decisions at this speed, given your thinking speed didn't change.
A hummingbird on the other hand is moving with precision at its top speed in the environment as it is. It is adapted to this behavior at these speeds and maneuverability, while our lack of adaption needs that sort of sensory crutch.
Intelligence has evolved on Earth at least three times - mammals, corvids, and octopuses. All the mammals have roughly the same brain architecture. But the corvids are not on the same evolutionary branch, and have a different neuron design and a different brain architecture. "Such behavioral flexibility might seem unexpected
because a layered cerebral cortex, the highest integration
center in the mammalian brain, is not existant in birds."[1] So there's more than one way to do intelligence. Useful to know for AI purposes.
Octopuses have a much more distributed system than mammals, suggesting a quite different approach is possible.
Jumping spiders are the geniuses of their size/energy tier. It almost makes no sense that so few neurons should be so capable, but my favorite hypothesis is that nature golf coded a specially tuned, unexpectedly flexible, highly optimized recurrent architecture that sequentially overthinks to simulate a far higher intelligence level than its size profile would suggest.
Yes, and the third book, Children of a Memory, which features the corvids, is particularly interesting in the age of AI and questioning what intelligence really is.
I feel compelled to mention Peter Watts' Blindsight here. Hardest of sci fi and explores consciousness, intelligence variants and has some of the most interesting antagonists I've ever read.
Can we count mammals and corvids separately if their common ancestor was already set on the path to intelligence? The amazing book Other Minds by Peter Godfrey Smith hinges it's argument on minds evolving twice, on the fact that the common ancestor of humans and octopi was probably a simple worm-like creature that had little or nothing in the way of a brain or consciousness.
I have to imagine that corvids and mammals had a common ancestor with more working brain structure. Though maybe you can make the case that "intelligence" showing up later on isn't the same thing as simply having a brain.
But it's much more impressive to me that there's convergent evolution from brainless to brain-having, than from brains to intelligent brains. Don't get me wrong, it's still awesome but doesn't feel like an out of nowhere path for natural selection to take.
Agree. Birds still have two eyes, two arms, two legs, heart, liver, kidneys, etc. there's clearly a common ancestor after the basic vertebrate anatomy evolved.
A very important fact to remember is that brains are not a requirement for intelligence (in the very broadest sense, not the more specific one used here), nor even neurons. All cells have some amount of computational power and can meaningfully react to their environment; a common example is white blood cells quickly adapting to pathogens to try to destroy them. Networks of cells are even more powerful, such as slime mould exploring the space around it until it detects nutrients and then channeling all resources in the direction of such nutrients. Plant roots have sophisticated sensory abilities detecting numerous kinds of chemicals in the soil, and actively search for nutrients and avoid contaminants. Even jellyfish, some of the simplest animals, long thought to be essentially passive, in fact detect and actively steer themselves towards prey.
Intelligence actually exists at all levels of life, and brains are just an apex of achievement, just like eyes are an apex achievement of light-sensing mechanisms that similarly exist all around the tree of life.
Additionally, both plants and slime mold have been shown to be capable of keeping track of time elapsed in experiments, it’s so cool and bewildering (how this is done as it seems quantitatively different from other automaton like behavior that could be programmed so to speak from a layman’s perspective at least).
Superstitious humans never really gave up their believe system that we have souls. Sure, we expanded it to include non-humans, and sure, the age of science compelled people to give it a more secular label ("neurons"), but we're as superstitious as ever. We have entire quasi-religions out there masquerading as lifestyles and "just common sense", and they all rely on the neuron being special.
So it doesn't really matter that technically you are correct.
I understand what you're saying but it sounds like you know what it means to separately ask about animal intelligence in the sense relevant for evaluating, say, crows vs pidgeons, and that question obviously is not just about animals having sophisticated immune responses.
I would venture a guess that nearly all animals will turn out "intelligent" if all we really mean is they things like complex immune responses to disease, or complex coordination needed to grow an embryo. Those matter and raise profound questions about how incredible natural selection can be, but I would wait for an actual sin of commission before treating any commentary on animal intelligence like it neglects to appreciate sophisticated behavior of cells.
My point was more that intelligence is a far more incremental property than it seems at first glance. The evolution of brain-like tissue and then of the brain itself is not as surprising in light of the incredible amount of computation happening in every cell of every organism - it's just taking that further and further and further. That's why I replied to the surprise that there would be convergent evolution from brainless to brain-having.
I don't think you can single out corvids from the rest of the avians and at the same time bunch all mammals together. I don't think there's evidence that their smarts or brain architecture are qualitatively different from other birds, some of which are plenty smart. If intelligence - for some definition of intelligence - evolved separately in mammals and birds, it's not implausible to me that the basic architecture developed before avian dinosaurs branched from other theropods, and some theropods might have been quite smart indeed.
Crows are songbirds (oscine passerines) which have a similar circuit in the brain to humans (other apes don't have it). Seems to have evolved independently.
I think there are two pathways have have human similarities, a vocal motor control one and one for song learning.
From AI, but I first read about it in "Why Only Us? Language and Evolution":
> Posterior (vocal motor) pathway: HVC to RA to the brainstem, which produces the song. This is the part compared to the human laryngeal motor cortex pathway.
> Anterior forebrain pathway (AFP): Area X, the thalamic nucleus DLM, and LMAN, which handles song learning. This is the part compared to human cortico-basal ganglia-thalamic loops.
I think parrots have something different that evolved separately but with a lot of similarities too.
Only some birds are precocial, just like only some mammals are precocial. Corvid young are completely helpless upon hatching, as are most other passerines.
> Humans don't have myelinated optic nerves yet at birth and if born permature still myelinate at around the same time from conception and don't really seem to reach mental developmental milestones earlier or anything even with the earlier data, even though they can still see some things without the myelination.
Reminds me of the case of a child who stopped growing in their first year; they never developed as far as childlike, let alone adult, cognition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooke_Greenberg
You left off Parrots, which are just about as intelligent as Corvids. For example, keas have a similar number of pallial neurons to ravens (or maybe slightly more). Parrots and songbirds generally have extremely high neural density but still lower raw neuron counts compared to primates, which makes their competitiveness in many cognitive tasks interesting.
Among parrots, everyone knows African Greys but cockatoos are also highly intelligent, with goffin's cockatoos the standouts in terms of cleverness.
Which just goes to show, imo, how many more tools are necessary to become an advanced civilization. Imagine if we'd just been restricted to water and couldn't make fire, but were otherwise identical? Imagine if we didn't have thumbs, or highly articulate mouths? Imagine if we were solo creatures, or if we were too self-interested to care for the village?
Edit but as an aside, we don't even really know what intelligence is, if you ask me. We have an idea, but trying to quantify it or measure it falls short seemingly every time.
Afaik lots of birds collect and some mammals. I don’t know of any outside that, but it would not surprise me if some fish do, some have very elaborate mate attraction strategies.
We do try to quantify it in school, and it works reasonably well. Of course that is only that of humans, comparing that with other animals or AI is tricky, but I believe doable. No need to be perfect here.
Bird brains are interesting because they've dealt with a significant chunk of the energy intensity of mammalian brains. Octopus brains are interesting because brains are traditionally energy intensive and top predators are usually long lived. Octopuses have this energy intensive sunk cost but also have a short lifespan.
I wish I understood enough of the appropriate level of neuroscience to get a bit of an understanding of the similarities and differences between bird and other brains.
I’m a little frustrated with talking about birds as a class in this context. Crows are legendary for figuring things out.
Turkeys are also legendary. Like the farmer brings three of them out, crops the head of the first one off. The other two are still standing there. “Wow! Look what happened to Charley! I wonder what this line is for.”
Trauma and PTSD? Nah. They are simply bred to be stupid because smarter animals escape and/or are hard to handle.
You got a herd of whatever animals, they have 20 kids, some are hard to handle or bite or claw or try to run away, one or a few others are dumber and easy to trap or cage or are reliant upon you for food to not starve. You want to breed a second generation and eat the rest, which ones do you breed and which ones do you eat?
If take a wild version of a domesticated animal from birth or egg or whatever, they aren't going to act like your domesticated versions even if you raise them identically among each other.
I view it as more fundamental than that. Size for size, joule for joule and cm3 for cm3 a smart bird seems to get a lot more out of their brain than smart mammals. I big chunk of the determinant of intelligence is diet quality, which is why horses, cows koalas are so dumb and why koalas are so sleepy.
Living in a town with a sizable turkey population, they're also utterly oblivious to car traffic when they're in the middle of the road. It's interesting that they're smart about some things, and stupid about others.
Your turkey case necessitates beings that have been subjected to captivity and horrors all their lives.
There is almost nothing to learn about their natural instincts and behaviors from what is done to farmed animals.
We also see this with cows where we saw a cow use a tool earlier this year, and it’s obvious the only reason we thought they were incapable was because cows are completely domesticated at this point and there is no opportunity for them to do so.
It really bothers me that people think so highly of themselves and so lowly of other animals
If you ever spend any time actually observing nature rather than just assuming we are the masters of it, there is an incredible amount to learn from our animal cousins
These "stupid' "unintelligent" animals manage to survive a harsh reality of life that would kill you within days if not less
Humans really aren't that special
It's honestly incredibly egotistical, really reminiscent of religious worship
The capabilities of humans relative to animals are self evidently transcendent.
It's wrong to suggest that humans are not 'special', we obviously are, it's just that we don't have 'near species' any more to connect us in an intuitive way to the evolutionary chain.
That and 'modernization' and all of our social and civil infrastructure which disconnects us from the rest of the animal kingdom will definitely have 'the effect' of our not respecting the nuanced capabilities of other animals, but it's not as though we don't have an instinct for that either. Every human is in awe of a single feature of at least every other animal.
I think a big factor in our supposed intelligence is how well we work together in groups. If there was just one human, they definitely wouldn't be building rocket ships.
Relative to something like ants, humans rank very poorly in intrinsic cooperation. Human cooperation is probably a result of intelligence rather than the converse. Even if one is 100% self centered, a bit of intelligence can make one realize that 10 people together can do much more than 10x as much as one person alone, simply because many tasks scale up in output much more quickly than they scale up in time.
Why do you treat your neighbor better than a random person you bump into on the street or a store? Because you're much more likely to see your neighbor again. That's intelligence driving a more social behavior. This also explains the paradoxical finding about increased population density being correlated with increased loneliness and other such issues. As the number of people increases, the chances of seeing any given person repeatedly decreases, and so the cognitive drive for social connections never kicks off and people end up lonely while surrounded by more people than ever.
I wholeheartedly agree, but I also disagree. Humans are pretty special: we hurl artifacts into outer space, split atoms, and communicate instantly with the other side of the globe. At the same time, we still make fatal decisions, like texting while driving or staying on a fossil-fuel path as a climate catastrophe unfolds.
I am divided on this. Yes there's that benevolent-ever-understanding-side of me, but then there's also my critical/rational thinking.
I think contrary to your point that there's some merit in the consideration, that *there are only those abilities and skills in certain groups of living beings, that have been proven*.
I find this to be the corollary thesis, to Carl Sagan's book "The Demon-Haunted World": To not be readily-assuming that there's smarts, that there's intelligence behind lots of actions by animals.
As a consequence to this base assumption, results and findings like the above "Crows make decisions faster than we can" show great scientific advancement in my eyes.
Humans are really that special. It is hard to quantify "intelligence" but I don't think survival by itself is a good criteria, some bacteria are really good at survival, and they can hardly be called intelligent. Heck even a rock can "survive" better than I do.
But few other species on Earth has had even a small fraction of the impact we had, and I think we are the only one where it can be tied to intelligence. Maybe we can make a point for eusocial insects if we include some notion of collective intelligence, but if we focus on the individual, nothing comes close to humans.
Maybe our brain is not that special, but we have a combination of traits that make us special overall: brainpower of course, but also longevity, social structure, agile fingers, etc...
This doesn't exclude respecting other life forms, as for observing nature, we do, a good part of what we call "science" is just that. There is the obvious: biology, but also the less obvious: the big thing on HN right now is AI, AI uses neural networks, the idea of neural network came from observing nature, the nervous system of animals specifically (I am not saying LLMs are like animal brains! but they are inspired by them).
And for the "egoistical" part, well, yes, but isn't life egoistical by nature? At its core, the point of life is to make more of itself, everything else is a mean to that end.
Short-timescale intelligence does seem to be a unique human trait.
But at a system dynamics level, and considering "species" as something of an artificial construct imposed by humanity onto the teeming mess of life, the impact of oxygen-producing bacteria? Or chloroplasts, mitochondria..? Lignin-producing trees in the Carboniferous? Flowering plants, grasses, symbiotic complexes - some of them continent-spanning - that we don't even fully understand, touching on the hydrological, carbon and nutrient cycles. Fire-adapted ecosystems as a downstream product of life's redox chemistry.
"Roughly the same brain architecture" is true, but watching the processing speed in short term memory tests in chimps is quite impressive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PNrWUS13th8
Humans can also be trained in tasks like these and we improve a lot over the course of training, but my ADD banana brain for one probably won't ever get past 50-60% of what the chimp can do.
Birdbrain should mean the opposite of what it does, for this reason, but for many others. Birds can sense the Earth's magnetic field and use it for navigation, a process that's about the one bona fide quantum biological paradigm.
Their body clocks are also significantly more sophisticated and decentralized than ours.
And in the end, the physical intelligence of flight itself demands a brain that's gotta be incredibly spatially and temporally aware.
I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.
> Birds can sense the Earth's magnetic field and use it for navigation, a process that's about the one bona fide quantum biological paradigm… I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.
You can harness your somatic infrastructure to gain some senses, like magnetic field sensitivity. Some people implant small permanent magnets in a fingertip to sense magnetic field, and claim it makes the world more interesting.
Unfortunately such an implant is not itself permanent (you'd want to coat it with something safe that doesn't trigger the immune system like gold or PTFE). Also though you want to be careful around other magnets I imagine!
But you could probably wear a magnetic sensor that used something attached to your skin that you could learn to "read" intuitively. The problems are dermatalogical sensitivity from the adhesive and the inability to wear it 24/7 to make the erading really feel like a new sense. But who knows?
Right, and importantly for this context, impressive as that capability is, it does nothing to debunk or demystify bird intelligence. There are impressive capabilities built into somatic functioning, and other things carved into the structure of our biology by evolution itself but those things don't signal intelligence.
I hate popular science articles like this. Ummmmm listen sweetie, you're just ignorant and Ima police you a bit here... sit down for some really wild SCIENCEism!
You dance with your entire body. You do shift weight to parts of your foot and use toes to various extents , but the ankles, knees, thighs and waist are all more important than the feet if we're simply focusing on lower body motion.
Re: the gotcha question, because these are simplified diagrams for teaching beginners or communicating genre-informed choreographies in shorthand. Even then, nobody achieve's any dancing simply by moving their feet as the diagram depicts (and they couldn't possible do so without the rest of their body). Part of the reason for their success is that people are already familiar with dances and combine the diagram's directions with the understanding that they must achieve it with a full body vocabulary.
> For example, learning to play a piano is training the spine, not the brain. Because the feedback loop with the spine is shorter.
It may train the spine too but good luck trying to play the piano without a brain. More concretely, your eyes read the notes you like to play, your ears provide the feedback loop whether you are playing the right thing (and dynamics and interplay with other musicians in an ensemble), and you need things like planning ahead, sense of form, etc. Twiching fingers from some spine impulse is just part of playing the piano. (Besides, the latency between brain and finger muscels is insubstantial w.r.t. the time scales you need for general music playing, beyond certain nuances.)
I believe that there are fundamental architectural differences. It's possibly related to birds doing continuous breathing rather than tidal breathing like mammals, so the limit of oxygen availability is higher.
The flying lifestyle creates size constraints, and nerve conduciton distances will be shorter and that will make some sort of difference.
But dusting off some very rusty student memories, we're not really working in real time - some latencies bottom out a 5ms, but 30-100ms is more common - if I am recalling correctly.
That is going to be part of the answer, simply because birds have much smaller neurons that are more densely packed than in mammals. They are also much more energy efficient, using something like 1/3 of the energy. They also have a different neural architecture, which may also contribute.
Human brain consumes enormous amount of power. So there's huge evolutionary pressure to reduce that. If there would be obvious way to evolve into bird-like brain with significantly better energy efficiency, we would be there.
So either bird mind is restrictive in a ways we don't fully understand but crucial for our survival. Or the evolution forked too many years ago and the way our brain evolved was far from optimal, but evolution didn't find the better way for us, while for birds it was just better.
I think the only reason we can actually do things like dancing and playing of pianos is because our brains are capable of predicting the future. Maybe not very far but far enough to compensate for the end to end latency. I don't think you train your spine when you learn an instrument. I think you learn a predictive model of the world that allows you to anticipate events far enough in advance to execute correctly.
The head is too far away from all the limbs to directly control every movement, the nerve cells in the body are basically like mini brains all over, so yes, you do train your spine when you learn any physical activity. And my pet theory why some really have trouble learning dancing etc. is exactly because they try to control every movement with their brain, but this doesn't really work (I know I initially tried to learn dancing and instruments like this and that caused frustration). The fingers should learn to play automatically. So this does of course has to be in coordination with the brain and the brain needs a predictive model of the future to do the coordination right and this is also what learning means, adapting that model, but the brain cannot directly control every finger and get the timing right. The learning also happens in the nerve cells in the body, not just the brain.
Reminds me of the instruction booklet for an R/C helicopter I had once, which said to practice hovering “until your fingers [on the joysticks] move by themselves”.
Yes, and you can exploit that to play music online in real time with tools like Jamulus. The trick is to set it up to only hear yourself after the network roundtrip, so you can get in sync with other players - initially it feels very off, but once the brain adjusts for latency you can even forget it's there.
Spine? I thought it was the cerebellum (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerebellum)? Any kind of motion that you have learned so well as to be able to do it "subconsciously" (playing an instrument, riding a bicycle, walking etc.) is stored in the cerebellum. The moment I realized how important this is was back in driving school while learning to start a stick shift car from a full stop. This requires some coordination between releasing the clutch pedal and pressing the gas pedal, and my first attempts failed miserably, killing the engine. Next day it suddenly started working, because the cerebellum had taken over.
I have to agree but not just the crows.. The two parakeets that I owned as a kid were quite smart and would stir their own seeds to move the good seeds above the spent seeds with tooth pick that I had been using to scratch them. They would play with the tooth pick and grab it from each other. And they were affectionate and liked to snuggle.
They had complete trust in my family and not others. So they could tell the difference.
Another article I read recently said that Birds use anaerobic metabolism inside their eyes so that there's much less biological clutter in front of the rods and cones.
I wonder if this could also have something to do with it. The bird would presumably be sharper at spotting the pattern partly because our eyes are trying to pick it out from in the midst of other kinds of "floater" patterns that we're (very) used to filtering out
185 comments
[ 2.3 ms ] story [ 23.5 ms ] threadI don't share this belief, but the more we find out about avian intelligence, the less surprised we should be that people actually think this.
Extreme miniaturization eliminates travel distance, giving near-zero latency and high metabolic efficiency despite 1/5th the neurons of a chimp.
Or something really weird like some emergent property of intelligence is traded off? something about connections between distant neurons being harder? Perhaps its harder for them to learn entirely novel things quickly?
Its fun to wonder.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/bird-brains-have-...
Seems that some posters would rather shoot the messenger that delivers information that they don't agree with.
From interacting with domestic and wild animals for most of my life I figured out a long time ago that they understand their own world and their place in it way better than many of us understand the world we have created for ourselves.
The term implies something that feels like "dodo" or imbecile.
Corvids and parrots and raptors are remarkably smart, yet not every bird species is. Some are incredibly stupid.
There's also the anecdote (maybe just in the American South?) of a chicken running around with its head cut off.
Also think of the "Always Sunny" meme where they call Dee a "bird" all the time [1]. It's meant to mean stupid, amongst other things.
[1] https://youtu.be/60D7SN06A8M
The Always Sunny thing is more about her looks. When they call her dumb, they tend to just call her dumb/stupid/etc.
I would imagine the Dodo is a big reason for the birdbrain insult meaning dumb. Since Dodo itself can be used to mean dumb, and since they weren't afraid of humans they were easy targets and hunted to extinction. That may say more about humans than the Dodo.
You will find similar middle age tales.
Raptors are pretty stupid. They don't _need_ to be smart. They're solitary and they are typically apex predators.
I have a great view out of my window, and I have a family of crows living nearby. They cooperated to drive out owls and eagles that were nesting in a nearby park. Right now it's raining with pretty strong gusty winds and the crows are flying outside, doing pretty crazy aerobatics. They are clearly having a lot of fun!
I have never seen pigeons or seagulls do that.
But crows were not just soaring, they were diving, doing loop-de-loops, chasing each other. Something like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FIWEFaVeWfw
It's really hard to take a good video of that.
That's from an anthropomorphized angle though? In their evolutionary niche, their level of expressed intelligence seems to be spot on, otherwise they'd have evolved or been outcompeted long ago.
In fact, some of those species that you might consider "incredibly stupid" may have existed long before humans and might easily outlive us if we follow some not-very-unlikely paths that we have opened up with technology and (lack of) social maturity. Who is "incredibly stupid" then?
There's some bias from how you measure intelligence but bias only goes so far.
> In their evolutionary niche, their level of expressed intelligence seems to be spot on, otherwise they'd have evolved or been outcompeted long ago.
Thinking is expensive. Being "spot on" for a niche doesn't imply much about stupid or not-stupid.
> In fact, some of those species that you might consider "incredibly stupid" may have existed long before humans and might easily outlive us if we follow some not-very-unlikely paths that we have opened up with technology and (lack of) social maturity. Who is "incredibly stupid" then?
The ones that can't figure out problems/puzzles are the ones that are stupid, using the definition everyone else in the conversation has been using.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_Chicken_Heads
Some birds have impressive specializations, and corvids clearly punch above their brain mass weight due to impressive efficiencies with their brain architecture, but I think the framing of the article is more wrong than right to frame it around speedy information processing of particular problems.
Intelligence isn't like a computer competing on processing speed.
Some just have better instincts than others.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46810027?
Watch a bird come in fast and then land on a narrow twig.
Bird neurons are roughly half the length of mammal neurons. This means you can pack in around 8x more neurons in a given volume.
Most birds don't spend their time flying at high altitudes. Most of the time they're remarkably close to the ground, and there are lots of obstacles when you're close to he ground. Some of those are trying to avoid being eaten, and others are looking for dinner.
> Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground.
That's just within the last 150 years, and has no relevance for our evolutionary history.
Watching drone racing videos gives an idea of just how complicated the task turns out to be - flitting through narrow openings at speed and zipping around obstacles that suddenly appear. Birds were doing this millenia before anyone programmed a drone.
We may even need to throw in humans if one mentioned group dynamics of pedestrian swarms inside transport terminals. I'm not sure that we can say at this point that all the members of a group like that are intelligent. It seems more likely that most are minimally sentient without any understanding of why they do what they do when they do it and probably none could offer a formulaic description of how they do it that would stand up to scrutiny. I think most would just SWAG it.
And don’t forget that crows can remember faces and not only hold a grudge but pass it on to other crows.
A hummingbird on the other hand is moving with precision at its top speed in the environment as it is. It is adapted to this behavior at these speeds and maneuverability, while our lack of adaption needs that sort of sensory crutch.
Hens/chickens are usually synonymous with "not very bright". Crows and ravens are usually depicted as smart and cunning.
Octopuses have a much more distributed system than mammals, suggesting a quite different approach is possible.
[1] https://niederlab.org/Nieder%20(2017)%20COBS.pdf
And I've read a lot.
I have to imagine that corvids and mammals had a common ancestor with more working brain structure. Though maybe you can make the case that "intelligence" showing up later on isn't the same thing as simply having a brain.
But it's much more impressive to me that there's convergent evolution from brainless to brain-having, than from brains to intelligent brains. Don't get me wrong, it's still awesome but doesn't feel like an out of nowhere path for natural selection to take.
Intelligence actually exists at all levels of life, and brains are just an apex of achievement, just like eyes are an apex achievement of light-sensing mechanisms that similarly exist all around the tree of life.
So it doesn't really matter that technically you are correct.
I would venture a guess that nearly all animals will turn out "intelligent" if all we really mean is they things like complex immune responses to disease, or complex coordination needed to grow an embryo. Those matter and raise profound questions about how incredible natural selection can be, but I would wait for an actual sin of commission before treating any commentary on animal intelligence like it neglects to appreciate sophisticated behavior of cells.
I think there are two pathways have have human similarities, a vocal motor control one and one for song learning.
From AI, but I first read about it in "Why Only Us? Language and Evolution":
> Posterior (vocal motor) pathway: HVC to RA to the brainstem, which produces the song. This is the part compared to the human laryngeal motor cortex pathway.
> Anterior forebrain pathway (AFP): Area X, the thalamic nucleus DLM, and LMAN, which handles song learning. This is the part compared to human cortico-basal ganglia-thalamic loops.
I think parrots have something different that evolved separately but with a lot of similarities too.
Reminds me of the case of a child who stopped growing in their first year; they never developed as far as childlike, let alone adult, cognition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooke_Greenberg
I'm assuming they need the wood chips for a nest or something.
I don't know anything about goldfinch intelligence but they've definitely got me running around!
Among parrots, everyone knows African Greys but cockatoos are also highly intelligent, with goffin's cockatoos the standouts in terms of cleverness.
Edit but as an aside, we don't even really know what intelligence is, if you ask me. We have an idea, but trying to quantify it or measure it falls short seemingly every time.
i guess i misremembered,
https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-collected-deep-sea-r...
they oxidized in the lab, maybe they're not shiny or curious enough of an object to be collected?
what animals perform collection?
Don't worry. We're getting there.
I think we do know that actually, but we tend to conflate it with perceived usefulness and that distorts our understanding.
1. Intelligence has evolved on Earth at least three times - mammals, corvids, and octopuses.
2. You left off Parrots
3. Also toothed whales.
Toothed whales were not left off the list.
I wish I understood enough of the appropriate level of neuroscience to get a bit of an understanding of the similarities and differences between bird and other brains.
Turkeys are also legendary. Like the farmer brings three of them out, crops the head of the first one off. The other two are still standing there. “Wow! Look what happened to Charley! I wonder what this line is for.”
Humans placed in similar situations would certainly be suffering and are also pliable in similar ways.
Genetics + epigenetics (environment).
You got a herd of whatever animals, they have 20 kids, some are hard to handle or bite or claw or try to run away, one or a few others are dumber and easy to trap or cage or are reliant upon you for food to not starve. You want to breed a second generation and eat the rest, which ones do you breed and which ones do you eat?
If take a wild version of a domesticated animal from birth or egg or whatever, they aren't going to act like your domesticated versions even if you raise them identically among each other.
There is almost nothing to learn about their natural instincts and behaviors from what is done to farmed animals.
We also see this with cows where we saw a cow use a tool earlier this year, and it’s obvious the only reason we thought they were incapable was because cows are completely domesticated at this point and there is no opportunity for them to do so.
https://youtu.be/ubE9hjrsHmI
If you ever spend any time actually observing nature rather than just assuming we are the masters of it, there is an incredible amount to learn from our animal cousins
These "stupid' "unintelligent" animals manage to survive a harsh reality of life that would kill you within days if not less
Humans really aren't that special
It's honestly incredibly egotistical, really reminiscent of religious worship
It's wrong to suggest that humans are not 'special', we obviously are, it's just that we don't have 'near species' any more to connect us in an intuitive way to the evolutionary chain.
That and 'modernization' and all of our social and civil infrastructure which disconnects us from the rest of the animal kingdom will definitely have 'the effect' of our not respecting the nuanced capabilities of other animals, but it's not as though we don't have an instinct for that either. Every human is in awe of a single feature of at least every other animal.
It has nothing to do with 'religious worship'.
Why do you treat your neighbor better than a random person you bump into on the street or a store? Because you're much more likely to see your neighbor again. That's intelligence driving a more social behavior. This also explains the paradoxical finding about increased population density being correlated with increased loneliness and other such issues. As the number of people increases, the chances of seeing any given person repeatedly decreases, and so the cognitive drive for social connections never kicks off and people end up lonely while surrounded by more people than ever.
We invented external memory. That was the game changer, because it allowed cumulative development and delayed transfer + validation of knowledge.
Being able to read what one of the smartest humans in history wrote centuries ago is quite a trick.
As is being able to read what various live humans wrote minutes/hours/months ago from different locations on different continents.
I think contrary to your point that there's some merit in the consideration, that *there are only those abilities and skills in certain groups of living beings, that have been proven*.
I find this to be the corollary thesis, to Carl Sagan's book "The Demon-Haunted World": To not be readily-assuming that there's smarts, that there's intelligence behind lots of actions by animals. As a consequence to this base assumption, results and findings like the above "Crows make decisions faster than we can" show great scientific advancement in my eyes.
Now I wonder what's your opinion.
But few other species on Earth has had even a small fraction of the impact we had, and I think we are the only one where it can be tied to intelligence. Maybe we can make a point for eusocial insects if we include some notion of collective intelligence, but if we focus on the individual, nothing comes close to humans.
Maybe our brain is not that special, but we have a combination of traits that make us special overall: brainpower of course, but also longevity, social structure, agile fingers, etc...
This doesn't exclude respecting other life forms, as for observing nature, we do, a good part of what we call "science" is just that. There is the obvious: biology, but also the less obvious: the big thing on HN right now is AI, AI uses neural networks, the idea of neural network came from observing nature, the nervous system of animals specifically (I am not saying LLMs are like animal brains! but they are inspired by them).
And for the "egoistical" part, well, yes, but isn't life egoistical by nature? At its core, the point of life is to make more of itself, everything else is a mean to that end.
But at a system dynamics level, and considering "species" as something of an artificial construct imposed by humanity onto the teeming mess of life, the impact of oxygen-producing bacteria? Or chloroplasts, mitochondria..? Lignin-producing trees in the Carboniferous? Flowering plants, grasses, symbiotic complexes - some of them continent-spanning - that we don't even fully understand, touching on the hydrological, carbon and nutrient cycles. Fire-adapted ecosystems as a downstream product of life's redox chemistry.
Don't underestimate life, I guess.
Humans can also be trained in tasks like these and we improve a lot over the course of training, but my ADD banana brain for one probably won't ever get past 50-60% of what the chimp can do.
Thank you for sharing.
Speed is not necessarily always a good thing. Deep contemplation is usually much preferred over spotting the ripest banana first.
https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adp3411
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2021.04.039
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32973004/
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2026.116926
(And Pluto is a planet!)
Their body clocks are also significantly more sophisticated and decentralized than ours.
And in the end, the physical intelligence of flight itself demands a brain that's gotta be incredibly spatially and temporally aware.
I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.
You can harness your somatic infrastructure to gain some senses, like magnetic field sensitivity. Some people implant small permanent magnets in a fingertip to sense magnetic field, and claim it makes the world more interesting.
Unfortunately such an implant is not itself permanent (you'd want to coat it with something safe that doesn't trigger the immune system like gold or PTFE). Also though you want to be careful around other magnets I imagine!
But you could probably wear a magnetic sensor that used something attached to your skin that you could learn to "read" intuitively. The problems are dermatalogical sensitivity from the adhesive and the inability to wear it 24/7 to make the erading really feel like a new sense. But who knows?
Ugh.
For example, learning to play a piano is training the spine, not the brain. Because the feedback loop with the spine is shorter.
It's the same with dancing. One is trained to not look at one's feet, because the feedback loop is too slow.
And playing a musical instrument like piano depends heavily on interactive processes throughout the brain and PNS
What do you dance with, then, and why there are step diagrams (with lines and little shoe prints) for classical dances?
Re: the gotcha question, because these are simplified diagrams for teaching beginners or communicating genre-informed choreographies in shorthand. Even then, nobody achieve's any dancing simply by moving their feet as the diagram depicts (and they couldn't possible do so without the rest of their body). Part of the reason for their success is that people are already familiar with dances and combine the diagram's directions with the understanding that they must achieve it with a full body vocabulary.
It may train the spine too but good luck trying to play the piano without a brain. More concretely, your eyes read the notes you like to play, your ears provide the feedback loop whether you are playing the right thing (and dynamics and interplay with other musicians in an ensemble), and you need things like planning ahead, sense of form, etc. Twiching fingers from some spine impulse is just part of playing the piano. (Besides, the latency between brain and finger muscels is insubstantial w.r.t. the time scales you need for general music playing, beyond certain nuances.)
I think you missed the point.
The brain is the general, the spine is the sergeant.
The flying lifestyle creates size constraints, and nerve conduciton distances will be shorter and that will make some sort of difference.
But dusting off some very rusty student memories, we're not really working in real time - some latencies bottom out a 5ms, but 30-100ms is more common - if I am recalling correctly.
So either bird mind is restrictive in a ways we don't fully understand but crucial for our survival. Or the evolution forked too many years ago and the way our brain evolved was far from optimal, but evolution didn't find the better way for us, while for birds it was just better.
I saw an article about it years ago.
Humans can make decisions and an action in less than 125 ms for very fast people.
[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25938481-the-genius-of-b...
They had complete trust in my family and not others. So they could tell the difference.
Intelligence is not about some IQ test.
I wonder if this could also have something to do with it. The bird would presumably be sharper at spotting the pattern partly because our eyes are trying to pick it out from in the midst of other kinds of "floater" patterns that we're (very) used to filtering out
The "journalist" just really wanted to make article out of "smol brain processes faster"